Ryan and Emily Baker

Story Matters Podcast

Religion EN ↓ 63 episodes

In the Story Matters Podcast, Hosts Ryan and Emily Baker discuss the intersection between theology and psychology helping listeners to better grasp how their particular stories have shaped them.

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: storymatterspodcast.buzzsprout.com

Author

Ryan and Emily Baker

Category

Religion

Latest episode

Nov 17, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

63. Four Signs of Codependency & the Paradox of Loving Others as Yourself (S5, E11 17.11.2026

Codependency can look like sacrificial love, loyalty, and even spiritual maturity, but it often hides a quieter truth: I don’t feel okay unless you feel okay about me. We sit with the confusion so many people feel, especially in Christian relationships, where God’s Word seems to support the four signs.   We break codependency into four markers you can actually watch for in your daily life: externa...

62. Good Toil in Every Season? (S5 E10 Paradox 6) 10.11.2026

We wrestle with the paradox of Ecclesiastes and the uncomfortable truth that we cannot control our lives, even though our choices and daily actions still matter. We talk about “toil,” seasons or times of our lives, and the freedom that comes when we trust God’s larger story without demanding immediate results.  • the central paradox of uncertainty alongside real significance  • eternity placed in...

61. Q & A: Understanding our Story, Theology & Relationships (S5 E9) 03.11.2026

We take a quick break from Season 5's Paradox Series to answer six listener questions. We lay out the foundations of narrative-focused trauma care and why Story Work matters for Christian growth.  The Questions and their time stamps are: 1:23 I have a friend who has seen the impact “story work” has had on my life and yet at the same time is very resistant to the idea that Christians need to l...

60. Strive or Rest? (S5 E8 Paradox 5) 20.10.2026

The push to achieve can feel like obedience, and the pull to rest can feel like faith, but being called to both feels confusing.  We sit in the paradox of Christian contentment and righteous striving, and we talk about why one-sided advice and spiritual platitudes leave people stuck, ashamed, or exhausted. We ground the conversation in two popular verses by Paul from his letter to the Philippians,...

59. Are You Being Generous or A Good Steward? (S5 E7 Paradox 4) 13.10.2026

Generosity gets complicated fast when the need is real, the ask is specific, and the cost lands on your marriage, your family, or your mental and financial health. Ryan and Emily wrestle with a paradox many Christians feel: Jesus calls us to sacrificial giving, and wisdom literature warns us not to overextend, go into unwise debt, or enable someone else’s dysfunction. We walk through what we call...

58. Called to Love: With Boundaries or By Remaining? (S5 E6 Paradox 3) 06.10.2026

Wise as serpents and innocent as doves: we explore why love gets confusing when Jesus calls us to be both at the same time. We sit with one of Jesus’ most challenging tensions and ask what that actually looks like when someone is undermining you, harming you, or simply wearing you down. Loving your enemies, honoring parents, forgiving again and again, avoiding toxic people, confronting sin, turnin...

57. Is It Them or Is It Me? (S5 E5) 29.09.2026

The quickest way to get stuck in healing is to force a simple answer onto a complex story. We keep meeting people who hesitate to look at childhood wounds because it feels like blaming parents, excusing bad choices, or losing agency. At the same time, we’ve also seen the “whiplash” where new awareness turns into contempt and everything becomes someone else’s fault. Neither path tells the whole tru...

56. To Judge or Not To Judge (S5 E4) 21.09.2026

“Don’t judge” sounds simple until someone gets hurt, a leader falls, or a friend drops a one-sided story in your lap. We wrestle with the real-world paradox Scripture puts in front of us: Jesus warns against judging others, and yet also says to “judge with right judgment” and Paul also talks about discernment inside the church. We need wisdom that can take-on complexity. We dig into the moment whe...

55. Feeling Stuck? A Conversation Worth Revisiting 30: Intensifying Your Binds! (S5 E3) 15.09.2026

We step back into an older conversation that sets the foundation for our Season 5 on Paradoxes, starting with how to recognize a bind when neither option feels like a true way out.  This is a re-release of Episode 30 "Intensifying Your Binds"  from our 4 part Series on Shame.  We use Robert Frost’s poem “The Road Not Taken” as an image for how badly we want certainty. Pop culture turns t...

54. "It is what it is" or Do We Have a Choice? (S5 E2) 08.09.2026

That flat feeling behind “it is what it is” usually isn’t wisdom or maturity. It’s often a clue that we’ve slowly lost agency and think there is no choice in the matter. Ryan and Emily share a three-step practice that helps us notice choice points earlier, hold paradox with clarity, and make decisions with more honesty before God. We offer a simple, practical framework you can use right away: bind...

53. You are in a Bind! (Season 5 Intro) 01.09.2026

Burnout you can’t explain, people pleasing you can’t stop, co-existing with anxiety, resentment that keeps leaking into your closest relationships, or habits that numb you just enough to get through the week. We start Season Five by naming a common root under all of it: the binds that exist in your life that you have not fully named. We talk about how our “non-negotiables” in decision-making momen...

52.Can We Just Not Tie a Bow On It? 12.05.2026

Season Four wrap up! When stories are unresolved, our bodies feel the tension so we often divert by looking for a way to tie everything up with a bow. “It’s fine.” “It’ll all work out.” Even faith language can become a bow we use to exit the pain before we’ve actually felt it. We talk about silver linings that bypass grief, the pressure to explain suffering, and J. I. Packer’s train yard illustrat...

