Doubt In The Details

In this series, we revisit the events inside the neonatal unit at the Countess of Chester Hospital, where a pattern of sudden collapses and unexplained deaths began to emerge. It looks at the early timeline of the Lucy Letby case, including the first infant deaths, the concerns raised by doctors, and the wider pressures on the neonatal unit. It considers how medical records, staff accounts, hospit...

In April 1989, the small community of Lakeville, Indiana woke to a crime that shattered its sense of safety. Inside the Pelley family home, four people were found dead. The murders would become one of the most debated cases in the Indiana’s history. Detectives took immediate interest in Jeff, the son. “Jeff was the only one unaccounted for. That made him our starting point.” Cold case investigator...

Tamla Horsford, a 40‑year‑old mother of five, attends a birthday sleepover in Forsyth County, Georgia, and never makes it home. When she is found dead the next morning, the investigation that follows raises immediate concerns: conflicting statements, missing photographs, uncollected evidence and a timeline that never quite holds together. In this episode, we examine the investigation, the inconsis...

What began as a series of infant deaths, became one of Australia’s infamous murder cases in 2003. Kathleen Folbigg was once labelled Australia’s worst female serial killer. But two decades later, science exposed a very different truth. A story of grief, genetics, and a justice system struggling to keep pace with emerging science. Sources:  Report of the Inquiry into the convictions of Kathleen Meg...

Part Two examines that aftermath: the police statements released in the immediate hours after the shooting, the contradictions that emerged, and the legal and institutional consequences that followed. We’ll look at the investigations, the inquest, and the long fight Jean’s family faced as they tried to understand how an innocent man could be killed by the police and why no individual officer was e...

This is the story of how an innocent man was followed into a crowded train where he was fatally shot in front of multiple witnesses. In the tense weeks after the 7/7 London bombings, the city was on edge. Police were operating at the highest threat level the UK had ever seen, racing to identify the men behind a second wave of attempted attacks. In this atmosphere of fear and urgency, a surveillanc...

In 2002, a house fire in Zeeland, Michigan leaves 14-year-old Robin Boes dead. Within hours, investigators suspect arson and attention turns to her mother, Karen Boes. After a 10-hour interrogation and a failed polygraph, Karen confesses. But she repeatedly says she doesn’t remember starting the fire. 24 years later, in 2026, the question remains: Did Karen Boes kill her daughter — or was she brok...