Which Murderer?

In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy. Ther...

In Season 3 Episode 6 – Serial Killers Released Early from Prison – Gemma starts with the Lainz Angels of Death which Holly correctly predicted she would (because nurses) and then Holly tells the tale of Charlene Gallego who did not find the third time lucky in the husband category of life. Shoutouts to lovely listeners who leave excellent reviews on iTunes (you give us life right now) and longtim...

In Season 3 Episode 5 – Vampire Murderers are covered by the girls after Gemma finds her perfect case. Holly starts off with James Riva who lived in a state Holly refuses to spell. Gemma then goes on to tell the tale of Peter Kurten who was a bad bad man. Shoutouts to Holly’s Mother who did not give her murder information and Holly might have yelled at her a little….and a Facebook Fan shout-out wh...

In Season 3 Episode 4 – Gemma and Holly cover ‘Murders that Shocked the World’. Gemma starts things off with the really sad story of James Bulger which was an unbelievable tragedy. Holly then rounds off the sadness with the murder of JonBenet Ramsey. Holly has a nervous breakdown at being late but firmly blames someone else all the way, there are sirens and mild panic, Gemma wins a contest while p...

In Season 3 Episode 3 – Holly and Gemma cover Sexually Motivated Murderers. Holly starts off with David Williams and his Canadian based murders. Gemma then goes over the story of Christopher Wilder…. which Holly almost covered as well. Despite being told clearly in writing that Gemma was covering it. Shoutouts for Superfan Natalie who left a lovely review and the quarantine episode from Fair City...

In Season 3 Episode 2 – Gemma and Holly talk about people who Murder in Small Towns. Gemma starts things off with some informative information that Holly screws up before Gemma covers the story of William Immon. Holly then takes things super close to home on a street where she spent some time as a child….and the murder of Vesna Soos. Shout out to friend-fan Diane who was not bullied into listening...

Welcome to Season 3! In the Season 3 premiere - Episode 1 - Holly and Gemma talk about people who wanted their parents dead…not to be confused with Patricide…which is not to be confused with Pesticide. It’s a bit of a rabbit hole. Holly kicks things off with the story of Patricia (Patty) Columbo who had worse taste in men than Holly. Which is saying a lot. Then Gemma heads over to Canada to talk a...

In Episode 52, Season 2, Gemma and Holly celebrate the end of their second season and the beginning of Season 3 and their 2 year anniversary, which they then realise are all essentially the same thing. Gemma covers Russian serial killer Alexander Pichushkin, who loved a game of chess and pushing people. Holly covers earthquake preventer Herbert Mullin, who somehow couldn’t convince people of his l...

In the Season 2 penultimate Episode - 51 - Holly and Gemma talk about Deathbed Murder Confessions from their lonely & ‘not coping well’ corners of the city. First Holly goes over the murder case of Christine Kett before Gemma launches into the horrific murder of Joan Harrison in 1975. In this episode Gemma struggles to make words escape her brain, Holly revisits her hatred for time travel when dis...

In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community...

In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community...

In Episode 49 Season 2 Holly and Gemma are looking for some ideas to keep Holly from becoming a very well researched murderer….and are also covering Murderers who had Early Warning Signs. Holly covers the story of Carroll Edward Cole who came from a family of androgynous namers. Gemma then goes into the case of David Berkowitz who had some interesting ‘head’ friends. There is a shout-out for Super...

In Episode 48 Season 2 – OUR 100TH EPISODE OVERALL – Gemma and Holly are recording far away from each other due to the dumbest virus ever but are super excited to be covering their personal choices for WORST MURDERS FROM SEASON ONE. Gemma heads back to Episode 14, Season 1 (Matricide) for clips from the story of Ed Kemper. Then Holly springs back to Episode 31, Season 1 (Cannibals) to discuss Armi...

In Episode 47 Season 2, Holly and Gemma (still pre-lockdown) cover the intriguing topic of Secrets and Murder. Holly talks through fellow Canadian Brett Ryan (aka the ‘Crossbow Killer’) who was a complicated mix of good guy and murderer. Gemma then covers Mark Hacking who did the unimaginable to his closest connection. Holly struggles to describe this episode’s topic then yells at Gemma, Gemma is...

