Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast

John Lepp ’s agency recently doubled a client’s direct mail revenue. Then the client fired them, because the marketing team didn’t like how the appeal looked. That story captures the gap between what looks good and what actually raises money, and John has spent nearly 30 years on the right side of it. In this episode, the co-founder of Agents of Good explains why there’s no room for being clever i...

Every nonprofit has a list of local corporations that should be giving. Jeff Serrano has spent 34 years in the corporate lane of fundraising, and he’d like you to delete that word from your vocabulary. Jeff is the founder and president of 360 Corporate Engagement Consulting . Before that, he led corporate engagement for the American Cancer Society, the American Heart Association, the Dallas Museum...

Most organizations treat a capital campaign like a marathon. Holly Kessler’s team treated theirs like a sprint, and they’re about to cross the finish line on a $1.1 million goal with a staff you could fit in a minivan. Holly is the Director of Community Engagement at Forsyth Jail and Prison Ministries in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. The ministry has served the county jail and a state work-releas...

Every fundraiser I know obsess over the ask. My buddy Ted Draper obsesses over everything that comes before the ask , and that’s how his team helped take Biblica ’s major gifts revenue from about $12 million to more than $30 million. Ted is the Vice President of Strategic Engagements at Biblica, the ministry that stewards the New International Version (NIV) of the Bible and works with roughly 150...

Dr. Clark Dickerson has led more than 250 capital campaigns over 40 years. Every one of them has rested on the same three principles: * God is the owner of all * We’re stewards and not owners * We’re blessed to bless others In this episode, Andrew sits down with Clark Dickerson , the co-founder of DickersonBakker to talk about his new book, Growing into Generosity: God’s Call to Greater Financial...

This might be the most important information you hear today for your nonprofit’s growth. The majority of wealth in the U.S. is held outside of cash, in other assets like stock, 401k’s, IRA’s, real estate, and closely held business interests. But nearly every nonprofit I’ve encountered (and at this point, that’s thousands ) are focused on asking donors to write them a check or give by credit card....

Justin Wheeler , Founder/CEO of Funraise and I talking about the realities of activating major giving behavior through high-touch direct mail outreach. Get full access to The Rainmaker Fundraising Newsletter at rainmakerfundraising.substack.com/subscribe

Every fundraiser on the planet has, at some point, wished they could have a prep conversation with a donor before they actually sit in front of them to make an ask of any kind.  But that’s silly. That’s not possible. Instead, most of us settled for half-baked role playing with a colleague from time-to-time.  And that was helpful. Sort of. But it was never exactly what we needed. It was never diale...

Every fundraiser on the planet has, at some point, wished they could have a prep conversation with a donor before they actually sit in front of them to make an ask of any kind.  But that’s silly. That’s not possible. Instead, most of us settled for half-baked role playing with a colleague from time-to-time.  And that was helpful. Sort of. But it was never exactly what we needed. It was never diale...

“How are you?” Simple question, right?  If you lead a nonprofit organization, a ministry, or work inside one, this probably feels like a loaded question. A trap, if you will.  What we all know, but what so few are willing to admit, is that burnout is at an all-time high in our sector. As Nathan LaGrange, Executive Director at Oasis Rest International says, leaders don’t set out in their careers to...

“How are you?” Simple question, right?  If you lead a nonprofit organization, a ministry, or work inside one, this probably feels like a loaded question. A trap, if you will.  What we all know, but what so few are willing to admit, is that burnout is at an all-time high in our sector. As Nathan LaGrange, Executive Director at Oasis Rest International says, leaders don’t set out in their careers to...

With access to clean water remaining a pressing issue in our world, charity: water stands out as a beacon of innovation and change. Brady Josephson, VP of Marketing and Growth (and a semi-regular guest on The Rainmaker show), shares insights into how the organization is transforming the way it engages with the world, driven by a relentless mission to provide clean water to every person on the plan...

