Which Murderer?

In Season 4 Episode 3 the girls tell you all about Abductors Who Murder. Holly teaches you about Donald ‘Nappey’ Neilson who was not a fan of diapers or postal workers before Mel covers Anni Dewani’s murder right after Holly awkwardly snickers at the name. Shoutouts to Facebook Sarah (are you still listening?) and a weird one to the wonderful Gemma and Consulting Producer Craig. We find out Holly...

In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part Two) the girls finish talking about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Holly covers the twisty tale of Jake Lingle then there is a detailed debate. Mel kicks it all off by insulting an entire nation, Holly continues the mob theme from episode one despite hating mob murders, there is a big debate despite the method of murder being exactly the same in both cases, there is a di...

In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part One) the girls talk about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Mel covers the sad story of Jill Dando in the first of this two part episode. Mel emphasises the best way to keep Holly happy, the girls decide gynaecologists are undatable, Mel makes a royal comparison, and Holly has to badly sum up this episode post-recording due to her being an idiot. EVERYTHING IS FINE. Product...

Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer! In Season 4 Episode 1 Mel and Holly cover Mob Murders - Mel's choice as Holly has terrible taste in TV shows. It all connects. Holly kicks off the episode with the story of Albert Anastasia before Mel tells you about Abe Reles. The girls discuss Holly's terrible brain, some new possible career options, an overview of Mel's extensive criminal history, there ar...

Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer! In the Season 4 Intro you finally get to meet this season’s new co-host – MEL! You’ll hear how she started off on this journey hating true crime and podcasts….look how that turned out. Almost as well as Holly saying she would never date again. There are loads of great cases lined up for this season so stay tuned! Production, recording and postproduction compl...

In the Season 3 Final Episode the girls cover Diagnosed Psychopaths Who Murder for Gemma’s final podcast appearance. Gemma chats through Robert Black before Holly talks about Jane Toppin. Holly has some nickname confusion, Gemma tells a horror story of note, Holly may be serving seconds when it comes to her murderer and the girls share a final tough choice at the end of this episode. Much love to...

In Season 3 Episode 51 the girls talk about Beauty Pageant Murders with Holly kicking off her story of Svetlana Kotova before Gemma dives into her tale about Michaela McAreavey. Shoutouts for Sarah with a case suggestion and Woody over at Real Life Real Crime who helped solve a cold case murder recently. We are super impressed and proud and totally recommend you listen to him. And not just because...

In Season 3 Episode 50 the girls cover Cabin in the Woods Murders with Gemma telling you all about the murder of David and Estelle Akeman before Holly chats through the nightmare of the Tiede family. BIG PODCAST ANNOUNCEMENT FOR SEASON 4 The girls reveal some dirty secrets, Producer Craig loses his sweet little mind, Holly is outraged by Producer Craig’s opinions on cats, random adoptions might be...

In Season 3 Episode 49 the girls talk about Murderers Who Have Disappeared with Holly covering the Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders before Gemma talks about the French case of Xavier Pierre Marie Dupont de Ligonnès. Holly comes clean about cheating on her diet plan, Producer Craig turns evil in the sunshine, eyebrow communication remains unreliable, California was not a great place to be in the 70s,...

In Season 3 Episode 48 the girls talk about College Murders with Gemma kicking the episode off with the story of Tina Morris. Holly then jumps into the surprising case of Robert Bechtel. Shoutouts for Helen and Catriona from the Superfan Gallery who were both a bit traumatised by the Manchester episode. The girls clarify that you cannot in fact take your mommy to college, Holly has an oddly uplift...

In Season 3 Episode 47 the girls talk about Surviving Serial Killers with Holly giving a very basic covering of Richard Specks attempted murder of Corazon Amurao before Gemma dives into the case of Kate Moir surviving the killer couple David and Catherine Bernie. It’s cold and spooky in Scotland during this recording and there is bitterness, having 8 kids leads to heart attack, someone actually ha...

In Season 3 Episode 46 the girls cover Prom Night Murders with Gemma kicking it off talking about Paul Michael Crowder before Holly chats through the tale of Adam James Sapikowski. The girls win their own professional standards contest, Producer Craig gets yelled at, shot cows are involved in one of the murders and the girls request a bit of a delay on shooting them in the head as a general PSA. P...

