True Crime Creepers

Reddit is an endless archive of humanity’s most disturbing, bizarre, and deeply human stories. If you love going down internet rabbit holes, you are going to love Crimes of Reddit with Alexis Linkletter and Sabrina Deana-Roga. Every Tuesday, one host brings a set of true-crime stories while the other reacts in real time with no prep, no spoilers asking the questions on everyone’s mind. They pull a...

“I killed Taunja Bennett.” The words appeared on a bathroom wall, after two convictions and the closure of the case. Then came another confession. And another. Each raised new questions about what really happened to Taunja and whether the people behind bars were guilty at all. As investigators revisited the case, the evidence they thought they understood began to unravel, forcing them to confront...

When 23-year-old Taunja Bennett disappeared from Portland, Oregon, her family feared the worst. Days later, her body was discovered in the Columbia River Gorge, brutally murdered and left hidden along an isolated road. Then investigators received a tip naming a suspect. What followed was a disturbing investigation filled with accusations and eventually confessions that led to two convictions. Even...

In the early hours of New Year’s morning, Morgan Metzer was attacked in her own home by a masked intruder. She was beaten, bound, and left terrified that she would not survive the night. As detectives investigate, disturbing clues begin to emerge. The closer they get to the truth, the more questions they uncover. Who was the masked attacker? Why was Morgan targeted? And how did the intruder know s...

In 2010, a silent 911 call from Monica Schmeyer’s Pennsylvania home led police to a shocking discovery: Monica had been murdered. At first, investigators focused on her ex-husband, but the case fell apart. Regrouping, the detectives uncovered a chilling connection between a circle of friends, seemingly harmless conversations, and private details about Monica’s life. The investigation that followed...

Twenty-five-year-old Shanquella Robinson traveled to Cabo with friends for a birthday celebration. She never made it home. Her family was told she died from alcohol poisoning, until an autopsy raised questions and a disturbing video surfaced. Two countries. Conflicting autopsies. An arrest warrant. A federal investigation. Years without answers. For Shanquella’s family, this isn’t about headlines....

David and Shawna Scott had built a happy life in a close-knit Kentucky community, surrounded by family and the grandchildren they adored. Then Frances Zaayer moved across the street. What began as a simple act of kindness became a nightmare of harassment, accusations, and relentless police calls. Slowly, Frances began taking away their sense of safety, and tearing their family apart. The Scotts tr...

On a stormy Mother’s Day morning in 2019, a 911 call sends first responders to a secluded property in Milledgeville, Georgia. What they expect to find is a drowning victim in a hot tub. What they actually discover is a scene so bizarre that almost nothing about it makes sense. Dr. Marianne Shockley, a beloved University of Georgia professor, pioneering entomologist, and passionate advocate for the...

Originally released 1/18/2024, but for the first time here are parts 1 and 2 together in one episode! December 20, 2019 is when the world became aware of Lori Vallow after police in Rexberg, Idaho sent out a news release reporting two missing siblings: 7 year old JJ Vallow and 17 year old Tylee Ryan. The story quickly made national news when it was revealed that their mother, Lori, had fled to Haw...

Originally published on our Patreon on 6/22/26. We usually wouldn't release episodes so recent from the vault, but this was a very special one! This week, Mogab is telling the story! We're heading to the heart of Kentucky horse country for a case involving wealth, power, and murder. Seventeen-year-old Jessica Whitaker seemed to have it all. The daughter of one of the most prominent families in the...

Originally posted on our Patreon 12/16/2024 Alison Botha is an incredible survivor from South Africa whose story is nothing short of unbelievable. In 1994, she endured a brutal attack Alison Botha is an incredible survivor from South Africa whose story is nothing short of unbelievable. In 1994, she endured a brutal attack where she was kidnapped, assaulted, and left for dead by two men. Against al...

We're on our break, so we're busting some episodes out of the vault! Originally posted on our Patreon 4/21/2026. When Nikki agreed to help a neighbor with a simple favor - a late-night drive to pick up some family members - she never imagined it would e When Nikki agreed to help a neighbor with a simple favor - a late-night drive to pick up some family members - she never imagined it would end wit...