In Episode 46 Season 2, Gemma and Holly still have no idea life is about to get much more complicated with a virus and are cheerfully recording face to face to cover 1920's Murders. Gemma starts off with the messed up story of Gordon Stewart Northcott - who unfortunately was Canadian. Holly then chats through the spooky Hex House Murder which was a bit awkward. In this episode Producer Craig think...

In Episode 45 Season 2, Holly and Gemma make a two-parter special to cover Murderers with Head Injuries. Holly starts off in Part One with the coverage of Bobby Jo Long. There are some corrections to be make as Gemma can’t count bones while Holly wishes for 100 more in the human body and shout-outs for some fans including hashtag-name-thing @Why83km and a lovely South African listener whom the gir...

In Episode 45 Season 2, Holly and Gemma make a two-parter special to cover Murderers with Head Injuries. Holly starts off in Part One with the coverage of Bobby Jo Long. There are some corrections to be make as Gemma can’t count bones while Holly wishes for 100 more in the human body and shout-outs for some fans including hashtag-name-thing @Why83km and a lovely South African listener whom the gir...

In Episode 44 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about 'Killers Who Died While Murdering' - which Gemma picked and subsequently ruined 3 days of Holly’s life. Gemma covers the story of Wayne Nance whose story should totally be a movie and then Holly chats through the death of murderer Neal Falls who liked to have options. Holly thinks getting up early, getting fuel and driving to Gemma’s is overachiev...

In Episode 43 Season 2, Holly and Gemma take a suggestion from 'Australian Al' and cover Body Storage Solutions. Holly pretty much takes the easiest option and covers the Snowtown Murders which do not involve Santa or Snow despite the happy sounding name. Gemma then goes on to destroy all our happy feelings with the sad tale of Junko Furuta and her murder. Holly is STILL hungry in this episode, Ge...

In Episode 42 Season 2, Gemma and Holly struggle their way through dates and times to bring you Murders from the 2010's. Gemma goes over the grisly tale of murderer Robert Bayne who murdered in Holly's old stomping grounds. Then Holly covers the short but tragic case of Murderer John Maden from Manchester. In this episode Holly can't carb so just stares longingly at Gemma's food, the paleness of t...

In Episode 41 Season 2, Holly and Gemma finally return home from the Highlands of Scotland and are really quite miserable about it. The girls cover Murderers with No MO and Holly tentatively takes on the terrifying character Israel Keyes. Gemma then goes on to cover the South African Cedric Mack. Gemma gives a shout-out to a friend named Andrew who the girls then manage to also threaten, then ther...

In Episode 40 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are still in the Highlands of Scotland (listen, we do eventually make it home....). The girls talk about Murderers Who Escape Prison to Murder Again with Gemma kicking things off covering the case of Gary Tison and Randy Greenawalt. Holly then goes over the story of John Thomas Straffen.  Some fan shout-outs happen from Instagram and there are mentions by an...

In Episode 39 Season 2, Holly and Gemma wake up in a tender state in Highlands of Scotland. The girls talk about cases of Biters with Holly diving into the gory tale of the 'Butcher of Hanover' or  "Fritz" Haarmann. Gemma then goes on to tell us all about the case of Stephanie Lazarus who got way obsessed with a guy. They aren't worth murdering for ladies! Some fan shout-outs happen from the Faceb...

In Episode 38 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are in a tipsy state in Highlands of Scotland. The girls tackle cases of Well Educated Murderers with Gemma chatting through the story of Joseph Michael Swango who used his brain cells for bad doctoring and general human interacting. Holly then talks through the case of Amy Bishop who reached a tragic breaking point.  Holly finds shampoo made by angels but s...

In Episode 37 Season 2, Holly and Gemma apparently now live in Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover the difficult topic of Cop Killers with Holly getting inspiration from Reddit on her case about Christopher Monfort who specifically targeted the police with his rage. Gemma then covers the historic Linwood Bank Robbery case from the outskirts of Glasgow, Scotland.  The girls do not recommend bank...