Megan and Lindsay

Sinners Among Saints

History EN ↓ 206 episodes

Hey Sinners! It's us, Megan Keyes and Lindsay Martinez.  Welcome to "Sinners Among Saints," the chilling true crime podcast that delves deep into the dark underbelly of society. Created by two best friends hailing from Utah, who share a passion for all things horror, this podcast aims to shed light on the victims of heinous crimes that often go unnoticed. Join us as we navigate through the twisted tales of real-life monsters and the innocent souls they prey on.  With meticulous research, compelling storytelling, and a lighthearted feeling of chasing with friends, "Sinners Among Saints" takes y...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.sinnersamongsaintspodcast.com

Author

Megan and Lindsay

Category

History

Latest episode

Oct 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 55: The 1947 UFO Craze 20.10.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we jump back to 1947, America in the height of war. With World War II just ending and the Cold War ramping up we were on edge to say the least but nothing could prepare the American people for what was coming next. On June 24, 1947 Kenneth Arnold would report a sighting of nine unidentified flying objects and once that hit the media we couldn't stop the sightings fr...

Episode 54: The Origin of Halloween 13.10.2023

Send us Fan Mail To continue our spooky October theme, this week we will be discussing where some of our Halloween traditions started.  We cover Halloween itself and how's it has evolved, truck or treating, Jack o lanterns, and costumes. We will also cover the origin stories of the creepy vampire and body Mary!  It's like a fun and creepy history lesson with your bestie♥️  Support the sh...

Episode 53: The Ohio State Reformatory 06.10.2023

Send us Fan Mail Join us this week as we head to Mansfield, Ohio to take an in depth look at the Ohio State Reformatory. It opened in 1896 and ran until the 1990s. While there were the typical death and violence, this building also houses many stuck souls. It has been the focal point of many movies and music videos over the years, including The Shawshank Redemption.  Support the show Thanks for al...

Episode 52: Roylynn Rides Horse 29.09.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay takes you to Montana to the Crow reservation to discuss the very sad tale of Roylynn Rides Horse, a Native American woman who was left alone to suffer unthinkable pain. She's was a mother, daughter, Aunt, sister, cousin, and friend. Her case didn't get much attention, which is the unfortunate reality for many missing and murdered indigenous women. We ho...

Episode 51: Delimar Vera 22.09.2023

Send us Fan Mail Just before Christmas in 1997, a family had their world turned upside down when a fire broke out in their home. All family members were taken out of the home except 10 day old Delimar Vera. Delimar was asleep in the upstairs bedroom and when her mother, Luzaida, reached Delimar's room she was no where to be found. Wrought with panic, Luzaida was evntually forced outside by th...

50: The Ken and Barbie Killers // Part 2 15.09.2023

Send us Fan Mail This we cover part 2 of the Ken and Barbie killers, Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo. We delve into the torture and murder of Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French, 2 young girls.  We then discuss the downfall of this couple, the deal with devil,  the trial and beyond!! There so many twists in this case so hang on and Tune in for this insane sin! Support the show Thanks for all the sup...

Episode 49: The Ken and Barbie Killers // Part 1 08.09.2023

Send us Fan Mail For this episode, Lindsay takes us on a ride to Canada to discuss one of their most infamous cases. Paul Bernardo is the Scarborough rapist and is terrible enough on his own but when he meets his other half Karla Homolka, things get even worse. These two rape and torture teenage girls and go on to do do other horrific things, including the murder of three victims. Hold onto your p...

Episode 48: Leonarda Cianciulli: The Soap Maker of Correggio 12.08.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we are heading to World War II era Italy where the love and devotion of one mother for her son goes beyond anyone's imagination. In the mind of Leonarda Cianciulli, she's only protecting her son but at what cost and to who? Tune in this week for tht story of The Soap Maker of Correggio.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook...

Episode 47: The Fremont Bridge 04.08.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we are headed to the small town of Casper, Wyoming to hear a horrific, harrowing, and very sad tale involving two sisters. The oldest sister has a truly inspiring will to live and help her little sister but unfortunately that isn't enough. This is the story of The Fremont Bridge.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram,...

Episode 46: NXIVM // The Cult of Personality 28.07.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we take a murder reprieve and instead take a look into what one cult expert refers to as "the most destructive cult in history". We take a look into Keith Raniere and what he posed as a "self-help" organization called NXIVM. On the outside you think you are getting some self-help courses to be a more successful and better person but what you really ge...

Episode 45: Armin Meiwes "The Rotenburg Cannibal" 21.07.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay takes us all the way to Germany for a completely insane case! Two men, with similar background would go on to be bonded for life in a way most people are terrified of. Armin Meiwes had a strong desire, from a very young age,  to consume human flesh! When he turns to the Internet for help, he finds a very willing victim Bernd Brandes, who volunteers to be eaten! T...

Episode 44: The Torture and Murder of Sylvia Likens // Part 3 14.07.2023

Send us Fan Mail The final piece of the story. Thank you so much for sticking with us through this brutal case. Gertrude Baniszewski is truly a horrific person and I hope she's getting hers for all eternity! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!   patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodca...

