Conspiring to Argue

Ep. 71 - The Enfield Poltergeist 05.07.2026 1:49:13 ↓

Spooky British ghost!

Ep. 70 - The MLK Jr. Conspiracy (Pt. 2) 10.06.2026 1:45:14 ↓

Ted and JJ conclude discussing whether or not the US government tried to murder Dr. King

Ep. 69 - The MLK Jr. Conspiracy (Pt. 1) 03.06.2026 1:02:38 ↓

Ted and JJ discuss the possibility that the United States government may have been responsible for the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Ep. 68 - Cryptids & Cocktails (Pt. 1) 21.05.2026 1:00:09 ↓

In what may possibly become a series, Ted and JJ try and blindly convince one another of the existence of a cryptid. (While becoming increasingly intoxicated.)

Ep. 67 - The Murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer 07.05.2026 1:39:20 ↓

The boys discuss the tragic 1964 murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer, a Washington D.C. artist.

Ep. 66 - The Tylenol Murders 23.04.2026 1:40:14 ↓

Ted and JJ discuss the bizarre tragedy of the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Murders.

Ep. 65 - The Rendelsham Forest Incident 06.04.2026 1:23:58 ↓

The boys discuss the Rendelsham Forest Incident, considered by many to be the most defensible UFO incident of all time.

Ep. 64 - Madeleine McCann 18.03.2026 1:58:17 ↓

Quite a long time ago, the boys tried to tackle the case of the tragic death of Madeleine McCann. That episode was lost to time, so, here we are. Rerun.

Ep. 63 - Why Holocaust Denialism is Harmful 18.02.2026 1:53:51 ↓

In what may be the heaviest subject matter so far on the show, Ted and JJ discuss the logical fallacies used by Holocaust deniers.

Ep. 62 - The Titanic Conspiracy: F*ck Ice 05.02.2026 1:46:37 ↓

This week, the boys discuss whether or not the tragic sinking of the Titanic could have been premeditated.

Ep. 61 - The Skinwalker Ranch 21.01.2026 1:37:22 ↓

The boys talk about a conspiracy heavy hitter.

Ep. 60 - The Coffee Timezone Conspiracy 06.01.2026 47:57 ↓

It’s… hard to describe this one.

Ep. 59 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 3) 24.12.2025 2:01:27 ↓

The boys cover the 2025 independent investigation of Ellen Greenberg’s death.

Ep. 58 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 2) 11.12.2025 1:51:33 ↓

The boys continue covering the death of Ellen Greenberg.

Ep. 57 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 1) 29.11.2025 1:42:04 ↓

The boys cover the mysterious, and (somewhat) controversial tragedy of the 2011 death of Philadelphia teacher, Ellen Greenberg.

Ep. 56 - Stonehenge 17.11.2025 1:11:16 ↓

The boys discuss the possible mysteries of Stonehenge. Also, Woodhenge (no, really, that exists.)

Ep. 55 - Ed Gein (Pretty Much a Monster?) 31.10.2025 1:43:55 ↓

Ted and JJ tackle the crimes of Ed Gein… HAPPY HALLOWEEN!

The Death of Charlie Kirk 22.10.2025 1:45:38 ↓

Yeah. It’s contemporary and controversial… yikes

The Death of Adam Walsh pt. 3 (Was it Dahmer…?!) 09.10.2025 1:15:02 ↓

It… probably wasn’t.

Ottis Toole & Henry Lee Lucas pt. 2 (feat. Courtney from Book of the Dead) 23.09.2025 1:49:47 ↓

We’re joined by a special guest this time to discuss how absolutely terrible Toole and Lucas were.

The Death of Adam Walsh (Ottis Toole Pt. 1) 01.09.2025 1:35:01 ↓

Ted and JJ discuss the tragic death of Adam Walsh, while regretting their drink choices…

Artificial Intelligence - The Most Irritating Potential Apocalypse… 22.08.2025 1:27:36 ↓

The boys from IA discuss AI.

Dyatlov Pass Incident 12.08.2025 1:16:19 ↓

Ooooooh this was a lot of fun honestly. Ted and JJ look into the Dyatlov Pass Incident, a tragedy that occurred in the Ural Mountains in the 1950s.

Update - Jeffrey Epstein 2.5? 28.07.2025 1:33:46 ↓

UNFORTUNATELY there’s more to talk about… ugh.

The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allen Poe - Poe Drinks, Poe Problems 15.07.2025 1:16:58 ↓

This week we discuss the (kind of) mysterious death of American author, Edgar Allen Poe. JJ like really doesn't like Poe?