The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' roster needs and the potential for a blockbuster trade to acquire Tarik Skubal. He criticizes Jose Caballero for a controversial plate appearance where the player dropped his bat mid-count and debates the true impact of the team's high strikeout totals. The discussion also highlights the importance of Gerrit Cole's performance in the upcoming series a...

Should the Yankees empty the farm system for Tarik Skubal? Chris McMonigle says if New York is going to overpay at the trade deadline, it should be for the best pitcher in baseball—not for marginal upgrades.

Chris McMonigle reacts to one of the strangest Yankees at-bats you'll ever see after José Caballero explains why he intentionally dropped his bat on a full-count pitch. Chris isn't buying the explanation and says there's no excuse for giving up during a Major League at-bat.

Anthony Volpe is finally responding to the rumors that he refused to move to second base and Chris McMonigle isn't buying the narrative. After Michael Kay walks back his report and Volpe publicly denies ever refusing a position change, Chris breaks down why the damage may already be done. Plus, should the Yankees send Volpe back to Triple-A to rebuild his confidence and learn second base?

The Yankees made franchise history in the worst way, setting a record for most strikeouts in a two game span. C-Mac is NOT happy after watching the strikeout fest, and he sounds off on the team's continued offensive woes, the miserable night from Jose Caballero after getting the start at shortstop, the continued "disgusting" showing from Paul Goldschmidt, Will Warren continuing his slide, and the...

Chris McMonigle breaks down why the Yankees' expectations have changed amid injuries and an ugly slump but insists they can't let the Rays gain ground in the AL East. A split in Tampa is now the bare minimum. Then the conversation shifts to the biggest question of the trade deadline: Should the Yankees go all-in for Tarik Skubal? Chris explains why an ace like Skubal could transform New York's pla...

Chris McMonigle delivers a passionate rant on the Yankees' recent struggles, pushing back against fans demanding more "accountability" from Aaron Boone. Is benching Anthony Volpe really the answer? Should Paul Goldschmidt be punished during his brutal slump? Chris explains why the Yankees' issues run much deeper than simply holding players accountable.

Big Mac turns his attention to the Mets, whose nightmare season somehow reaches another low after a wild, 12-run offensive outburst still ends in defeat. He breaks down Juan Soto's incredible play being wasted, the team's endless defensive and pitching blunders, David Stearns' growing criticism, and why Mets fans have officially reached their breaking point.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and says the Yankees are focusing on the wrong issues. While Anthony Volpe continues to dominate the headlines, Chris argues the bigger concerns are Cody Bellinger's struggles, Paul Goldschmidt's shocking slump, and a team that's unraveling at the worst possible time.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and unloads on the Yankees after another frustrating loss. While everyone is focused on the team's record-setting strikeout totals, Chris says they're missing the real problems. He also dives into the latest Anthony Volpe controversy after reports surfaced that Volpe allegedly refused to play second base before Michael Kay walked back the story. Ha...

Chris McMonigle breaks down the Yankees' pivotal win over the Rays, highlighting Cam Schlittler's dominant performance and the clear defensive upgrade provided by Jose Caballero. He also discusses Jalen Brunson's surgery, USA Soccer's disappointing loss to Belgium, and rumors surrounding Francisco Lindor's future with the Mets. 01:50 - Yankees Win In Tampa 05:10 - Caballero Versus Volpe Debate 21:...

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent success against the Tampa Bay Rays and debates the team's defensive strategy at shortstop. He advocates for Jose Caballero to remain the starter over Anthony Volpe, citing a disconnect between the front office's analytics and on-field performance. The discussion also covers the USMNT's recent struggles, Jalen Brunson's surgery, and potential ro...

Chris McMonigle praises Cam Schlittlers dominant outing and his Michael Jordan mentality of finding motivation in slights from critics. They analyze the Yankees' decision to start Jose Caballero over Anthony Volpe in the lineup. The conversation also covers rumors regarding a Francisco Lindor trade and the embarrassment of USA Soccer’s loss to Belgium. 01:20 - Cam Schliitler Dominates Rays 04:45 -...

