True Crime with Gavin Fish

We didn’t finish this call on Friday, so tonight we’re picking up right where we left off and playing the rest of Magnolia’s 911 call. The first 19 minutes already raised a lot of questions, but what comes next adds more context and takes the situation in a different direction. We’ll listen through it together, break it down in real time, and connect it to everything else happening around JLR righ...

The situation surrounding JLR Investigates is getting messier by the day, and now it’s spilled into a new state. Tonight, we’re breaking down the disorderly conduct citation out of Tucson tied to an airport confrontation, along with newly surfaced audio that adds more context to the broader pattern of allegations. We’ll walk through the police paperwork, what allegedly happened during the confront...

New surveillance data has redefined the timeline of the search for Amy Hillyard. Amy, the 52-year-old co-owner of Farley’s Coffee, was last seen on March 25, 2026. While her initial last known location was reported as Radnor Road, updated footage has confirmed her presence at Dimond Park in East Oakland at 4:30 PM that same afternoon. Amy is classified as "at-risk" due to a serious medic...

Hello Everyone, Thank you so much watching this video, in this video ''New Details Reveal How Perps Entered Nancy Guthrie’s Home as FBI Data Shows How Rare This Crime Is" Was the abduction of Nancy Guthrie an inside job? New FBI data reveals why this specific crime is statistically "impossible" without prior knowledge, as evidence suggests the perpetrators knew exactly how t...

911 calls and police dispatch audio are shedding new light on the domestic violence allegation case involving YouTuber JLR Investigates, with multiple recordings capturing real-time reactions from witnesses and law enforcement, including calls from the All Seasons River Inn, attempts to reestablish contact after the incident, and Magnolia’s own statements to police as the situation continued to un...

In the wake of Savannah Guthrie’s interview, the narrative around Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance is shifting. New clues are pointing away from a random act and toward something more deliberate. From what investigators found at the home to indications of possible pre-planning, we're taking a closer look at why Nancy was specifically chosen and what that means for this case moving forward. 📲 CON...

Strangulation, Trauma, and Why Victims Stay Silent | The JLR Investigates Allegations Tonight, we’re taking a serious look at the domestic violence allegations involving Jonathan Lee Riches, a.k.a. JLR Investigates, while also discussing a question many people ask the wrong way: why victims stay. This is not about blaming victims of abuse! It’s about understanding the trauma, fear, manipulation, a...

Tonight, we’re breaking down the newest twists in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, including conflicting statements from investigators about the significance of Jan. 11, questions about what law enforcement may know, and why critics say the public still isn’t getting a clear picture of the timeline. We’ll look at the latest reporting, what changed, and why this mystery date may be far more impo...

Let's take a deeper look at the police report involving D.V. allegations connected to YouTuber Jonathan Lee Riches, known as JLR Investigates (I'd tag him, but I seem to be blocked) , with the help of a former law enforcement officer who has specialized training in these types of cases. Brian Bennett joins me to break down what trained investigators look for in situations like this, what s...

D.V. Allegations Surface in Police Report Involving YouTuber JLR Investigates A police report obtained by Julez with True Crime Reactions outlines D.V. allegations involving YouTuber Jonathan Lee Riches, known as JLR Investigates. According to the Chelan County Sheriff’s Office, deputies responded to a call at a hotel in Leavenworth, Washington, where a woman reported being assaulted, threatened,...

New Scrutiny on Sheriff’s Decisions as Nancy Guthrie Investigation Drags On New scrutiny is falling on the leadership behind the Nancy Guthrie investigation as criticism grows over how the case has been handled from the start. With a recall effort targeting Sheriff Chris Nanos and experts raising concerns about early decisions, tonight we break down what’s being said, what it could mean for the ca...

A shocking new twist is emerging in a Tennessee murder case involving former NFL player Darron Lee, and it centers on something rarely seen in court, alleged ChatGPT-related evidence. Prosecutors say digital activity may help show intent and mindset in the moments leading up to the killing of Gabriella Carvalho Perpétuo. 🎧 Stay Connected: Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotify Follow On my So...

