Which Murderer?

In Episode 12 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover two tales of Black Widows (the ladies not the spider, because Holly nopes out of anything spider related). Holly starts off with the tale of the 'dull normal' Evelyn Dick and Gemma talks about Mary Elizabeth Wilson who totally liked an alternative lifestyle.  Holly gets sugar boosts from Producer Craig which results in memory loss and problems speaking...

In Episode 11 Season 2, Gemma and Holly chat through two cases of Murderers with Nicknames, both terribly accurate and ridiculous. The girls delve into the dark decade of the seventies....with Gemma covering 'The Doodler' and Holly speaking about 'Charlie Chop-off'.  Holly starts off the episode by ruining 'Forrest Gump', then in short order ruining Gemma's entire case. Gemma forgives her (probabl...

In Episode 10 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about their two favourite topics....food and murder. Holly covers the sad case of Veronica Cirella and her terrible use of a wonderful candy. Gemma then goes over the double murderers Sofia Sam and Arun Kamalasanan who were super terrible at hiding things.  Holly starts off the episode by completely screwing up her credit to whichever of the people she...

In Episode 9 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover 'Old Timey London Murders'  - a place where people always seem to get stabby. Gemma covers the story of Adelaide Bartlett who may have been an aristocrat or just a normal human. Holly then talks about The Barnes Mystery where a woman named Katherine was super talented at avoiding full time employment.     Holly gets excited about pears because all life...

Gemma covers the story of terrible teacher Violet Berling who taught the horrific craft of accordion playing. Holly chats through the tale of teacher Carla Ann Hughes who threw away a promising life over a dude. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/which-murderer--4106338/support .

In Episode 7 Season 2, Holly and Gemma chat about 'Murderers with Distinguishing Features' which was a suggestion from the continuously challenging Producer Craig. Gemma covers the famous (and poorly parented) Henry Lee Lucas and Holly covers Tsutomu Miyazaki who was the stuff of nightmares.    Holly starts off the episode by complaining about everything on earth, Gemma points out the obvious to H...

 In Episode 6 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk cover the crimes of two 'Wrestlers Who Murder' which was a suggestion from the ever challenging Producer Craig. Holly covers fellow Canadian Christopher Benoit and Gemma talks about the 'little old lady killer' and Lucha libre wrestler Juana Barraza.    Producer Craig kicks off this episode with a wizard impression, Holly makes it very clear she does NO...

In Episode 5 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through the especially disturbing way some murderers dispose of their victim's bodies....in the Food Chain. Gemma talks about the unstable Australian woman who liked a Sunday roast, Katherine Knight. She really freaks Holly out this week. Then Holly tells the sad tale of Charlene Downs and many other young girls from Blackpool.  Holly starts off on a sha...

In Episode 4 Season 2, Holly and Gemma get into the spirit of hoarding by covering Murderers who Kept Trophies - or Trophy Killers. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/which-murderer--4106338/support .

In Episode 3 Season 2, Gemma and Holly take two episodes to cover the topic of Spree Murderers. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/which-murderer--4106338/support .

In Episode 3 Season 2, Gemma and Holly take two episodes to cover the topic of Spree Murderers. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/which-murderer--4106338/support .

Copycat Murders and a 'Which Would You Rather' debate - from the Which Murderer Team! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/which-murderer--4106338/support .

Our first episode of Season 2 focuses on Murderers with the worst defences. Holly and Gemma get off to a bad start by forgetting where and when they first met! Then Holly speaks about Scott Falater who killed his wife in the garden in front of his neighbour. Gemma moves on to her case, speaking about barmaid Sandie Craddock. Both cases involve very strange defence arguments. Holly and Gemma to hav...

In **Episode 52** - the end Season One! - Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who used the internet to hunt their victims, instead of using it for what the good Lord Almighty intended...shopping and porn. Gemma covers the tragic story of murderer Lisa Montgomery and Holly talks about a truly monstrous employer and sadomasochist John Edward Robinson. Holly can't read her own writing and makes some...