McMonigle evaluates the Yankees' recent skid and argues that Anthony Volpe might benefit from a stint in the minor leagues to regain his confidence. He also reviews the news of Jalen Brunson’s wrist surgery and debates the leadership dynamics between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto. 01:20 - Yankees Rays Series Preview 05:15 - Volpe vs Caballero Defense 12:00 - Francisco Lindor Trade Discussion 18:0...

C-Mac evaluates the decision to start Jose Caballero over Anthony Volpe as the Yankees face the Rays. The discussion shifts to the Mets' future with Francisco Lindor and a heated defense of Aaron Boone's managerial track record regarding team accountability. Additionally, the segment covers Paul McCartney's rare performance at the Swift-Kelce wedding and trade deadline strategies involving Carlos...

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on WFAN while Craig Carton is out, and he floats a fascinating idea for the Yankees ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline. Could Carlos Rodón become a postseason bullpen weapon if the Yankees add another frontline starter? C-Mac explains why it might make sense and discusses the Yankees' biggest trade deadline needs.

Chris McMonigle flies solo on WFAN while Craig Carton is out, and dives into the Yankees' recent struggles. Should Aaron Boone really be fired? Chris explains why the manager isn't the problem, why Anthony Volpe sitting is the right move, and why Yankees fans are directing their frustration at the wrong person.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and reacts to the news that Jalen Brunson underwent wrist surgery after leading the Knicks to an NBA Championship. Chris explains why Brunson's postseason performance is even more incredible knowing he played through an injury that required surgery, calling the Knicks captain the toughest athlete in New York.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and takes on one of the hottest debates in New York sports: Should the Mets trade Francisco Lindor?

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show while Craig Carton is away, and he's thrilled after seeing the Yankees finally make the move fans have been begging for—Jose Caballero starts at shortstop over Anthony Volpe! Chris breaks down why Aaron Boone got it right, reacts live to the Yankees lineup, and explains why Caballero gives the Yankees their best chance to win. Plus, Chris weighs in...

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and can't stop raving about Yankees rookie sensation Cam Schlittler after his dominant performance against the Rays. Chris explains why Schlittler's mentality reminds him of Michael Jordan, breaking down the young pitcher's chip-on-the-shoulder approach and why that's exactly what the Yankees have been missing. Plus, Chris discusses the Yankees' Wo...

Chris McMonigle analyzes Cam Schlittler’s dominant start against the Rays and how his competitive fire mirrors Michael Jordan’s legendary drive. They also discuss the USMNT's embarrassing soccer loss to Belgium and explore potential trades for Francisco Lindor and Tarik Skubal. 01:09 - Cam Schlittler’s Dominant Performance 06:51 - Cam Schlittler’s Competitive Mentality 11:38 - Comparing Yankees an...

Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Yankees' recent performance and the growing debate over the starting shortstop position. He critiques Aaron Boone's 'day-to-day' approach with Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe, while also highlighting a dominant outing from the pitching staff. The discussion on The Carton Show explores the tension between team analytics and on-field results during a pivotal s...

The Yankees have seemingly bottomed out after losing their first series to the Twins in 12 years. Chris McMonigle reacts to another lifeless series, and how the Yanks look awful in every facet of the game right now. From a punchless offense to continued starting pitching struggles amid more injuries, C-Mac gauges the level of panic heading into a massive series against the first-place Rays, and wh...

Chris McMonigle critiques the New York Yankees' recent collapse and looks ahead to a pivotal four-game series against the Tampa Bay Rays. He argues that roster construction failures under Brian Cashman and the poor performance of young players are more significant than managerial issues. The segment also addresses the Knicks' center rotation and a controversial decision in the US Soccer tournament...