The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonagle analyzes the impact of injuries to Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, suggesting the Yankees make a massive move for a middle-of-the-order bat like Rafael Devers. They also debate which Mets players are truly untouchable in a 'Would You, Wouldn't You' trade segment while sharing rules for summer driving etiquette. 01:50 - Yankees Injury Crisis 13:40 - Rafael Devers Trade Proposal 2...

Big Mac explores the alarming nature of Giancarlo Stanton's latest injury setback and argues why it presents a bigger challenge for the Yankees than Aaron Judge's recovery. He proposes aggressive trade targets to stabilize the middle of the order while also highlighting the Mets' fortunate situation against a travel-weary Red Sox squad. The discussion takes a nostalgic turn as he and the crew deba...

Chris McMonagle analyzes a potential blockbuster trade bringing Rafael Devers to the Bronx while debating the slugger's clubhouse reputation. They also break down the controversy surrounding Carolina Hurricanes owner Tom Dundon engraving his children's names on the Stanley Cup over team personnel. Additionally, the discussion covers the Mets' strategy regarding long-term extensions for top prospec...

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' shortstop situation, asserting that Jose Caballero is currently the team's best option over Anthony Volpe. He proposes a significant trade for Rafael Devers to bolster the lineup and replace Giancarlo Stanton's production. They also delve into the New York Giants' offseason concerns and debate which New York Mets players should be moved in a Would You...

C-Mac rants about slow drivers and people who decorate their car dashboards with tchotchkes like rubber ducks. They transition into a trivia game called The Wheel, where Gallo and Hoff struggle with Tom Hanks movies and Beatles facts. The segment concludes with a look at the Yankees lineup as Anthony Volpe sits once again for Jose Caballero. 01:20 - Driving Etiquette Rant 11:04 - Tom Hanks Trivia...

Big Mac pits Hoff & Gallo against each other in the Wheel of Fun in this weeks edition where he picks the topics and it doesn't disappoint

Chris McMonigle takes calls from frustrated Yankees fans demanding accountability, but pushes back on the idea that firing Boone magically fixes the team's annual midseason "death spiral." Is the problem the manager, Brian Cashman, the roster construction, or something deeper within the organization?

Chris McMonigle leads a debate with Anthony Gallo and Pete Hoffman about which players the Mets and Yankees should trade as the deadline approaches. They play a game of "Would You, Wouldn't You" to determine the value of stars like Francisco Lindor, Bo Bichette, and Clay Holmes. They also examine potential contract extensions for Yankees players Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice. 02:38 - Mets Trade Game...

The Yankees salvaged a series split in Tampa thanks to the bats finally coming alive, scoring more than five runs in a game for the first time in their last 20 games. Chris McMonigle reacts to the offensive breakout, from Ben Rice continuing his strong series to the huge third inning against Drew Rasmussen. Can this kind of game carry over and carry the Yanks out of their swoon, and did they keep...

Are the Mets and Yankees handling their young stars the right way? Chris McMonigle reacts to the Cardinals locking up top prospect JJ Wetherholt with a long-term extension and asks whether the Mets should do the same with rising stars AJ Ewing and Carson Benge. Plus, Chris explains why the Yankees should consider signing Ben Rice before his price skyrockets.

Should the Yankees make a blockbuster move for Rafael Devers? Chris McMonigle makes the case that Devers is the perfect bat to replace Giancarlo Stanton's production and help the Yankees make a World Series run. But not everyone agrees, as callers question Devers' clubhouse reputation and whether he'd fit in New York.

The Yankees are doing it AGAIN... and Chris McMonigle wants answers. Chris breaks down the Yankees' frustrating yearly "death spiral," questioning why one of baseball's best teams suddenly forgets how to hit, field, and win for weeks at a time. Is it Aaron Boone? The roster construction? Brian Cashman? Or something bigger? Plus, Chris reacts to concerns about Aaron Judge's injury timeline, explain...

Gallo and Hoff debate which movie trilogies boast the best third installments, analyzing films like Die Hard with a Vengeance and The Dark Knight Rises. They also provide an update on the Red Sox's travel delays in Chicago and what it means for their matchup with the Mets. 01:01 - Movie Trilogy Debates 05:18 - Indiana Jones Plot Holes 10:12 - Red Sox Travel Nightmare 12:49 - Favorite Trilogy One-L...

