Which Murderer?

In Season 3 Episode 32 the girls wish you a calm and JUMANJI FREE 2021 with New Year’s Murder themed stories. Gemma starts off with the sad murder Brandon Teena and Holly tells us all about murderer Rhys Hancock Shoutouts to fans Dave, Natalie and Helen…. thanks so much for listening and chatting to us. While it’s mentioned Holly is dating someone in this episode she is in fact not anymore…. awkwa...

In Season 3 Episode 31 the girls cover some Egyptian Murders in recognition of the popularity of the podcast in the Egyptian iTunes charts. Holly tells you all about Raya and Sakina’s money making murder plans and Gemma chats through the story of Ramadan Abdel Rehim Mansour. Holly is still being attacked by Nandos and now has a Starbucks issue, Gemma’s story is super sad…like her energy levels dur...

In Season 3 Episode 30 the girls speak about Rap Murders which is kind of thanks to a fan named Steven and Producer Craig’s unique brain interpretations. Gemma talks about the aptly named rapper C-Murder and Holly goes through the story of Mac Minister. Holly is attacked by Nandos, Gemma goes over a small mistake from a previous episode (small in that we said the opposite of the truth) and Snoop D...

In Season 3 Episode 29 the girls speak about Murders with Weird Backstories. Holly kicks things off with the bizarre tale of Sharon Lopatka before Gemma chats through the case of Hiroshi Maeue who had a very specific victim group. Holly once again forgets to push the button, she then suggests you un-ring your necrophilia bell, Producer Craig is on fire with sass, Gemma’s murderer is very strangley...

In Season 3 Episode 28 the girls cover American Thanksgiving Murders with Gemma kicking it off telling us all the utterly depressing story of Terri Lynn Hollis. Holly then goes over the family killing by Paul Michael Merhige. Holly starts things off dirty, there is a huge justice gap in Gemma’s case, Holly demands revenge on a corpse, red flags are flown, Gemma offends America slightly and Turkey...

In Season 3 Episode 27 the girls cover Family Murder Mysteries. Holly speaks about the creepy Hinterkaifeck Murders in Bavaria and Gemma covers the mystery of the Sodder Children – murder or not? Holly starts things off by ignoring the basics of podcasting, Gemma is glowing with health, the girls have strong conclusions and basically solve the cases themselves and Gemma hates her family (not entir...

In Season 3 Episode 26 the girls take a fan theme suggestion (thanks Carrie!) and cover cases of women who were Murdered While Pregnant. Gemma starts off with the story of Winifred Ransom and Holly then speaks about Reyna Angelica Marroquin. The girls are professionally unprepared in their shout-outs this week, the girls complain to the country of America regarding their selfish election thing, ge...

In episode 25, season 3, Gemma and Holly discuss Clubland Murders. Theme suggested by listener Jared Muppet. Shoutouts given to long time supporter of the podcast, Woody from Real Life Real Crime, and to superfan Oliver. Holly’s case is the mass shooting in a Florida nightclub, carried out by a terrible man called Omar Mateen. Gemma thanks Jared for suggesting her case, the murder of Angel Melende...

In Season 3 Episode 24 the girls speak about Scottish Island Murders with Gemma covering the tragic case of Alesha MacPhail and then Holly goes into old timey times to speak about Angus MacPhee. Holly is in a rare positive mood and might be an alien, the girls diagnose mental illness via time travel, Gemma knows what cases bent boy parts and there is an update on Episode 20’s murderer. Who is stil...

In Season 3 Episode 23 the girls are back with some Spooky Halloween Murders! Holly starts it off with the horrible story of Ronald Clark O’Bryan and Gemma tells us about a monster named Eric Copple. Gemma is alive and telling you all about her organs (thanks everyone for all your lovely messages of support), the girls talk about their little trip to Skye with hill tumbling included, Holly’s drivi...

In Season 3 Episode 22 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Interesting Body Disposals from Season 2 Episode 17 Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In Episode 17 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover murderers with 'Interesting Body Disposals...

In Season 3 Episode 21 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Murderers on TV from Season 1 Episode 46 Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In **Episode 46** Gemma and Holly cover murderers who have been on the silver screen, but not for t...

