Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

That's A Dumb Rule

Sports EN ↓ 157 episodes

Discover some of the strangest, obscure or downright silly rules in sports that have you asking “is that a dumb rule?” Listen in on the conversations between two sports enthusiasts wanting to answer this question. Some rules you already know, others are the industry’s best-kept secrets. Find out what they are, the history behind them, and judge for yourself if it’s a dumb rule or not!

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: redcircle.com

Author

Greg Selner and Ben Seifert

Category

Sports

Podcast website

redcircle.com

Latest episode

Apr 5, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

REPUBLISHED - Episode 36: Baseball - The Pitch Clock Rule 12.05.2023

Does a pitch clock really help speed up the game, or is it another attempt at trying to fix something that isn't broken? Find out what this is and if it helps or hurts baseball.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 27: Baseball - The Balk Rule 10.05.2023

What exactly is a balk in baseball? Find out why this rule is in the rule book and whether or not you agree with it!

REPUBLISHED - Special Edition 15: Basketball's Draft Lottery 06.05.2023

The NBA Draft Lottery .. oh the madness behind it! Find out how it works and if you think it's the best way to do it.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 22: Baseball - The Ambidextrous Pitcher Rule 05.05.2023

Can a pitcher pitch with either arm? Is that even legal? Find out about this rule and why it was added to the rule book!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 54: Basketball - The Original 13 Rules 03.05.2023

Find out what the original 13 rules were in basketball, and how much the game has changed since then!

Special Edition 25: MLB Divisional Realignment 29.04.2023

If you look at a map and see how the various MLB divisions are configured, you may leave scratching your head. Why are the divisions set up like this and would baseball benefit for another realignment?

REPUBLISHED - Episode 15: Baseball - The Making Outs in Foul Territory Rule 28.04.2023

Very few sports allow you to play the ball out of bounds - and yet baseball is one of them. Find out this history of this very old and strange rule.

Episode 80: Football - The Franchise Tag Rule 27.04.2023

The Franchise Tag. We hear this a lot in sports talk, but what does it really mean? And more importantly, is it good for the game or not so much? Tune in to find out what this rather vague term really means!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 13: Baseball - The Ball Stuck in Mask Rule 26.04.2023

Do you know what happens if the ball gets stuck in the catcher's mask? You'd be surprised on how much this simple thing can impact a game!

Special Edition 33: NBA Team Nicknames 23.04.2023

Have you ever wondered where the nicknames of the NBA team originated from? Some are pretty obvious, but what about the others? Tune in and find out the history behind the Celtics, Jazz, Rockets and more!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 12: Baseball - The Automatic Strike Rule 21.04.2023

Find out how a strike can be called on a batter without the batter even being in the batters box! Yes, it happens more than you think.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 41: Golf - The Unsigned Scorecard Rule 19.04.2023

So you forgot to sign your scorecard .. big deal, right? Oh yes, let me tell you it is a big deal and find out what happens if you forget!

REPUBLISHED - Special Edition 02: Baseball - History of Notable Rule Changes 15.04.2023

Greg and Ben review some of the original rules as well as more recent rule changes to the great game of Baseball.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 9: Baseball - The Infield Fly Rule 14.04.2023

Did you know that a batter can be called automatically out - even if a fielder drops the ball. Seems a bit unfair, but find out why this rule is in the rulebook!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 5: Baseball - The Dropped 3rd Strike Rule 12.04.2023

Did you know a batter can reach first base safely, even after striking out? It happens more than you think. Find out the history behind this very old rule.

Commissioner for a Day Series - Episode 01 - MLB Baseball 11.04.2023

Tune in to hear our first episode of our new series "Commissioner for a Day". In this episode, find out what changes Greg would make to Major League Baseball and if you agree with them .. or not!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 68: Basketball's Play-In Tournament 08.04.2023

Is it good that 66% of teams make the playoffs? Find out more about this fairly new playoff format and if you think it should be in or out.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 32: Baseball - The Ground Rule Double Rule 07.04.2023

What exactly is a Ground Rule Double? Or how about an Automatic Double? Find out if there is a difference between these two and if they are both dumb rules!

Special Edition 31: Golf's 7 Most Unbreakable Records 06.04.2023

Ahh - golf. One of the oldest sports and yet still has not been mastered. Tune in to hear about the seven records that may never be broken!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 18: Baseball - Tie Goes to the Runner Rule 05.04.2023

We've all heard that a tie goes to the runner. Hold on folks. Is this really the case, or just something we made up to yell at the umpire? Find out if this is actually a rule or not!

Special Edition 26: Upcoming NBA CBA discussion 01.04.2023

Tune in to hear Ben's thoughts on the upcoming collective bargaining agreement (CBA) between the NBA players and owners. Who will come out ahead and will the new agreement help or hurt the game?

REPUBLISHED - Episode 3: Baseball - The Catcher's Balk Rule 31.03.2023

Did you know a that catcher can be called for a balk? Yes, a catcher. Find out how this can happen and the history behind this rule.

REPUBLISHED - Episode 19: Basketball - No Long Free Throws Rule 29.03.2023

How long can a player really take to shoot a free-throw? Some may take a few seconds, others seem to take a virtual eternity. Find out what the actual rule is behind this part of basketball and if it's ever enforced.

Special Edition 23: Baseball’s 41 Most Unbreakable Records 25.03.2023

Records are meant to be broken, right? Well we think there are some records in baseball that will never ever be broken. Tune in and find out which ones!

REPUBLISHED - Episode 64: Baseball - The Baserunner Basepath Rule 24.03.2023

When does a baserunner actually go out of the basepath? It may not be what you think - listen to find out!

Listen to the That's A Dumb Rule podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.