With Aaron Judge sidelined, Chris McMonigle says the Yankees can't afford to think small at the trade deadline. While Judge's injury is impossible to replace, Chris argues the bigger long-term concern is Giancarlo Stanton's latest setback—and makes the case for Brian Cashman to swing BIG for Rafael Devers. Plus, Chris breaks down why the Yankees' win over the Rays was so important, why the AL is s...

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' series split with the Tampa Bay Rays, focusing on Ben Rice's standout performance and a resilient bullpen effort. He discusses concerning injury updates for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton while addressing fan concerns regarding the lineup's consistency and coaching. They also cover the New York Mets' series victory over the Kansas City Royals and a...

Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle breaks down the New York Yankees' 10-4 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays to salvage a crucial series split. He highlights Ryan McMahon’s twelve-pitch at-bat as a season-defining moment and discusses Ben Rice's power performance while addressing injury updates for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. 01:20 - Yankees Salvage Rays Series Split 04:42 - Ryan McMahon's Turning Poin...

Chris McMonigle reacts to Brian Cashman’s grim updates regarding the recovery timelines for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. He debates the Yankees' recent 'death spiral' without their superstars, considers a potential trade for Rafael Devers, and revisits his radio roots with a nostalgic piece for Steve Somers. 01:20 - Remembering Bonnie Tyler 05:02 - Mets Care Or Not Care 08:35 - Cashman Backs...

Mac revisits a nostalgic 2008 radio segment featuring Johan Santana's shutout performance before engaging in a heated debate with callers about the Yankees. He argues that Anthony Volpe should be benched in favor of Jose Caballero due to prolonged offensive struggles. The discussion also critiques Brian Cashman’s roster construction, specifically comparing the Giancarlo Stanton trade to missed opp...

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman react to Brian Cashman’s discouraging updates on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton's health. They explore the Yankees' recent struggles and discuss why acquiring Rafael Devers could provide the necessary offensive boost. 01:00 - Bonnie Tyler Reminiscence 04:55 - Mets Care or Not Care 09:54 - Cashman Backs Aaron Boone 13:25 - Judge and Stanton Injury Updates 21:55 -...

C-Mac evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive struggles and the significant lack of production from the catching position. He analyzes the debate between starting Anthony Volpe or Oswaldo Cabrera at shortstop while addressing the team's high strikeout rate compared to recent World Series champions. 01:00 - Highlander Movie Discussion 02:43 - Yankees Catching Upgrade Needed 06:33 - Debating Yanke...

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees' much-needed series finale victory over the Rays and explains why this wasn't just another win. From Ryan McMahon's game-changing 12-pitch at-bat to Ben Rice's monster series, Chris breaks down the biggest positives and why Yankees fans shouldn't dismiss them. He also clashes with callers who insist the Yankees still aren't contenders, discusses the bullpen, Aaron Jud...

Chris McMonigle reacts to the Yankees' historic strikeout streak and addresses rumors surrounding Anthony Volpe's alleged refusal to move to second base. They analyze the Mets' frustrating high-scoring loss, evaluate potential trade deadline targets like Tarik Skubal, and discuss the culture shift expected at Giants training camp. 02:02 - New York Baseball Struggles 07:28 - Volpe Position Change R...

On The Carton Show, Chris McMonigle addresses the historic strikeout issues plaguing the Yankees and the controversy over Anthony Volpe’s rumored refusal to change positions. He critiques the organization's loyalty to struggling prospects and the lack of production from the bottom of the lineup during a critical stretch. 01:20 - New York Baseball Recap 05:10 - Yankees Historic Strikeout Crisis 11:...

Chris McMonigle analyzes the Yankees' decision to bring Anthony Volpe back to the lineup and evaluates the team's need for starting pitching help like Tarik Skubal. They critique the Mets' recent defensive embarrassment and the broader issue of player accountability under Aaron Boone. The conversation also explores the psychological toll of playing in New York and Juan Soto's standout individual p...

Chris McMonigle addresses Anthony Volpe's firm denial of rumors reported by Joel Sherman and Michael Kay regarding a refused position change. They analyze the impact of injuries to stars like Carlos Rodón and Gerrit Cole while debating the pursuit of Tarik Skubal as the trade deadline approaches. 01:20 - Yankees Rays Series 08:47 - Injury Impact Debate 12:37 - Strikeout Performance Analysis 20:44...