True Crime with Gavin Fish

Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Tonight we’ll dig into the most recent developments in the search for Nancy Guthrie — investigators say DNA from a glove found near her Tucson home still hasn’t produced a match in the FBI database, the sheriff is urging the person responsible to release her, and authorities are continuing to follow thousands of tips while trying to piece together whether...

Tonight we’ll break down the latest twists in the Nancy Guthrie disappearance investigation out of Tucson, Arizona, including recent reporting by Brian Entin that FBI agents have been canvassing local gun shops with a list of names and photos of 40 possible persons of interest in hopes of matching someone seen in surveillance video outside Guthrie’s home the night she vanished. Case Background: Na...

Watch to video on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Investigators say DNA evidence has been recovered, but what does that actually mean? In this livestream we’ll walk through how DNA testing works, how CODIS is used to identify suspects, and what investigators can still learn even if there isn’t a database match. Case Background: Nancy Guthrie, an 84-year-old resident of the Catalina Foothills near...

New details have just been released about the man investigators believe may be connected to Nancy Guthrie’s kidnapping, and tonight we’re breaking it all down live. The FBI has now shared a description and put more money behind the search, raising new questions about what they know, how close they might be, and what this means for the case moving forward. Case Background: Nancy Guthrie, an 84-year...

Authorities continue to investigate the disappearance of 84 year old Nancy Guthrie in the Catalina Foothills near Tucson, treating the case as a suspected abduction after evidence was found at her home, while a man briefly detained has been released without charges and a new Bitcoin ransom demand is now under scrutiny. Surveillance video of a masked individual near her front door has intensified t...

Tonight, we’re covering a breaking development in the search for Nancy Guthrie after FBI Director Kash Patel released photos on X tied to what authorities describe as a potential subject in the case. We’ll go over the images, what law enforcement has said so far, why this public release matters, and how it could shift the investigation as pressure mounts to find answers in this high profile disapp...

Tonight, we break down the latest developments in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie as a second ransom deadline is looming and her family publicly declares they are willing to pay for her safe return. We’ll walk through what investigators have confirmed so far, the troubling lack of proof of life, and why a former FBI agent is publicly questioning whether this is a legitimate kidnapping at all, a...

Tonight, we take a closer look at where the investigation into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie stands on day six. Police believe the 84-year-old mother of Today show co-host Savannah Guthrie was kidnapped from her Tucson-area home, but the case has become increasingly complicated by ransom messages, false tips, and information that investigators say is muddying the waters and causing real damag...

Tonight, we break down the latest developments in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the 84 year old mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, after the deadline outlined in an alleged ransom note has now passed. Investigators have confirmed the note demanded a payment by 5:00 p.m., raising urgent questions about who took Nancy, whether the demand was real, and what happens now that the clock...

Today, authorities are expected to provide new information in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, as the sheriff and the Federal Bureau of Investigation hold a press conference addressing what they call a kidnapping. In this livestream, we'll watch the update in real time, break down what officials say, and examine what new details, if any, emerge about the investigation. Case Background: Nanc...

Tonight, we break down the alarming developments in the search for Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of Today show anchor Savannah Guthrie. What began as a missing person case has taken a far more serious turn, with FBI agents descending on a family member’s home, reports of blood found at the scene, and the emergence of possible ransom notes. Let's walk through what’s been confirmed, what...

Tonight, we break down everything that is currently known about the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of journalist Savannah Guthrie, who vanished from her home in Arizona under troubling circumstances. We’ll walk through the timeline, what investigators have said so far, why authorities believe this was not a voluntary disappearance, and what key questions remain unanswered a...

The disappearance of Lilly Sullivan and Jack Sullivan is now intersecting with a disturbing new development involving their stepfather, Daniel Martell, who has recently been charged with the S.A. of an adult. While police have not linked those charges to the children’s disappearance, the allegations raise unavoidable questions about who the children were living with and what may have been happenin...