In Season 3 Episode 45 the girls talk about Wartime Murders. Holly kicks it off with the story of Paul Orgorzow before Gemma tells you about Harry Dobkin. Shoutout for Lindy who shared her panther cat Willow on the Facebook Page – SHARE ALL YOUR ANIMALS ALL THE TIME. Farming leads to Nazi’s, Holly lectures you all on the Spanish Flu and propaganda, apparently you can be ‘too bad’ to be a Nazi, Gem...

In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story. Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team. The girls are engrossing you all with endless stor...

In Season 3 Episode 43 the girls talk about Manchester Murders following the case suggestion by listener Ray. Holly starts off with the disturbing case of Suzanne Capper before Gemma tells the story of ‘The Beast of Manchester’. Shoutouts for Jennifer Fabulous who understands an abbreviation and Postie Jess from down under whose ears must be bleeding by now. Thanks for the five star review! BE LIK...

In Season 3 Episode 42 the girls talk about Murderers Influenced by TV Shows which was a re-record due to Holly being Holly. Luckily neither one of them has any reliable memory. Holly kicks it off with murderer Mark Twitchell, a fellow Canadian unfortunately before Gemma tells us about Joseph Hall who the girls have strong opinions about. Shoutouts for Ray who contacted us with a case suggestion a...

In Season 3 Episode 41 the girls talk about Siblings Who Murder. Gemma kicks things off with the case of the Scissor Sisters Linda and Charlotte Mulhall then Holly chats through the story of twins Betty and Peggy Woods. Penis removal takes place, sympathy is hard to muster in the first case, AA meetings were the first Tinder (apparently), 2020 makes another scary appearance and there is a surprise...

In Season 3 Episode 40 the girls talk about Chainsaw Murders – happens more than you’d think. Gemma starts you off with the gruesome murderer Jonathan Stasiuk before Holly tells you all about the sad story of Teri Lea Zenner and her brutal murder. Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig a...

In Season 3 Episode 39 the girls talk about Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press. Holly starts us off with the Lipstick Killer and Gemma then goes over the Smiley Face Killer. Holly tells tales of murder in the local zoo, Scottish weather is the worst, Gemmas insults Holly RIGHT BEFORE HER BIRTHDAY about her age, we all learn Holly has tried to get her fist in her mouth and Gemma has a p...

In Season 3 Episode 38 the girls talk about Ax Murders – can you believe it’s taken 3 seasons to get here? – with Gemma kicking it off by telling us the tale of the Ax Man of New Orleans and Holly then going on to chat us through the South African murderer Henri Van Breda. Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse. A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ig...

In Season 3 Episode 37 the girls talk about Cruise Ship Murders suggested by listener Jared Muppet (thanks JM!!!). Holly tells us about Tamara Tucker then Gemma covers the death of Kristy Manzanares. Shoutout for Sarah from the Facebook page/group. The girls become a TV Guide…you’re welcome, a scene from Titanic is reenacted (obvious reasons but also completely by accident), fines for Murder are i...

In Season 3 Episode 36 the girls talk about murders which involved Bodies in Wells suggested by all three of Holly’s personalities. Gemma kicks things off with the story of Jessie McMahon who waited a long time to be found and Holly goes over the murder of David King. Shoutouts for Helen, Dave, Kev – much love to you all! Holly is missing Craigs hand-feeding methods, the girls give themselves bonu...

In Season 3 Episode 35 the girls talk about Tinder Murders – which does not help Holly’s reluctance to rejoin. Holly starts off with the sad tale of Grace Millane who died on her birthday, then Gemma talks about Sidney Loofe. Shoutouts for Jomya1989 who left a lovely iTunes review, Kyla on the Facebook page and Superfan Caitriona. The girls give their Christmas reviews (and a life update from Holl...

In Season 3 Episode 34 the girls cover the interesting field of Rich People Who Murder. Gemma starts off with the story of Michael Skakel which has an unexpected legal ending and Holly tells us about the strange John du Pont murder case. A missed shout-out eventually happens for Kate despite Holly being unprepared for life and podcasting, then there is a secret cryptic message that we aren’t talki...

In Season 3 Episode 33 the girls start 2021 off with a Murders on Airplanes theme….which does nothing to help with Holly's fear of flying. Holly starts off with murderer Yuji Nishizawa (‘All Nippon Airways’ Flight 61) who was very safety conscious and Gemma follows up with the scary story of Andreas Lubitz and Germanwings Flight 9525. Future Gemma and Holly were hoping for some good vibes – week o...