Episode 43: The Torture and Murder of Sylvia Likens // Part 2 07.07.2023

Send us Fan Mail ***TRIGGER WARNING*** We don't normally place a trigger warning on our episodes because well you know what you're getting into when listening to true crime but this one is especially brutal. The things that happen to such the sweet, innocent 15 year old, Sylvia are hard to hear so just prepare yourself or check back in on another case. Thanks for listening and for suppor...

Episode 42: The Torture and Murder of Sylvia Likens // Part 1 30.06.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Megan takes us back to the 1960s when life was tough and trust in others was strong. When Sylvia's parents head off with the carnival and leave her and her younger sister with a complete stranger, they expect to come back in a few months with a few extra dollars and continue life with all of their children but before they can return their third child, Sylvia, will h...

Episode 41: Cryptids: Skinwalkers 23.06.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay takes us back to the paranormal as we discuss the creepy AF skinwalkers! We will talk about origin stories, strengths, weaknesses, and appearance, Then, for the first time we have some listener stories which give us some personal insight to these cryptids! We hope you enjoy!! **THIS WEEKS SOUL CLEANSE** Michael Jordan has become the given the largest single donat...

Episode 40: Torture throughout history 16.06.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Megan takes us into the dark and disturbing world of torture. We will talk a little about what it is and why it is done, different methods and just how a torture survivor might feel. Come join us in this week's episode!!  **THIS WEEK'S SOUL CLEANSE** We head to St. Louis where a mom placed an ad for men ages 20-28 to come play video games with her 24 year old s...

Episode 39: The Pike County Massacre 09.06.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay rashes us to the small rural town of Peebles, OH to cover the Pike county massacre. There are a total of 8 victims in 4 locations, all killed on the same night. Marijuana grow sites are find in 3 of the locations and suspicion turns to the drug cartel. But soon this theory is dismissed only to realize the truth is much worse. Another local family, the Wagner&apos...

Episode 38: Ed Kemper // Part 3 02.06.2023

Send us Fan Mail Ok guys, this is the final episode!! In this one we will go over Kemper's final two kills, his capture/surrender, court, prison, and where he is now.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!   patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast sinnersamongsaintspodcast@gmail.com T...

Episode 37: Ed Kemper // Part 2 26.05.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we are taking a look into Ed's life after Atascadero and his next 6 murders. Mary Ann Pesce, Anita Luchessa, Aiko Koo, Cindy Schall, Rosalind Thorpe, and Alice Liu.  Get all comfy and let's get into this, it's a rough one but nothing about Ed Kemper is easy! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok,...

Episode 36: Ed Kemper // Part 1 19.05.2023

Send us Fan Mail We are jumping into one of the most well known serial killers, Edmund Emil Kemper, A.K.A. The Co-Ed Killer, The Co-Ed Butcher, Ogre of Aptos, The Mad Titan, and my favorite "Big Ed". He began murdering at age 15 and continued into his adulthood until finally killing the one person who seemingly sent him into these rages in April of 1973 at age 25. He's a dichotomy o...

Episode 35: Stephen and Tara Grant // Part 2 28.04.2023

Send us Fan Mail Part 2 of 2 This week we finish up talking about the monster Stephen Grant aka the og crazy eyes!  We go into the murder and dismemberment of Tara, the trial, and so much more horror!  I'll never understand how people can murder someone they've built a life with then after brutally taking them away from everyone they loved, just have casual conversations about all the de...

Episode 34: Stephen and Tara Grant // Part 1 21.04.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week is part 1 of 2 of the horrific murder of Tara Grant.  It's a typical love story- boy meets girl in college and they fall in love.  Boy and girl have 2 beautiful children. Girl becomes a high powered Boss Bitch and boy is slightly emasculated. Boy turns to hot, young au pair to help deal with his fragile manhood and then decides he doesn't love his wife anymore....

Episode 33: The Abuse and Murder of Ethan Stacy // Part 2 14.04.2023

Send us Fan Mail ** Trigger warning... This whole episode is about child abuse and eventual murder with some pretty graphic details.** Here is part 2. It's important you hear the whole story and find out what happens to these disgusting, deplorable humans. I can honestly say I have never heard of more evil people than these two.  Check out our patreon, the support helps us make more and bette...

Episode 32: The Abuse and Murder of Ethan Stacy // Part 1 14.04.2023

Send us Fan Mail **Trigger warning... This whole episode is about child abuse and eventual murder with some pretty graphic details.** Ok guys, this week we are releasing just one of our Patreon episodes so that you can all see what you are missing out on, Now they are not all as difficult as this one is to listen to but through all the horrific details of this case we think Ethan deserves for peop...

Episode 31: Cold Case Edition 1 07.04.2023

Send us Fan Mail Welcome to our very first cold case edition!! We had a request for the Johanna Leatherbury case and once I realized there wasn't a lot of information I decided to put together a compilation of Utah cold cases. In this episode we cover: 1. Johanna Leatherbury - Unsolved Homicide 8/20/1971 2. Ann Marie Woodward -  Unsolved Homicide 3/1/1973 3. Carolyn Yvonne Kingston - Unsolved...

Listen to the Sinners Among Saints podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.