Tonight I’m joined by strangulation and domestic violence expert Brian Bennett, a retired South Carolina law enforcement instructor and consultant, to examine the Spencer and Monique Tepe murders through one of the strongest predictors of lethal violence: non-fatal strangulation. Using new details from the recently released probable cause affidavit, including prior allegations that Monique made ag...

We have the court docs with special thanks to The Docket! Join us live as we break down the latest in the tragic Columbus, Ohio double murder case, where authorities say 39-year-old surgeon Michael McKee allegedly visited Monique and Spencer Tepe's home weeks before the couple was found fatally shot while their children were inside. We will walk through the newly unsealed affidavit, surveillan...

Tonight, we’re breaking down the explosive Washington Post profile that pulls back the curtain on Nick Reiner’s life inside extraordinary privilege, years of addiction, escalating volatility, and repeated warning signs that many now say were impossible to ignore. From the shocking Thanksgiving dinner outburst where witnesses say he hurled a turkey leg at his father, to accounts of violent behavior...

Tonight we’re breaking down a major new development in the Celeste Rivas Hernandez homicide investigation after a grand jury witness connected to singer D4vd was arrested on a warrant for failing to appear and testify. We’ll explain who the witness is, why this arrest matters, and what it signals about the direction of the grand jury probe as prosecutors continue examining the circumstances surrou...

Michael McKee appeared in an Ohio courtroom today, formally facing a judge in the murders of his ex wife, Monique Tepe, and her husband, Spencer Tepe. Let's talk about exactly what happened during today’s arraignment, what charges McKee is now facing, how prosecutors framed the case in court, and what this hearing tells us about where the case goes next. We’ll walk through the key moments, the...

For years, the Ellen Greenberg case has been framed as a mystery, a tragedy, or a disagreement between experts. Tonight, I’m calling it what it is, an institutional failure shaped by conflicts of interest, political pressure, and decisions that protected careers instead of truth. Federal authorities are now taking a closer look, but few people are willing to explain what that actually means. I wil...

Tonight, we’re digging into new reporting and jailhouse accounts describing Nick Reiner’s behavior behind bars following his arrest in the murders of his parents, Rob Reiner and Michele Singer. According to sources, Reiner has been described as childlike, detached, and at times delirious while in custody, raising fresh questions about his mental state after the killings. We’ll break down what’s be...

Tonight, we’re breaking down the case against Jonathan Gerlach using the actual criminal complaint and multiple search warrants obtained by investigators. I’ll walk through what police allege, what the documents say they found, and how this case came together based on the records themselves, not headlines or speculation. Case Background: The case centers on Jonathan Gerlach, a Pennsylvania man acc...

Tonight we’re breaking down the newly unsealed Franklin County indictment against Michael McKee in the December 30, 2025 murders of Dr. Spencer Tepe and Monique Tepe. Prosecutors charged him with four counts of Aggravated Murder and Aggravated Burglary, all carrying firearm and suppressor specifications. We’ll walk through what the charges mean and what they reveal about how the state says this do...

Tonight we’re taking a closer look at a troubling theory in the murders of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Reiner. New reporting has raised questions about a recent change in Nick Reiner’s mental health treatment and whether substance use may have played a role. We’ll walk through what’s known so far, what remains unclear, and why this angle is now drawing increased attention as the case moves forwa...

Tonight, we break down the latest developments in the murders of Spencer and Monique Tepe, including police confirming they have recovered what they believe is the murder weapon. Investigators say the killing was targeted and DV-related, and evidence seized from Michael McKee’s property is now being linked to the crime scene. Case Background: Spencer Tepe and his wife, Monique Tepe, were found sho...

We're talking about the newest development in the Ellen Greenberg case: the federal government is now requesting records and reviewing what happened. After more than fourteen years of unanswered questions, legal battles, and mounting expert criticism of the medical examiner's ruling, this could mark a major turning point. Case background: Ellen Greenberg was a 27-year-old first grade teach...