A significant development is raising fresh questions in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. A genetic genealogy expert now suggests that the FBI may be able to identify a suspect using advanced forensic techniques, offering a potential breakthrough in a case that has gripped the nation. In this update, we break down the latest expert analysis, how the DNA triangulation process works, and what thes...

Attorneys squared off in a dramatic day of closing arguments in the murder trial of Kouri Richins, the Utah woman accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins. Prosecutors and defense attorneys delivered their final pitches to the jury, each offering sharply different interpretations of the evidence and the events leading up to Eric’s death. Tonight, we break down the most important moments from...

🔴 New Twist in the Nancy Guthrie Case as Sheriff Says He Knows the Motive, Others May Be in Danger Authorities say they may now understand why Nancy Guthrie was taken, but they are not revealing the motive to the public. In a new development in the case, the sheriff says investigators believe they know what may have driven the abduction, while also warning that the suspect could strike again and...

Tonight we’re breaking down the disturbing case of Aliyah Henderson, the Cleveland mother accused of killing her two daughters after their bodies were discovered inside suitcases in a field. The victims, 10-year-old Amor Wilson and 8-year-old Mila Chatman, were identified through DNA after a dog walker stumbled across one of the suitcases, leading police to a second nearby. Henderson now faces two...

Tonight we’re diving into a major new development in the mysterious disappearance of Lilly and Jack Sullivan. While the world has largely moved on to other headlines, these two children are still missing, and the questions surrounding what happened that day have never truly been answered. Now, newly revealed lie detector tests are adding a surprising new layer to the investigation. Who was tested,...

Tonight we take a closer look at new developments in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. In a recent interview with The Interview Room, Pima County Sgt. Aaron Cross sharply criticized how the investigation has been handled, raising questions about early decisions and investigative leadership. At the same time, a neighbor is speaking out to Brian Entin about a strange man seen near Guthrie’s home a...

The search for missing 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie has entered its fifth week, and investigators say cadaver dogs previously used in the search have now been pulled back. Tonight, we’ll break down the latest developments, what investigators have revealed about the case, and what the decision to pause the use of cadaver dogs might mean as authorities continue searching for answers. Case Background: N...

Could the case against Kouri Richins have serious weaknesses? Tonight, I’m joined by Josh Ritter of Courtroom Confidential, a former prosecutor who now works as a criminal defense attorney. We’ll take a close look at three of the biggest vulnerabilities in the prosecution’s case and discuss whether any of them could create reasonable doubt for a jury. Case Background: Kouri Richins is accused of m...

Join me for a special Ascot Me Anything livestream where you can ask your questions about the biggest true crime cases we’ve been following together. From the latest developments to the deeper questions people keep asking, nothing is off limits. We’ll be talking about cases including Kouri Richins, the investigation into Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, and other stories currently making headlines i...

Nancy Guthrie remains missing, and the biggest question investigators still face is why she was taken. In this livestream, I’m joined by a retired FBI agent to break down the psychology of the person responsible. We’ll explore what behavioral profiling can reveal about the abductor, the motives that may be driving this crime, and what investigators typically look for in cases like this. Join us as...

Day 7 of the Kouri Richins trial leans heavily to the money trail. Prosecutors introduced detailed financial records they say reveal mounting debt, secret loans, and life insurance policies tied to Eric Richins’ death. We’ll break down the testimony, the key exhibits shown in court, and what this financial evidence could mean for the state’s theory that this was a calculated poisoning. Case Backgr...

Investigators have thrown everything at the search for Nancy Guthrie, from early canvassing efforts to DNA analysis and now even high tech attempts to detect a signal from her pacemaker, yet there is still no clear break in the case. In tonight’s livestream, we’ll walk through what law enforcement has tried, where mistakes may have slowed momentum, and whether those early missteps continue to cast...

A new report claims the FBI is “desperate” to take over the investigation into Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, citing growing frustration and alleged missteps in the early days of the case. Tonight, we’ll break down the allegations, the tension between federal and local authorities, and what it could mean if this investigation truly was “doomed from the start.” Case Background: Nancy Guthrie, an 84...