Jay and Jack: The Whole Enchilada

A pardon in the castle? Fruitgate comes to an end. Send feedback to tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “The Traitors S5 Ep 8” on Spreaker.

Amanda, Shandy, and Colleen are joined by Matt, Drake, Greg, and J.P. for their annual Halloween party. Amanda and Colleen recap their 20th college reunion weekend and they read real-life paranormal anecdotes. Happy Halloween! Feedback: TheBroadcasters3@gmail.com or 331-BROADS3 (331-276-2373) Links: Merchandise, Matt’s Broadcast Book Club (Updated link) Subscribe (MP3) | Become a Patron...

This week’s episode kicks off with TV talk as well as a discussion about hiking movies like Tenzing. The gang also talks about the death of Sir Patrick Stewart, Godzilla (You have one week to watch Godzilla Minus One), and To End All Wars. Should Chris watch Mad Men?
There’s also an all-new Meme Game! Finally, […]

The merge is imminent, but before then, another castaway goes home. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “Survivor 51 Ep. 6 "I Love Crying"” on Spreaker.

On this week’s episode, Colleen recaps the 2026 Meet-up Weekend. All’s fair in war and Card’s Against Humanity! Then the man who lives inside the Broads’ fingers talk about Halloween-ish movies, including Backrooms, Muppet’s Treasure Island, and Practical Magic 2. We’re sailing for adventure on the deep blue wet thing. Our Margaritas bring all the […]

On this week’s episode, there’s some football talk: The San Diego Colts? Someone is getting a license renewal. Chris discusses The Diplomat and Small Prophets, Nick talks about East of Eden and The Point, and Matt watched Over the Garden Wall. They also discuss old school beers and some music. Finally, there’s an all-new Witchy […]

The boy who cried fruit. Send feedback to tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “The Traitors_ Season 5 Episode 7” on Spreaker.

Twists abound as two castaways are voted off the island. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “Survivor 51 Ep. 5 "Not Here to Get a Pedicure"” on Spreaker.

We’re back after a week off! Chris talks about his daughter’s hat trick and a lot of hiking while Jack talks about his grandkids. We talk a little bit about Ted Lasso and dinosaurs! There’s also an all-new Meme Game, where, of course, we get sidebarred by many things. Lastly, we talk some Lanterns, the […]

Come join us, faithfuls. It’s time to discuss FRUITGATE. Send feedback to tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “The Traitors S5 Ep 6” on Spreaker.

Welcome to part two! This episode picks up where 11.14 left off. The Broads read a crazy Buzzfeed post about meeting a real-life murderer, respond to feedback, and more. We’re talking about Muppet Treasure Island, Pan’s Labyrinth, Practical Magic 2, and more next week! Send in your feedback! Feedback: TheBroadcasters3@gmail.com or 331-BROADS3 (331-276-2373) Links: Merchandise, […...

This episode is split into two parts! On part one, the Broads talk about the latest Pope Leo news, the Kelly Clarkson Brooklyn art store drama, community(!), measuring time in pre- and post-Covid terms, and more. Colleen reports on what social media is like without the Russian bots. Stay tuned for part two! Feedback: TheBroadcasters3@gmail.com […]

Two tribes become three and Survivor fandom collectively groans. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “Survivor 51 Ep. 4 "That's the Magic of Survivor"” on Spreaker.

Shandy had a Montana Adventure! Pope Leo goes after AI. The Broads clear the cache before Colleen gets to her creepy Halloween-related topics with the long-awaited divorce attorney secrets BuzzFeed post. Feedback: TheBroadcasters3@gmail.com or 331-BROADS3 (331-276-2373) Links: Merchandise, Matt’s Broadcast Book Club (Updated link) Subscribe (MP3) | Become a Patron Listen to “Ep. 1...

The Tally the Votes crew discusses the latest castle murder. Send feedback to tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “The Traitors S5 Ep 5” on Spreaker.

Aspiring Survivor Contestant John Way joins the Tally the Votes group to discuss his quest to be cast on the show. Episode 3 is also discussed. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “Survivor Season 51_ Episode 3_ Tally the Votes” on Spreaker.

This week’s RCAD has a special guest!!! Chris discusses hiking, and they get into the dangers of A.I. They recount the infamous “Hot Dog Story”…the myth and legend. Matt does a robot-themed Meme Game. Lastly, they talk about Shoresy, Dungeon Crawler Carl, and Ted Lasso. Become a Patron at JayandJack.com Write us an email at […]

If a tree changes color in Montana and nobody sees it, was there even a tree? Amanda, Shandy, and Colleen talk about the Jack Smith hearings mix-up, Gen Z problems vs. “everybody” problems, what it means to consume media, The New York Times’ list of Top 100 TV series of the 2000s, and more. Feedback: […]

The winner of Big Brother 28 is crowned. Join us to discuss the season. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “Big Brother 28: Season Finale” on Spreaker.

Reward challenges return. The weirdest tribal strategy ever is tried. Jack and Colleen are taking this season off, but the Tally the Votes crew is here to bring you awesome Survivor coverage. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “TTV: Survivor 51 Ep. 2 "Weaponized Honesty"” on Spreaker.

Kiss the clock, it’s episode 11.11, and the Broads are back after a week off. On this week’s ep, Amanda, Shandy, and Colleen talk about the Mandela Effect, Gen Z taking iced coffees to job interviews, and have a follow-up talk about their 9/11 discussion. Feedback: TheBroadcasters3@gmail.com or 331-BROADS3 (331-276-2373) Links: Merchandise, Matt’s Broadcast Book […]

Once banished, twice killed, and an accomplice enters the turret. Send feedback to tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Listen to “The Traitors S5 Eps. 3 & 4” on Spreaker.

On this week’s show, Chris shares about hiking, which morphs into Crawler Carl, and Matt recommends SNL UK. Jack and Chris match wits on a band-related Meme game, with Nick showing up just after to catch up with the guys after a couple weeks of travel. Tune in next week for a possible guest! Become […]

Two houseguests go home, and only the Final Three remain. Send us an email at tallythefeedback@yahoo.com. Listen to “Big Brother 28: Eps 36-39” on Spreaker.

Survivor is back for Season 51! A season of permanent uncertainty begins as 21 people are marooned in Fiji. Jack and Colleen are taking this season off, but the Tally the Votes crew is here to bring you awesome Survivor coverage. Feedback: tallythefeedback@yahoo.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayandjack Listen to “Survivor 51 Ep. 1 "Permanent Uncertainty"” on Spreaker.