Which Murderer?

In Episode 36 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are still recording on the road in the Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover the appropriately chosen theme of Scottish Highland Murders and Gemma starts the ball rolling with the story of Allister Wilson's death. Holly then tells us about the cold case murder of Renee Macrae which has some exciting new developments. Holly renames everything in Scotland nor...

In Episode 35 Season 2, Holly and Gemma hit the road to record on location in the Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover Hotel Murders (making the thematic connection as they are staying in a hotel - genius!) and Holly talks about the Claypool Hotel which had it's share of fame, fortune and murders. Gemma then tells us about a horrific death at a hotel by Jesse McDonald who was a fancy criminal. ...

In Episode 34 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss murders that involved alcohol, which is fitting as both the girls are quite hungover. Gemma starts off with a disclaimer that her case about Angela Wrightson is very sad this week. Holly then discusses the murderer Jean Lanfray who had a fondness of absinthe and pretty much all other drinks involving alcohol. Holly shouts out the podcast Sharp and sh...

In Episode 33 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about Murder Manhunts with some sneaky country leavers. Holly covers Shane O'Brien who didn't have a bank account - which blows Holly's mind, followed by Gemma's telling of the bizarre murderer Luka Magnotta who was recently the subject of the Netflix documentary 'Don't F**k with Cats'. https://twitter.com/NetflixUK/status/1207347943298256896 The girls...

In Episode 32 of Season 2, Gemma and Holly brave a hangover to bring you all some murders connected to Religion. There were a few to choose from sadly. Gemma talks about Lauren Stuart and her Jehovah's Witness family. Holly then takes on a Catholic murder committed on sacred ground by the priest Gerald Robinson. Holly has her life ruined by a pepper...not just any pepper...only the FIFTH HOTTEST P...

In Episode 31 Season Two, Holly and Gemma cover cases of Bosses Who Murder. Holly goes into the tale of Hemy Newman who was crazy in love.....or just crazy. Gemma talks about the tragic and frustrating murder of Alisha and Ava Bromfield by the worst manager on earth. The girls start out with a weather and car safety segment which makes Producer Craig pull out all his eyelashes in frustration, Gemm...

In Episode 30 Season 2, the girls cover some grisly Victorian murders. Gemma goes for Frederick Bailey Deeming also known as 'Mad Fred' who failed at relationships and fatherhood dramatically. Holly then talks about Richard Dadd who was an accomplished artist and crazy person....perhaps even an Egyptian god. Holly ticks all her boxes, Gemma introduces Effie the Dog to the episode by gently acciden...

In Episode 29 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about cases of stalking which sadly led to murder. Holly covers Robert John Bardow who went deep into TV land and mental disorder, followed by Gemma's telling of a sad case of domestic abuse/stalking that led to the murder of Shana Grice.  Gemma shouts out her sister's roommate Claire who is the new podcast sister, Holly gives Gemma an update on one of...

In Episode 28 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who put pen to paper and wrote books about their crimes. Gemma speaks about Donald Gaskins Jr. aka 'PeeWee' who had adorable nicknames and gang names....but was very much not adorable. Then Holly covers Johann "Jack" Unterweger who had some hard core Mummy issues.  Holly fails at the first hurdle, the girls get nostalgic for the days whe...

In Episode 27 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss cases that sparked their obsessions with true crime - CASE ZERO. Holly tries to cover the Black Dahlia but seeing as Gemma was TOO SELFISH to look into the future it's already been done, so she settles for a connected case and the murder of Gertrude Landon. Gemma then goes on to cover a murderer Ann Rule wrote about, Diane Downs.  Holly is pretty agg...

In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s.  The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a...

In Episode 25 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who buried their victims alive! Gemma covers the murder Stephen Small who had a pretty terrible kidnapping experience and Holly speaks about murderer Tiffany Ann Cole.  The girls plug the Facebook Group hard and give much thanks to moderator Kimberlee! Gemma invents a new word that will definitely catch on, a construction worker is heavi...

In Episode 24 Season 2, Gemma and Holly discuss cases involving Gemmas. Holly stars off with the case of young Gemma McCluskie, an actress who was sadly murdered by her own brother. Gemma discusses the wannabe serial killer Jemma Lilley who had the wrong heroes and a grandiose sense of importance. ⠀ ⠀ Gemma mistakenly advertises several products and gets annoyed at unobservant taxi drivers. Holly...