With access to clean water remaining a pressing issue in our world, charity: water stands out as a beacon of innovation and change. Brady Josephson, VP of Marketing and Growth (and a semi-regular guest on The Rainmaker show), shares insights into how the organization is transforming the way it engages with the world, driven by a relentless mission to provide clean water to every person on the plan...

Should you invest in branding, OR, should you invest in fundraising?  What creates greater impact for your cause?  The answer often depends on who you ask. There are plenty of fundraising consultants who will tell you that investing in brand is a useless exercise, and all you need to do to be successful is invest in fundraising. Buy more direct mail. Spend more on paid ad programs. Hire more consu...

Should you invest in branding, OR, should you invest in fundraising?  What creates greater impact for your cause?  The answer often depends on who you ask. There are plenty of fundraising consultants who will tell you that investing in brand is a useless exercise, and all you need to do to be successful is invest in fundraising. Buy more direct mail. Spend more on paid ad programs. Hire more consu...

Do you know the 7 key donor performance metrics that drive organizational fundraising success in your nonprofit?  My friends Gabe Cooper and Carly Berna from Virtuous help us dig into those KPI trends in this conversation about the Virtuous 2025 Nonprofit Benchmarking Report. Some of the insights we cover in this conversation include: The importance of donor retention, and the key difference betwe...

Do you know the 7 key donor performance metrics that drive organizational fundraising success in your nonprofit?  My friends Gabe Cooper and Carly Berna from Virtuous help us dig into those KPI trends in this conversation about the Virtuous 2025 Nonprofit Benchmarking Report. Some of the insights we cover in this conversation include: The importance of donor retention, and the key difference betwe...

Do you know what sets the most generous fundraisers apart from the rest? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson sits down with David Duxbury, Major Gift Officer at Hammer Residences, to explore the transformative power of generosity. David shares his personal journey from growing up in poverty to becoming a passionate advocate for donor impact. Together, they discuss th...

Do you know what sets the most generous fundraisers apart from the rest? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson sits down with David Duxbury, Major Gift Officer at Hammer Residences, to explore the transformative power of generosity. David shares his personal journey from growing up in poverty to becoming a passionate advocate for donor impact. Together, they discuss th...

What does it really take to become a great fundraising organization? In this powerful episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson is joined by Alan Clayton, author of Great Fundraising Organizations and founder of Revolutionise. Together, they explore what separates thriving nonprofits from those that struggle, why fundraising success starts with leadership, and how to run two disti...

What does it really take to become a great fundraising organization? In this powerful episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson is joined by Alan Clayton, author of Great Fundraising Organizations and founder of Revolutionise. Together, they explore what separates thriving nonprofits from those that struggle, why fundraising success starts with leadership, and how to run two disti...

Is your nonprofit leaving long-term donor value on the table? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson talks with Dave Raley, founder of Imago Consulting and author of The Rise of Sustainable Giving. Dave explains how the subscription economy is reshaping recurring giving and why many organizations fail to treat sustainers as the long-term partners they are. They explore...

Is your nonprofit leaving long-term donor value on the table? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson talks with Dave Raley, founder of Imago Consulting and author of The Rise of Sustainable Giving. Dave explains how the subscription economy is reshaping recurring giving and why many organizations fail to treat sustainers as the long-term partners they are. They explore...

Are you telling stories that truly inspire donor action? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson talks with Tayloe Clements, Director of Digital Marketing at Barna Group and host of the Mission Money podcast. Tayloe shares her journey from filmmaker to nonprofit strategist and breaks down five key elements of compelling storytelling. She explains why conflict and transfo...

Are you telling stories that truly inspire donor action? In this episode of the Rainmaker Fundraising Podcast, Andrew Olson talks with Tayloe Clements, Director of Digital Marketing at Barna Group and host of the Mission Money podcast. Tayloe shares her journey from filmmaker to nonprofit strategist and breaks down five key elements of compelling storytelling. She explains why conflict and transfo...