In Season 3 Episode 20 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. First up its Murders at Sea from Season 1. Two REALLY good cases. Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. The term '100%' 7 too many times. As well as… Shoutouts for Crime Monthly Magazine, Facebook Gro...

In Season 3 Episode 19 – Murder Solved Through Exhumation – Holly speaks about Donnie Rudd, then James Otto Earhart Shoutouts for Transcripted Podcasts, Storyglass Media and Generation Why Podcast In this episode Holly and Gemma criticize three countries, Holly hates ‘Intro Holly’ and it’s revealed the girls might have been drunk during that clip, it’s the days of never-ending rain, the girls emph...

In Season 3 Episode 18 – Mean Girl Murders – Gemma covers the Canadian case of Reena Virk from Holly’s Island and Holly goes on to speak about Skylar Neese. Shoutouts to Canadian Dani for the suggested theme and to our Facebook fan who we aren’t sure meant to pop up but we see you! In this episode Holly is a cookie feeder….some may say monster, the girls find out a superfan likes war and Gemma’s p...

In Season 3 Episode 17 – Bollywood Murders – Holly covers the horrific murder of Meenakshi Thapa and Gemma goes through the story of Brijmohan Sadanah. Shoutouts to our good friend Oliver (you cute little binger you…), Canadian Facebooker Graham and Canadian Dani who likes a little sneeze. In this episode everyone is distracted by the scheduled Pub lunch about to happen, the girls struggle very ha...

In Season 3 Episode 16 – Thrill Killers – Gemma covers the brutal murderers Christopher Jones and James Roughan from Australia and Holly talks through the horrific Toolbox Killers case. WARNING: This is a particularly disturbing episode with extreme graphic violence. Listener discretion is advised. Shoutouts to Superfan Catriona, a fabulous recommender and a lovely reviewer. In this episode Gemma...

In Season 3 Episode 15 –Gold Diggers Who Murder – Holly starts us off with the story of a pretty poor excuse of a human named Desmond Campbell. Then Gemma goes on to tell us all about Vicky Efandis who had a George fixation. This episode launches rather aggressively before Holly goes on to declare war on Scottish insects. They are the worst. Both girls cheat a little on research and end up using t...

In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little? Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’ In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we co...

In Season 3 Episode 13 – Framing Others for Murder – Holly tells the story of Rod Covlin who just so happens to be the king of assholes. Gemma then covers the story of Floyd Bledsoe who possibly has the worst family ever. In this episode Holly is very excited and scares her team, the English language continues to die via this podcast, names don’t get any easier and the US justice system takes a pr...

In Season 3 Episode 12 –Doctors who Murder – Gemma takes on the bizarre story of Walter Freeman who was most definitely a fan of scrambled eggs, while Holly attempts to share the store of Marcell Petiot. Shoutouts to @podchaser and @behindthebastards In this episode the girls are finally reunited for recording and Holly is once again being produced by Producer Craig in the flesh. Gemma faces a dil...

In Season 3 Episode 11 – Solved Their Own Murders – Holly tells the story of Grace May Brown who helped convict her killer after her death before Gemma goes on to tell the sad story of Simon Ng who blogged his murderer into a conviction. Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time. In this episode we learn that Pro...

In Season 3 Episode 10 – Murdered by Police, Gemma covers the tragic and horrifying death of Elliot Williams who died in custody after prolonged suffering. Holly then goes over the story of murderer Kevin Gregson in Canada. Shoutouts for some lovely fans who left five star reviews and a plug for the gorgeous new boutique shop @etonmessboutique The girls start out with a therapy session surrounding...

In Season 3 Episode 9 – Homophobic Murder, Holly tells the story of Colin Ireland who was known as the ‘Gay Slayer’ and Gemma goes over the murders surrounding the Bondi Beach Attacks. In this episode Holly longs to be touched and stalks her nail people, Gemma broadcasts her lunch around the UK (possibly) and there are yet more math arguments. Math continues to be the source of all evils. Producti...

In Season 3 Episode 8 – Jealousy and Murder, Gemma covers the tale of Melanie Smith – not to be confused with SuperFan Mel…. although it was very exciting times for Holly briefly. Holly then goes on to break Gemma’s heart and mind with the horrific tale of murderer Gertrude Baniszewski. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who is well on the way to SuperFan status and to True Crime Zone who adde...