True Crime with Gavin Fish

The investigation into the Siders family continues to raise difficult questions as new details emerge about the conditions inside the Ohio home where authorities say 16 children were found living in severe neglect. Newly released investigative photographs offer a sobering look inside the residence, while a new report examines whether repeated pregnancies over nearly two decades should have prompte...

New developments in the Ohio 16 case are drawing attention to a new bond filing from Elizabeth Siders, one of four family members charged after 16 children were removed from a Hamden home. Her attorney is asking the court to modify her $300,000 bond, but rumors about the reason for that request have already started spreading online. The motion tells a more specific story than the rumor mill does,...

New developments in the Ohio 16 case are raising fresh questions about what happens next for the Siders family and the criminal cases now moving through Vinton County. Gary Siders "Sr.," one of four family members charged after 16 children were removed from a Hamden home, is now out of jail after a medical emergency disrupted his scheduled court appearance. Prosecutors say the children a...

Newly uncovered records and interviews are providing a clearer picture of the Siders family long before authorities discovered 16 children living in horrific conditions inside an Ohio home. Court documents, birth records, and statements from relatives have raised new questions about Elizabeth Siders' early life, her marriage at age 15, and the years leading up to one of the most disturbing chi...

Authorities in southeastern Ohio say they discovered 16 children living in shocking conditions inside a Vinton County home, leading to felony child endangerment charges against four members of the Siders family. Investigators allege the children had little contact with the outside world, with many lacking school enrollment, medical records, and other documentation that would normally mark their ex...

The investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance has taken a major turn after the FBI concluded that the ransom notes at the center of the case were not authentic, at least according to Reuters. The announcement raises new questions about the motive behind her disappearance and challenges one of the most widely accepted assumptions in the case. As investigators continue to analyze physical...

Two cases. Two very different circumstances. One disturbing thread that raises important questions about risk, violence, and the warning signs that are too often overlooked. Joining us is former law enforcement officer Brian Bennett, a nationally recognized DV and strangulation expert, whose experience training investigators and first responders brings valuable insight to both the Anna Kepner and...

An anonymous sender has reportedly contacted TMZ claiming a hidden phone contains evidence in the Nancy Guthrie abduction case, including alleged video connected to the case and identifying information for two people the sender claims were involved. The message reportedly came with a Bitcoin demand, raising new questions about whether this is a meaningful lead or an attempt to exploit a missing wo...

Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PST Experts are challenging one of the most talked-about pieces of the Nancy Guthrie investigation: the ransom emails. New reporting explores claims that even messages previously believed to be authentic could have been written by someone other than her abductor, raising new questions about the evidence, the investigation...

Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PST The Ohio Supreme Court has declined to hear Mackenzie Shirilla's latest appeal, leaving her murder convictions in place and dealing another major blow to her efforts to overturn the case. The decision follows arguments from her attorneys involving post-conviction deadlines and claims that a medical condition may h...

Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PST New details in the Nancy Guthrie case are raising sharp questions about the ransom notes, the Bitcoin strategy investigators used, and whether the masked man seen on her porch may finally be within reach. As former FBI voices suggest law enforcement could be closing in on “Porch Guy,” another question hangs over the c...

[CONNECT & SUPPORT] Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Follow On my Social media: 🌐 Website: https://gavinfish.com 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/gavinfishtrcrm 🐠 The Fish Tank: https://www.facebook.com/groups/gavinfish 💙 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/gavinfishtrcrm 🕵️‍♂️ CrimeCod: https://crimecod.com 🧡 Patreon: https://gvnf.sh/ptrn 👕 Merch: https://gvnf.sh/mrch 📁...

The 8-foot dinghy that Brian Hooker says he and his wife, Lynette Hooker, were aboard when she disappeared in the Bahamas in early April has been seized by U.S. Coast Guard investigators. This as CGIS divers and cadaver dogs continue their search for Lynette in the Bahamas, focusing on areas where Brian says he never was. [CONNECT & SUPPORT] Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Follow On...

Karen Read’s new civil lawsuit accuses the Massachusetts State Police and Canton Police of negligence, bias, failed supervision, and a corrupt investigation into the death of John O’Keefe. The complaint names explosive allegations involving Michael Proctor, Sean Goode, evidence handling, internal discipline, and the agencies’ role in the case. [CONNECT & SUPPORT] Listen on Spotify: https://gvn...

The Lynette Hooker case may have started as a reported boating accident in the Bahamas, but the latest reporting suggests U.S. investigators are now treating it as something much darker: a possible foreign murder of an American citizen. [CONNECT & SUPPORT] Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Follow On my Social media: 🌐 Website: https://gavinfish.com 📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram...

After Kouri Richins was convicted in her husband's murder, her team told Judge Mrazik they need more time to prepare a motion for a new trial. The defense says the trial record is massive, the motion will need transcripts and video clips, and attorney availability plus limited access to Kouri after her prison transfer have slowed the process down. Prosecutors are pushing back, arguing the defe...

A newly unsealed court transcript in the federal case against Timothy Hudson shows the defense pushing hard on what may become one of the central problems in the case: the timeline inside cabin 8343. Prosecutors argue Anna Kepner was killed during a window when Hudson was alone with her, but the defense pressed the FBI case agent on the lack of an exact time of death, the missing Apple Watch, the...

A newly unsealed court transcript in the federal case against Timothy Hudson lays out some of the clearest details yet about the murder of Anna Kepner aboard the Carnival Horizon, including the government’s timeline inside cabin 8343, what investigators say happened to Anna’s phone, the medical examiner’s findings, DNA evidence, and the moments prosecutors argue point to Hudson after Anna was last...

The disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of TODAY co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, remains unsolved nearly four months after investigators say she was abducted from her Tucson-area home in the early morning hours of February New reporting has raised questions about the masked man seen near Nancy’s home, mystery DNA evidence, delays in forensic testing, tens of thousands of tips, and wheth...

Tonight, I’m digging into Netflix’s The Crash, the documentary about Mackenzie Shirilla, the Ohio teenager convicted of murdering Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan by driving into a building at nearly 100 mph. We’ll talk about what the film shows, what it leaves out, Shirilla’s prison interview, the former inmate who says the documentary doesn’t show who she really is, and the bigger question hang...

Elizabeth Jones from Hillbilly Crime returns to the show for a live true crime conversation covering some of the biggest and most talked-about cases making headlines right now, along with viewer questions throughout the stream. From courtroom drama and controversial investigations to the strange twists that keep pulling people deeper into these stories, expect an unfiltered discussion with plenty...

This is your last chance to get in at: https://fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST ⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business, Fanathem, to give you the chance to win an Omega Speedmaster! As somebody who genuinely loves watches, this is such a cool prize to be able to offer because the Speedmaster is one of the most iconic watches ever...

Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST ⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business, Fanathem, to give you the chance to win an Omega Speedmaster! As somebody who genuinely loves watches, this is such a cool prize to be able to offer because the Speedmaster is one of the most iconic watches ever made. Every entry helps su...

Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST ⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business, Fanathem, to give you the chance to win an Omega Speedmaster! As somebody who genuinely loves watches, this is such a cool prize to be able to offer because the Speedmaster is one of the most iconic watches ever made. Every entry helps su...

Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfish DEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST ⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business, Fanathem, to give you the chance to win an Omega Speedmaster! As somebody who genuinely loves watches, this is such a cool prize to be able to offer because the Speedmaster is one of the most iconic watches ever made. Every entry helps su...