In **Episode 51** Holly and Gemma tackle the ultimate taboo of incest, then take it to the next level in cases that led to murder. Holly chats through the story of the Bakeland family, who in a weird 'butterfly effect' sort of way eventually led to a Sea Turtle getting something extracted from it's nostrils. Gemma speaks about Ryan Wyngarden who was eventually convicted for murdering his sister, w...

In **Episode 50** Gemma and Holly talk about cases where the victims were killed while at work, like work wasn't bad enough. Gemma talks about convicted killer Richard Farley who committed the cowardly crime of stalking and harassing his victim Laura Black before attempting to murder her in the workplace, killing many others in the process. Then Holly chats through the story of Raymond Clark III w...

In **Episode 49** Holly and Gemma cover a couple of murderers who had the audacity to seek the public's help for the crimes they had committed. Gemma talks about the convicted killer John Tanner who killed his fiance of approximately 12 hours and Holly goes through the story of Tracie Andrews who was found guilty of the brutal  murder of Lee Harvey. Holly starts off claiming to be candy deprived b...

In **Episode 48** Gemma and Holly talk about Murders that happen while on holiday. Which is the worst kind of holiday to have. Gemma goes for Bruce Beresford-Redman with the murder of his wife Monica in Mexico and Holly covers Bradley John Murdoch who was convicted of killing Peter Faconio in Australia. Holly kicks things off by moaning about rain and finger bruises, Gemma decides she’s never goin...

In **Episode 47** Holly and Gemma chat through some Urban Legends involving murders from both reality and fiction. Gemma goes for the cannibal Scottish family led by Sawney Bean and Holly covers a relatively new legend, The Alice Killings. The episode starts off with Producer Craig setting himself on fire, there is an update on the Jack the Ripper case, the girls talk about how amazingly terrifyin...

In **Episode 46** Gemma and Holly cover murderers who have been on the silver screen, but not for their crimes. Gemma speaks about the worst gameshow prize ever, Rodney Alcala and Holly talks about a serial killer cook names Stephen Port. The girls struggle a little with Geography (also Math, unrelated to this episode), Holly nopes out of a multiple strangling situation, the girls do not recommend...

In **Episode 45** Holly and Gemma talk about some murderers who were convicted despite there being no bodies found of the victims. Gemma speaks about the terrible road tripper David Gilroy and Holly covers an absolutely terrible son and brother named John Perry. The girls go back to 17th century England to talk about a whacky 'Gone Girl' situation, Holly is an expert on cadaver dogs since listenin...

In Episode 44 Gemma and Holly talk about some murderers who are still **Claiming Innocence**….despite being found dead-ass guilty. Gemma speaks about Pamela Smart and Holly covers Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald . The girls once again forget how to make a podcast, Gemma sets Holly up and Holly fails the test, giggles ensure at the name of an unfortunate high-school and Gemma has to deal with another spouse...

In Episode 43 Holly and Gemma watch some movies and TV shows in order to cover their theme this week - **Based on a True Story**. Holly covers _‘The Frozen Ground’_ which is the story of Robert Christian Hansen….a truly horrible hunter….and Gemma speaks about _‘American Crime Story’_ and the murder of Gianni Versace by Andrew Cunanan. Holly complains about her movie (a lot) and Nicholas Cage, both...

In Episode 42 Gemma and Holly decide to butcher the Spanish language and cover murderers in Mexico (which is the land of Holly's third favourite food group). Gemma covers Raul Marroquin who had a very flawed get rich quick scheme and Holly talks about Gregorio Cardenas Hernandez who got the bad end of encephalitis. Not that there is a good end. This week the girls attempt and then totally give up...

In Episode 41 Holly and Gemma continue discussing murders surrounding worst fears, this time Holly's issues with Strangulation. Gemma covers Susan Newell who was the worst Spiderman impressionist and Holly talks about Edward Leonski who was exceptionally quick at overstaying his international welcome. This week the girls both admit to having suffered through their worst fears, Holly talks a bit to...