Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

That's A Dumb Rule

Sports EN ↓ 157 episodes

Discover some of the strangest, obscure or downright silly rules in sports that have you asking “is that a dumb rule?” Listen in on the conversations between two sports enthusiasts wanting to answer this question. Some rules you already know, others are the industry’s best-kept secrets. Find out what they are, the history behind them, and judge for yourself if it’s a dumb rule or not!

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: redcircle.com

Author

Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

Category

Sports

Podcast website

redcircle.com

Latest episode

Apr 5, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 79: Baseball - The Disengagement Rule 22.03.2023

Tune in to hear about this new rule and what impact it may have on the game. Spoiler alert - this does not help pitchers at all!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 1: Baseball - The Fair Foul Ball Rule 15.03.2023

In baseball, find out how a batter can hit the ball into fair territory, and it still be called a foul ball.

Special Edition 22: The NCAA March Madness Seeding Process 14.03.2023

Ahh.. March Madness. Can it get any better? Tune in and find out how the NCAA selects the 68 teams for the "big dance" tournament. It's way more complicated than you might think!

REPUBLISHED - Introduction 14.03.2023

Discover some of the strangest, obscure or downright silly rules in sports that have you asking “is that a dumb rule?” Listen in on the conversations between two sports enthusiasts wanting to answer this question. Some rules you already know, others are the industry’s best-kept secrets. Find out what they are, the history behind them, and judge for yourself if it’s a dumb rule or not! 

Episode 76: Baseball - The 13-Pitcher Rule 23.12.2022

Every team in baseball needs pitching. Always. Find out why the MLB put this very restrictive rule in place for the 2022 season -- and if you agree with it or not!

Episode 75: Baseball's MLB Playoff Structure 21.12.2022

Major League Baseball has changed how the playoffs are done more times than I can count. Tune in to hear the history of the playoffs and if you think the most recent change is the best so far.

Special Edition 21: Football's Best 16 Rule Changes 17.12.2022

Football is a sport where the rules change every year. These are the best rule changes that have happened since the inception of the league in 1920. Tune in and see if you agree!

Episode 74: Football - The Spinning Ball Rule 16.12.2022

What's the deal with showboating in the NFL? Is it good for the game, not good for the game or somewhere in-between? Tune in and decide for yourself!

Special Edition 20: The Nine Rules the NFL Should Enact 10.12.2022

The NFL is a money-making juggernaut - but there's always room for improvement, right? Tune in to hear about these 9 rules that the NFL should consider adding - and if you agree or not!

Episode 72: Basketball - The Mandatory Timeout Rule 09.12.2022

Why on earth are you required to call a timeout in basketball? Find out more about this ... ahem, dumb rule and the history behind it!

Episode 71: Golf - The Wedged Ball Rule 07.12.2022

What happens if the ball gets wedged between the pin and the green? Find out about this very new rule and if you agree ... or not!

Special Edition 19: Basketball's Health of the NBA 03.12.2022

Tune in for this discussion between Ben and Greg regarding today's NBA and the state of the league.

Episode 69: Basketball - The Take Foul Rule 30.11.2022

Foul after foul after foul. Ugh. Find out about this new rule and what the NBA's intention is behind it.

Special Edition 18: More Obscure Rules in Baseball 26.11.2022

Tune in to hear some rather obscure rules that are still in the baseball rule book. See how many you know and how many are new to you!

Episode 67: Baseball - The Mound Visit Rule 23.11.2022

How many times can a manager visit the mound? Yes, there is a limit and find out why this is a rule and if it should remain in the rule book!

Special Edition 17: Basketball's NBA vs NCAA differences 19.11.2022

Greg and Ben discuss some of the major differences between NBA and NCAA basketball - and why they even exist in the first place!

Episode 66: Footbal - The Gameday Hat Rule 18.11.2022

You know those hats that players wear on the sidelines? Yes, there are actually rules around those. Listen and find out what the deal is - and if you agree.

Special Edition 16: Football's Altered Rules 12.11.2022

Not all rules are set in stone. Find out which rules have changed over the years, why they changed, and if you think the changes were good or maybe not so good!

Episode 62: Football - Top 20 Unwritten Rules 04.11.2022

Did you know it's not just baseball that has unwritten rules? Find out what some of these are in football - some of them may surprise you!

Episode 61: Golf - The Bunker Rule 02.11.2022

So what happens when you hit your ball into the bunker? What can and can't you do? Find out the answers to these questions and decide if you think it's a dumb rule or not!

Episode 59: Football -Forward Pass Oddities 26.10.2022

We all love the forward pass in football. However, that was not always the case. Find out some history behind this play and how it came to be what it is today.

Special Edition 14: Football's Divisional Alignments 22.10.2022

If you look at a map of the USA, you will see some clear boundaries that make up the 8 divisions in the NFL. But, why are some teams just out of place? Find out why this is and the history behind the NFL divisions!

Episode 58: Baseball - The Position Player Pitching Rule 20.10.2022

So we've all seen cases where a position player comes in to pitch in a game. Did you know there are rules around if and when that can happen? Find out what this rule is all about and decide if you think it's a good rule or not.

Episode 57: Basketball - The Strict Dress Code Rule 19.10.2022

What's the deal with the dress code rule in basketball? Find out when this was added, how much it is actually enforced and decide for yourself if you think it's a good thing or not.

Special Edition 13: The 1983 NFL Redraft 15.10.2022

The 1983 NFL draft was jam-packed with future hall-of-famers. Greg and Ben put on their NFL owner hats and do a re-draft of this iconic draft year. See if you agree with their picks!

Listen to the That's A Dumb Rule podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.