51. They Will Know We Are Christians By How We Repair 05.05.2026

“They will know we are Christians by our love” is true, but what if the clearest proof of love is our ability to repair after rupture? Ryan and Emily Baker dig into why repair is strangely missing as a category in many Christian families, churches, and faith-based organizations and why that absence makes communities fragile instead of safe. We talk about “weak systems” and how good intentions don’...

50. Have You Experienced Betrayal? 28.04.2026

Betrayal is brutal: it takes a relationship, a community, or an institution that was supposed to be safe and turns it into a source of harm.  We unpack betrayal trauma through the lens of shalom, the way things are supposed to be, and we talk about the “ripple effect” that spreads into your limbic system, your future relationships, and your view of God. We also name the amplification that happens...

49. Can We Call This What It Really Is? 21.04.2026

Gossip sneaks in dressed up as concern, processing, connecting, or the classic church-friendly cover of a prayer request.  We talk through a gut-check illustration that still gets us: what if a device instantly alerted someone the moment you started talking about them? We expose the hidden contract gossip creates between the speaker and the listener, where we quietly step into the seat of judge wh...

48. Why Are You Here? 13.04.2026

We talk about the motives that bring people to this podcast, narrative-focused trauma care, counseling, and discipleship. We love the desires that drive us, and we also name the risk. When we use Jesus as a tool to get a specific outcome, we shrink the gospel. Drawing on C.S. Lewis, we explore that in seeking God first, we trust that the fruit we’re craving often gets thrown in as a byproduct. Fro...

47. Here Be Dragons - An Interview with Author Melanie Shankle Pt. 2 07.04.2026

Emily continues her conversation with author and podcaster Melanie Shankle to talk about her memoir Here Be Dragons and the surprising metaphor that helped her finally see boundaries clearly: her dog’s leg amputation. The loss was painful, but it also removed the source of constant suffering and made room for real freedom. That same question hangs over so many of our lives: what are we still toler...

46. Here Be Dragons - An Interview with Author, Melanie Shankle Pt. 1 31.03.2026

Some family pain doesn’t look dramatic from the outside, which is exactly why it can trap you for decades. Emily sits down with three-time New York Times bestselling author Melanie Shankle to talk about her book "Here Be Dragons."  We talk about how helping a daughter navigate mean girls uncovered a deeper story of generational trauma, people pleasing, and the old parental scripts that s...

45. Why We Avoid What Heals Us 23.03.2026

Resistance is something we all feel at times. We know growth is good, we know story work matters, and yet we'd rather stay in “get things done” mode rather than feel what’s tender. We lean into that tension of a nervous system that doesn’t want to shift gears.  When we lack flexibility, we get stuck in one state of being and even small endeavors like journaling can feel costly.  We talk throu...

44. I Believe, Help My Unbelief pt.4 17.03.2026

This is an updated and edited episode replacing the one we accidentally published two weeks ago.  In it we discuss how your mind can say “I trust God” while your body quietly braces for abandonment. That tension is not a character flaw, it’s often a story. We sit with the hard reality of a divided self: the logical part of us reaches for faith, while the limbic system carries old alarms that flare...

43. I Believe, Help My Unbelief pt.3 09.03.2026

In this conversation, drawing from Mark 9, Romans 7, and Romans 12, we unpack ambivalence. Two opposing truths can freeze the body, fog the mind, and keep the heart guarded. Rather than calling one wrong and another right, we ask what each part is protecting, and we invite Jesus to carry the burden those defenses have held for years. We explore why evil can look orderly and why legalism masquerade...

42. I Believe, Help My Unbelief pt. 2 24.02.2026

Ever set a bold goal only to watch your body reach for the old comfort? We pull back the curtain on why change feels like a tug-of-war, showing how the limbic system, dopamine, and attachment history shape cravings—and why that makes perfect sense. Rather than shaming the body or glorifying willpower, we map a kinder route to lasting transformation where faith and neuroscience meet. We unpack the...

41. I Believe, Help My Unbelief pt. 1 17.02.2026

We kick off Season 4 with a timely exploration of goals, Lent, and the deeper workings of the human heart. Drawing from neuroscience and Christian spiritual formation, we unpack why 80–90% of our daily actions originate in the limbic system and how that reality reframes change, healing, and sanctification. We define the “inner world” of the heart—emotions, memory, and subconscious patterns and the...

40. Bonus Re-Release "The Holidays" When Longing For Home Meets The Ache Of Reality 25.11.2025

In Season 1 we had a conversation the week of Thanksgiving that we want to share again as we conclude Season 3. Holiday tables can be warm, funny, and deeply desired—and they can also be minefields of subtle jabs, old roles, and unspoken rules. We name the ache beneath nostalgia and share a grounded, faith-based way to move from autopilot to awareness so you can keep your peace without losing your...

39. Tender Hearts, Strong Hope: More with Mary Ellen Owen 18.11.2025

What if the shortest path to joy runs straight through your tears? We sit down with Mary Ellen Owen to unpack why uncomforted harm teaches us to banish tenderness, how that “closed book” stance blocks love, and why grief— often done in the presence of a safe other—becomes embodied surrender that restores our capacity for connection. This conversation bridges trauma theory, attachment, and Christia...

Listen to the Story Matters Podcast podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.