Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

That's A Dumb Rule

Sports EN ↓ 157 episodes

Discover some of the strangest, obscure or downright silly rules in sports that have you asking “is that a dumb rule?” Listen in on the conversations between two sports enthusiasts wanting to answer this question. Some rules you already know, others are the industry’s best-kept secrets. Find out what they are, the history behind them, and judge for yourself if it’s a dumb rule or not!

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: redcircle.com

Author

Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

Category

Sports

Podcast website

redcircle.com

Latest episode

Apr 5, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 55: Baseball - The Manager Wearing Uniform Rule 12.10.2022

Ok, what's the deal with baseball managers wearing uniforms? I mean, are we still in the 1930's? Can we please put a stop to the madness? Check out why this is still the case today and if it should be outlawed!

Special Edition 11: The Numbers Game - 76-99 01.10.2022

Greg and Ben debate who the best athletes were to wear jersey numbers 76-99.

Episode 52: Hockey - The Goalie Replacement in Shootout 30.09.2022

Find out why you can't just replace your goalie in a shootout and the history behind this really bizarre rule.

Special Edition 10: The Numbers Game - 51-75 24.09.2022

Greg and Ben debate who the best athletes were to wear jersey numbers 51-75.

Episode 49: Golf - The Crowd Silence Rule 21.09.2022

Why does everyone have to hush-up when a golfer is about to swing? Yet a fan can make as much noise as they want at a football game. Find out why this is and the history behind this ... rule?

Special Edition 09: The Numbers Game - 26-50 17.09.2022

Greg and Ben debate who the best athletes were to wear jersey numbers 26-50.

Episode 47: Football - The Helmet Rule 14.09.2022

You know those sweet creamsicle helmets that Tampa Bay used to wear? Find out why we haven't seen them in a while and if there's a chance they may come back!

Special Edition 08: The Numbers Game - 00-25 10.09.2022

Greg and Ben debate who the best athletes were to wear jersey numbers 00-25.

Episode 46: Football - Notable Rule Changes 09.09.2022

Find out some of the bizarre and hilarious rules from days gone by. Some of these are just crazy!

Special Edition 07: 2022 Fantasy QB Mock Draft 03.09.2022

Greg and Ben go through the top 10 QB's in this year's NFL Draft. Find out which QB's make the cut, and which ones are left behind.

Special Edition 06: Football - 2022 Rules 28.08.2022

Greg and Ben review the rule changes for the upcoming 2022 NFL season.

Episode 42: Basketball - The No Shatter Rule 26.08.2022

While it may look cool, shattering a backboard is a big no-no in the NBA. Find out why there is a rule behind this and if you think it should stay or go.

Special Edition 05: Football - History of the Gridiron 20.08.2022

Find out the history of the mighty gridiron and some of the crazy stories that helped shaped the field as we know it today.

Special Edition 04: Football - The Bye Weeks 13.08.2022

Find out why they have bye weeks in the NFL and the scheduling madness behind them!

Episode 38: Hockey - The Disagree with Referee Rule 12.08.2022

Sure, you can disagree with the referee .. but what happens if you let them know in uncertain terms? Find out why this rule is, well, really weird.

Special Edition 03: Baseball - 2022 Rules 06.08.2022

Get a rundown of the new rules that were added for the 2022 MLB season.

Episode 35: Basketball - The Defensive 3-second Rule 03.08.2022

Find out what the 3-second rule really means - and if it's one we can do without.

Episode 31: Football - The Coaches Challenge Rule 20.07.2022

What exactly is the correct procedure for challenging a play? Find out when challenging is allowed, when it's not, and why?

Episode 29: Baseball - Ballpark Dimensions 13.07.2022

Why on earth is every major league ballpark a different size? Find out why this is the case and can we please stop the madness?

Special Announcement: New Web Site! 13.07.2022

Check out our new Web site at www.thatsadumbrule.com. Find out how this whole thing started, listen to past episodes, view our mock draft boards and even contact us if you have any ideas for the show!

Episode 26: Football - The Headphone Helmet Rule 01.07.2022

Are the glory days of the quarterback calling plays a thing of the past? Find out what the rules are around headphone helmets and if it's a good or bad thing for the wonderful game of football.

Episode 25: Baseball - The Shift Rule 29.06.2022

Does the shift in baseball really help a team defensively? Find out why this fairly recent phenomenon has gained popularity and if it really makes a difference ... or not.

Episode 24: Baseball - The Home Field Advantage Rule 24.06.2022

Which team gets home field advantage during the World Series? Find out why this rule was changed after 98 years, and why it has changed four times since.

Episode 23: Football - The Overtime Scoring Rule 22.06.2022

Are the NFL overtime scoring rules fair, or are we in for yet more changes? Is there an easy answer to this seemingly complex problem? Find out the history behind this rule and if you think it should be changed!

Episode 21: Baseball - The Designated Hitter Rule 15.06.2022

Is the Designated Hitter a good thing or bad thing for baseball? Find out about the almost 50-year history behind this position and the impact it has had on the game.

Listen to the That's A Dumb Rule podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.