In Episode 23 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover...Hollys! - specifically ones who murder or are victims of murder. Surprisingly hard to find! Holly covers the case of Holly McFeature who you should never accept Iced Tea from. Gemma starts off this episode with the sad tale of Holly Jones who was taken far too soon.  The girls give some fan shout-outs from iTunes Reviews and Instagram, Holly apologis...

In Episode 22 Season 2, Gemma and Holly discuss the 1 of the 3 things that annoy Holly the most, murderers who keep diaries. Holly shares the tale of young Jason Massey who worked his way through the Triad and documented it all. Gemma discusses self proclaimed “strange character” and serial killer Robert Berdella. Who wasn’t just strange, he was a sadistic torturer and had the laziest way of getti...

In Episode 21 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through two stories of Murderers with Charm. Gemma starts off with Paul John Knowles, who has a little bit of sparkly vampire in his cheekbones. Then Holly moves on to William Theodore Durrant....who liked a church, or rather all the storage space available in a church. Gemma learns to say the word 'burglary' very carefully, Holly debunks a psychic, Can...

In Episode 20 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover two cases of people who were sentenced to death but were later proven innocent. Holly goes through the case of Timothy John Evans from Wales who confessed to a crime he most definitely did not commit. Then Gemma talks about the saddest case Holly has ever heard.....Joe Arridy. Listen with tissues.  A happy shout-out to a fan kicks off this episode whic...

In Episode 19 Season 2, Gemma and Holly chat through the terrible childhoods of two murderers.  Gemma talks about the bizarre case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard. Which Holly gets excited about despite it totally not being a real surprise. Holly then speaks about the prolific vigilante murderer Pedro Rodriguez Filho who is a YouTube legend - apparently.  Holly is confused by how someone with a skinned kn...

In Episode 18 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about a particularily terrifying category of murder - Criminally Insane Killers. Holly takes a recommendation from Ladynickmiller on Reddit ( https://www.reddit.com/user/ladynickmiller) and covers the 'Vampire of Sacramento' - Richard Chase. Gemma then goes through the murders committed by Michael Charles Hayes.  Gemma feels masses of sympathy for Richa...

In Episode 18 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about a particularily terrifying category of murder - Criminally Insane Killers. Holly takes a recommendation from Ladynickmiller on Reddit ( https://www.reddit.com/user/ladynickmiller) and covers the 'Vampire of Sacramento' - Richard Chase. Gemma then goes through the murders committed by Michael Charles Hayes.  Gemma feels masses of sympathy for Richa...

In Episode 17 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover murderers with 'Interesting Body Disposals'. Gemma covers the strange tale of Jim Smith who way back in oldie times ended up in an aquarium side-show and Holly ruins everybody's day with the horrific crimes of Enriqueta Marti Ripolles - who is now knows as Ricki as Holly almost swallowed her own nostrils trying to pronounce it.    The girls record in t...

In Episode 16 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk through 'Road Rage Murders'. Holly speaks about the conviction of Kenneth Noye and Gemma covers Gary Durham from Florida.  Holly is violently torn from her hippie colony school roots when Gemma slaps real world gangster school crime rackets at her, Gemma weaves a twisted tale of karma that has Holly choking on air and Producer Craig causes endless troub...

In Episode 15 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through 'Victims in the Architecture'. Gemma talks about Anthony Sowell who was the poster boy for 'Crack is Whack' and then Holly covers the story of eccentric and jerkfaced Mr. Nichols.  The girls don't support having 12 children in the same house, Holly explains why she can't live on a farm with an orchard, Gemma judges people who ride lawnmowers lik...

In Episode 14 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss cases where one victim was killed by more than one murderer. Holly covers the tragic case of Stephen Lawrence ( https://www.stephenlawrence.org.uk/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw753rBRCVARIsANe3o47uGsSmjCl_jOQ8wKgSyYKOzzknaLJKelyWlLE971yXvSVSuRzEC5EaAtTgEALw_wcB ) who changed the course of the UK legal system with his untimely death. Gemma then goes into the grisly...

In Episode 13 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about crimes that were solved using fingerprints. Gemma travels to New Zealand (verbally) to chat through the tale of Dennis Gunn, who was really not up to date on crime technology. In that he was an idiot about covering up his involvement. Holly then chats through the groundbreaking case of the Stratton Brothers in London.  Holly and Gemma are bossed a...