Heather Morgan wanted to be famous. Years before the world knew her as Razzlekhan—the self-proclaimed "Crocodile of Wall Street" and creator of some truly unforgettable rap videos—she built a career as an entrepreneur, writer, and startup founder. Alongside her husband, Ilya "Dutch" Lichtenstein, she cultivated a quirky online persona that seemed more cringe than criminal. But behind the scenes, f...

In 1998, 6 year old Brooke Sutton survived a brutal attack that left her grandmother, Judy Johnson, dead. When Brooke identified her Uncle Clarence as the attacker, police quickly built their case around him, and despite a complete lack of physical evidence, he was convicted and sent to prison for life. But one person refused to believe the verdict: Judy's daughter, Melinda. As appeals failed and...

When Peggy Carr suddenly became violently ill in October 1988, doctors were baffled. She complained of excruciating pain in her feet, began losing weight at an alarming rate, and eventually slipped into a coma. Then other members of her family started showing the same mysterious symptoms. As panic spread through their small Florida community, investigators discovered the family had been exposed to...

In February 2005, Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone Jr. left a bar on Philadelphia’s South Street after a fun night out with friends — and were never seen again. Even more bizarre? Richard’s massive black Dodge Dakota truck vanished with them, without leaving behind a single trace. What began as a missing persons case quickly spiraled into one of Philadelphia’s most baffling mysteries. Investigato...

This week, we’re heading deep into the Alaskan wilderness to cover one of the most chilling mass murders in the state’s history — the 1983 McCarthy massacre. McCarthy wasn’t just remote… it was practically off the grid entirely. A tiny community tucked inside Wrangell-St. Elias National Park where residents crossed icy rivers by hand-powered tram, recognized each other by boot prints in the snow,...

Jason Young was three hours away when his wife was murdered. Receipts, surveillance footage, phone records—on paper, everything checks out. He was exactly where he said he was. But the more investigators dig in, the more that story starts to fall apart. There’s a gap in the timeline no one can fully explain. A security camera that was tampered with. A strange stop at a gas station that raises more...

A routine favor turns into a nightmare. When Meredith Fisher agrees to stop by her sister’s house, something feels off the moment she arrives—lights on in the middle of the day, a dog whining inside, a door that won’t open. What she finds upstairs will haunt her forever: a brutal crime scene, her sister dead, and a child left behind in the aftermath. As investigators begin to piece together what h...

What starts as a messy love triangle and a drunken fight quickly spirals into something much darker. By the next morning, one man is dead, one woman is critically injured, and the person responsible has already fled the scene. But the biggest question isn’t just what happened—it’s who should be held accountable in the end. Sponsors: 🛍️ Quince – Go to Quince.com/CREEPERS for free shipping and 365-d...

What's that saying about the best laid plans? Well, ours were derailed this week and unfortunately we were not able to record an episode. But with Mogab's recent visit to the Masters tournament, we thought it was a good time to drop our episode, originally a mini creep over on our Patreon, about that time #1 golfer in the world Scottie Scheffler was arrested at the PGA championship. Sponsors: 🛍️ Q...

Dr. Amie Harwick was a well known therapist in Los Angeles with a full life and a wide circle of friends, but on Valentine's Day 2020, that life was cut short in a shocking attack at her home. At first, the case left investigators trying to figure out what had even happened. But as they dug deeper, a clearer picture started to form - one that pointed to a history that couldn’t be ignored and a sit...

After her death, one doctor refuses to let the case go. What he uncovers transforms a so-called “mysterious illness” into something far more sinister—and far more intentional. As investigators begin piecing things together, a chilling pattern emerges, pointing toward someone who was there all along. But in a case built almost entirely on circumstantial evidence, proving it won’t be easy. Because w...

When 40-year-old Esther Castellani begins experiencing strange and worsening symptoms, doctors can’t figure out what’s wrong. What starts as stomach pain quickly turns into something far more serious—numbness, vomiting, and a steady, terrifying decline that no one can explain. As Esther fights to get better, her husband, Rene Castellani, plays the role of devoted partner… but behind the scenes, hi...

On Mother’s Day 2020, 49-year-old Suzanne Morphew went out for a bike ride near her home in Salida, Colorado… and never came back. At first, it looked like a tragic accident, maybe even a mountain lion attack. But the deeper investigators dug, the stranger things became. A missing phone. A staged scene. A husband with a story that kept shifting. And digital evidence that told a very different vers...