Megan and Lindsay

Sinners Among Saints

History EN ↓ 206 episodes

Hey Sinners! It's us, Megan Keyes and Lindsay Martinez.  Welcome to "Sinners Among Saints," the chilling true crime podcast that delves deep into the dark underbelly of society. Created by two best friends hailing from Utah, who share a passion for all things horror, this podcast aims to shed light on the victims of heinous crimes that often go unnoticed. Join us as we navigate through the twisted tales of real-life monsters and the innocent souls they prey on.  With meticulous research, compelling storytelling, and a lighthearted feeling of chasing with friends, "Sinners Among Saints" takes y...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.sinnersamongsaintspodcast.com

Author

Megan and Lindsay

Category

History

Latest episode

Oct 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 30: Lawrence Anderson 31.03.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay covers a very recent case from Oklahoma. Lawrence Paul Anderson had his prison sentence committed and is released from prison early... Which ends up being proven a mistake. Just 3 weeks later he goes on to kill house unless lean Pye, his great niece Kaeos Yates, and their neighbor Andrea Blankenship. He also tried to kill his aunt Delsie Pye by stabbing her multi...

Episode 29: The Senseless Murder of Daniel Halseth 24.03.2023

Send us Fan Mail ** This Week's Soul Cleanse** 17 Year old Grace Pontzer was at her local Planet Fitness working out with friends when  a man across the gym fell off of his treadmill. She really didn't think anything of it until she noticed that the man was not getting up. Concerned, she ran to see if he was alright. When she got to him, she noticed he was unresponsive. Being newly CPR c...

Episode 28: Martin and Michele MacNeill // Part 3 17.03.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we will be finishing up the Martin and Michele MacNeill case! It has been a long ride so don't miss out on the ending! We will go into the charges, trial, and sentencing. We also talk even more about the crazy connection of Gypsy and Martin! The book Lindsay suggested in this episode is:  The Stranger She Loved  by Shanna Hogan Support the show Thanks for all the su...

Episode 27: Martin and Michele MacNeill // Part 2 10.03.2023

Send us Fan Mail This week we cover the second part of Martin and Michele MacNeill. We delve more into Marin's mistresses, his deceit and lies, Michele's death and autopsy, and more about the terrible person Martin is! He will go on to sexually assault one of his daughters while offering to kill another! Hang in for this crazy ride! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please fo...

Episode 26: Martin and Michele MacNeill // Part 1 03.03.2023

Send us Fan Mail **Soul Cleanse** This week we head to Tennessee where Sergio Peralta, a sophomore in a new high school, gets an unexpected life changing surprise. He was born with an underdeveloped hand and while he tried to keep it hidden, the school's engineering teacher and some of his students took it upon themselves to freaking 3D print him a hand!! This week Lindsay brings us part 1 of...

Episode 25: The Bermuda Triangle and The Queen Mary 24.02.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This Weeks Soul Cleanse** This week we talk about Shauna Devenport A.K.A. "The Bread Lady". For over 30 years this wonderful woman has been placing food on her porch for the less fortunate. Most of us can't even keep up with our New Year's resolutions for longer than a couple weeks let alone continually do something for others for over 30 years!! She's a...

Episode 24: Israel Keyes // Part 2 17.02.2023

Send us Fan Mail Welcome back for part 2 on Israel Keyes. This week we will go over what happens after his arrest, listen to some FBI interview audio and talk about where he is now. Tune in for some wild content!! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!   patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodc...

Episode 23: Israel Keyes // Part 1 10.02.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This Weeks Soul Cleanse** This weeks soul cleanse focuses on Smith Alley and his amazing life path, The Live Life Bigger Foundation. He is the founder and has one of the most touching stories. As a young teen, he found himself on the brink of committing suicide after  enduing bullying for a speech issue and size plus an addiction to pornography, something he was exposed to at an...

Episode 22: The Senseless Murders of Derek Davis and Chad Grijalva 03.02.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This Weeks Soul Cleanse** This week we are shining a spotlight on an amazing person with an amazing idea. His name is Iuri Melo and after being contacted by a Utah principal about the rising cases of teen suicide, he came up with SchoolPulse.  This is a text based platform that allows students the opportunity to speak up about their feelings in a way that is easy and familiar to...

Episode 21: Aza Ray Vidinhar 27.01.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This Week's Soul Cleanse** This week we are highlighting the People Helping People organization here in Utah. It is a program dedicated to helping low-income women and single moms reach their full potential in the workplace. PHP helps families break the cycle of poverty by teaching women how to earn a living wage. If you would like more information or to donate you can reac...

