I Scream, You Scream Podcast

Happy 100th Episode!! 🍾🥂🎉✨ Today, we’re celebrating this milestone with Kathryn’s favorite hometown haunt… complete with paranormal evidence captured at The Peoria State Hospital😱 Originally known as the Illinois Asylum for the Incurable Insane (but better known to locals as the Bartonville Asylum), this haunted hospital has a reputation for sinister stories about trapped ghosts and angry spi...

In 1860, Elizabeth Packard was committed to Jacksonville Insane Asylum for “extensive application of body and mind,” or as she put it, “placed there by her husband for thinking.” She spent three years there, enduring horrific abuses alongside countless other women whose husbands and families had abandoned them. When she finally got out, she went after the men, laws, and systems that put her there...

Hidden in the Venetian Lagoon, just a short distance from the glittering streets of Venice, Poveglia has earned a reputation as one of the most haunted islands in the world—a place so steeped in death and tragedy that even today, few people are willing to set foot there. For centuries, the island was used to quarantine victims of disease. The sick were brought there. The dying were abandoned there...

Founded in 1247, Bethlem Royal Hospital (AKA Bedlam) is literally synonymous with chaos. In today’s episode, we’re exploring its dark history - including horrifying procedures, longstanding corruption, and its time as one of London’s top tourist attractions. Story Starts: 00:06:04 Welcome to I Scream, You Scream, where Gina & Kathryn serve up your weekly scoop of the most chilling histories, m...

IT’S FINALLY HERE 😈 Welcome to autumn, little spoons!!! To celebrate the turning of the wheel, we have some scrumptiously spooky tales to share. Plus, what’s your zodiac sign’s horror movie archetype? Guess you gotta listen to find out 🤷‍♀️ Stories Start: 07:50 📚Book recs: Check out “Sign Here” by Claudia Lux: ​​https://app.thestorygraph.com/books/eb66767a-781f-4d0e-aedf-0091c761ca36 Check out...

In the early 1900s, a string of brutal axe murders left communities across America searching for answers. The crimes were attributed to a mysterious figure known as Billy the Axeman… but who was he? As stories of the murders spread, so did theories about the man behind them. In this episode, we’ll trace each crime and explore the theory that Billy the Axeman may have been responsible for far more...

Is there anything scarier than being trapped on a boat with a delusional murderer? If there is, I (Gina) don’t want to know.  When the Mary Russell departed for Barbados in 1828, it was just another routine trading voyage. That is, until the captain dreamed there was mutiny afoot. Believing it to be a warning from God, Captain Stewart sank deeper into righteous paranoia - and when his men tri...

In June 1912, eight people were brutally murdered inside a small home in Villisca, Iowa. Despite an extensive investigation and countless suspects, the case remains officially unsolved. More than a century later, the Villisca Axe Murder House is haunted with not just the ghosts of its victims, but the question about who did it & why. Story Starts: 05:00 Welcome to I Scream, You Scream, where G...

In 1892, Abby and Andrew Borden were violently murdered inside their home. Andrew’s 32-year-old daughter, Lizzie, was famously arrested and - after a very dramatic trial - acquitted of the crime. But to this day, the court of public opinion finds her guilty.  In this episode, we’re zeroing in on Lizzie’s side of the story. How did her personality influence the investigation? Were any of the h...

When Tony and Debra Pickman moved into their infamous haunted Atchison, Kansas, home, they soon reported terrifying encounters, including unexplained scratches and sightings of a little girl named Sallie. But was there really a spirit in the house, or were there people who stood a lot to gain from convincing everyone that this is one of the most demonic houses in America? Story Starts: 11:10 Welco...

Once described as a “real-life storybook character,” Victor Lustig spent decades using deception, disguise, and charm to trick the wealthy out of their money. With a legacy spanning pre-war Europe to Great Depression America, he waltzed his way across history as the most infamous con artist of all time. This week, we’re unpacking history’s most infamous con artist, and the ten rules he left behin...

What happens when a haunted house promises to push you beyond your breaking point… and actually delivers? This week, we're diving into the unsettling history of McKamey Manor, the infamous extreme haunted attraction that blurred the line between entertainment and straight up legal torture. From its controversial creator and infamous waiver to (not so shocking) participant allegations of psychologi...

In 1984, a group of teenagers started a band called Mayhem, ushering in a new, darker evolution of Norwegian black metal. Born from a hatred of “humanity, life and happiness,” Mayhem attracted a fanatical fanbase - but it quickly spiralled out of control. In just a few short years, this bloodthirsty subculture escalated from internal power struggles to outright violence, leading to several murders...

Niagara-on-the-Lake may be known for its charming streets and award-winning wineries, but beneath its picturesque beauty lies a darker past. From the bloody battles of the War of 1812 to haunted inns, restless soldiers, and ghostly guests who never checked out, this historic Canadian town has earned a reputation as one of Canada’s most haunted towns. Join us as we uncover the chilling legends, tra...

Are you drawn to the sea? Do you love dancing under the moon? Are you capable of transforming into an actual seal by putting on a magical seal skin? If so, we’re pleased to report that you’re a selkie, and you need to be our friend.  Selkies have featured in Celtic and Norse folklore for centuries, for good reason. Join us as we learn all about our favourite aquatic shapeshifters, and trace t...

She wanders riverbanks dressed in white, her mournful cries echoing through the night: "¡Ay, mis hijos!" But who is La Llorona really? From ancient Aztec legends to colonial folklore and chilling modern encounters, we're tracing the haunting evolution of one of the most heartbreaking ghost stories to get to the bottom of our most burning question: Is she really the villain in her story, or is ther...

In 1872, a ship was found adrift in the Atlantic Ocean. On board, there were nearly two thousand barrels of untouched cargo, months' worth of provisions, and cabins full of personal items - but the captain and crew were missing, never to be seen again.  What could’ve caused experienced sailors to abandon their vessel? Why were they in such a rush to leave? And could it happen again? Today, we...

After a month of harrowing amusement park tales, it’s high time for a Palate Cleanser. And this time, we’re sharing hand-picked summer-themed stories! So grab a glass of something tasty (and ideally cold, bc the world is melting and so are we), and gather ‘round to hear your new favorite campfire stories.  Story Starts: 11:52 Welcome to I Scream, You Scream, where Gina & Kathryn serve up...

In Alton, England, there stands a grand, 19th-century Gothic Revival mansion…and its ruins are surrounded by rollercoasters.  Alton Towers is one of Europe’s most popular amusement parks, and the land it stands on has a body count dating back thousands of years. To the surprise of no one, it’s haunted as hell. Today, we’re taking a trip through time to explore the legends and folklore around...

From ghostly sightings on the most famous rides to strange behind-the-scenes experiences, Disneyland is absolutely loaded with haunted legends. Are these stories simply part of Disney's magic, or is something else lingering after dark? Join us as we walk through our favorite ghost stories from Disneyland in Anaheim, CA. Story Starts: 13:50 Welcome to I Scream, You Scream, where Gina & Kathryn...

Reputed for its world-class rollercoasters and family-friendly amenities, Kings Island welcomes millions of guests each year - but the park’s dark history goes well beyond the attractions. Visitors and staff alike report encounters with restless spirits, from the playful ghost of a 5-year-old girl to a haunted replica of the Eiffel Tower. And alongside the paranormal, Kings Island’s history is rid...

Abandoned rides creak in the shadows, but the park’s eerie reputation goes far beyond rusting Ferris wheels. Built on land tied to tragic loss, violent colonial history & decades of ghost stories, Lake Shawnee has become one of America’s most infamous haunted locations. In this episode, we explore the park’s troubled past & the lingering question that keeps visitors coming back: who or wha...

If walls could speak, The Langham in London would be hooting and hollering. For over 160 years, it's hosted the world’s elite - from royalty and billionaires to artistic legends - and these days, it’s known for being haunted af. This week, we’re mapping the hotel’s history and reputation, from its Victorian origins to the string of journalists who reported paranormal encounters within its walls.&n...

Opened for the 1893 World’s Fair, the historic Congress Plaza Hotel has spent more than a century collecting ghost stories and eerie rumors. From the infamous Room 441 to phantom figures roaming dark hallways, many call it Chicago’s most haunted hotel. In this episode, we explore the hotel’s chilling connection to some of history’s most infamous bad guys, in addition to the lesser-known (but so im...

Perched above Eureka Springs, Arkansas, the eerie Crescent Hotel holds secrets darker than its grand facade suggests. In the 1930s, conman Norman Baker transformed it into a sham cancer hospital, peddling false cures to desperate patients. Today, whispers linger in its halls of lost souls and restless spirits. We’re breaking down what really happened inside those walls… and turns out it’s so bad t...