Episode 20: Mina Pajela 20.01.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This Weeks Soul Cleanse** A woman who was attacked by a man who was just out looking to kill, survived this terrifying attack and after recovering in the ICU, she was really upset about the brand new Cardinals jersey that she was wearing during the attack because it was ruined. The Davis County Sheriff's Department learned about this and pooled money together and bought her...

Episode 19: Jeremy Hauck // Part 2 13.01.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This weeks Soul Cleanse** This week we highlight Jaydenn, a little 9 year old boy here in West Valley whose birthday is on New Year's Eve and when no one showed up to celebrate his day, his mom took to Facebook just asking that people wish him a happy birthday so he knew that people did care. In turn, people started sending gifts and money to him all throughout the weekend...

Episode 18: Jeremy Hauck // Part 1 12.01.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This weeks Soul Cleanse** This week we highlight Jaydenn, a little 9 year old boy here in West Valley whose birthday is on New Year's Eve and when no one showed up to celebrate his day, his mom took to Facebook just asking that people wish him a happy birthday so he knew that people did care. In turn, people started sending gifts and money to him all throughout the weekend...

Episode 17: The Clearfield Rapist // Part 2 06.01.2023

Send us Fan Mail **This weeks Soul Cleanse** This is a story about Sierra Sandoval, a mother of a four-year-old son and a six-month-old baby girl. Her daughter had just recently gotten out of the hospital after having RSV and the family was stressed with holiday expenses and medical bills. While at Walmart in Layton, UT, a little boy came up to her in the store and gave her an envelope saying, &qu...

Episode 16: The Clearfield Rapist // Part 1 30.12.2022

Send us Fan Mail **THIS WEEKS SOUL CLEANSE** This week we talk about the cutest little 5 year old here in Utah, named Raxon "Bubba" Garza. He is a business owner and entrepreneur. He sounds like an amazing little boy who is just wanting to bring happiness to others while fulfilling some financial goals like making enough money to have someone iron his clothes for him LOL!! Check out his...

Episode 15: Derrick Todd Lee // Part 3 23.12.2022

Send us Fan Mail **This week's Soul Cleanse** www.jane.com is a site that is based out of Lehi. They are a boutique that sells clothes, jewelry, shoes, home goods and more. They do these pop up boutiques in different places across Utah. During these they invite women from the local shelters to come and get themselves some new clothes and whatever they need. How awesome is that?! Let's gi...

Episode 14: Derrick Todd Lee // Part 2 16.12.2022

Send us Fan Mail **This Weeks Soul Cleanser** Jessica Smith, a wife and mother of four, was diagnosed October 15, 2022 with a rare persistent chronic cancer called Adenoid Cystic cancer in the salivary glands. She will need extensive surgeries and facial reconstruction. Jess is a pillar in her community, getting involved in anything and everything to lift others, such as Cops and Cupcakes. She fie...

Episode 13: Derrick Todd Lee // Part 1 09.12.2022

Send us Fan Mail **This weeks Soul Cleanser** Brittney Bott, hairstylist in Ogden. Runs her business out of the Thomas Hardy Salons, her business name is Occultist Hair. She gives free hair services to people who are struggling with mental health issues. She sounds like an AMAZING woman and whether you are a person struggling or not, please hit her up and give her some support! This week Megan is...

Episode 12: The Utah Cabin Murders 02.12.2022

Send us Fan Mail Hey guys! This week Lindsay wanted to get everyone in the Christmas spirit by telling you all about the Christmas cabin murders....nothing like murder and despair to get you in the holiday spirit! This is all about the Tiede Tanquility Cabin murders that took place in Oakley, UT in 1990. Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik...

Episode 11: The murder of Claudia Benn 25.11.2022

Send us Fan Mail This Thanksgiving week, Megan is taking us way way down from where we were last week. This case is about the thoughtless, devastating, unnecessary death of Claudia Benn by her daughter's ex, Taberon Honie. Taberon has been on Utah's death row for 23 years now, one of only 7 inmates we have on death row. Please take  caution when listening as the details are grisly and th...

Episode 10: The Survival of Tiffany Mead 18.11.2022

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay presents a case a little different from what we've covered in the past. This is a story of perseverance, survival, good police work, and lasting friendship. This is the story of Tiffany Mead and Kristopher Ertmann. This case is also covered on Oxygen network's show Murder for Hire, so check it out!! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please f...

Episode 9: The David Family Cult 11.11.2022

Send us Fan Mail In this episode Megan takes us into the life of Bruce Longo A.K.A. Immanuel David. His life begins seemingly "normal" but in his early 20's he begins to show signs of mental illness. He then reveals that he is God and is able to convince his family, a wife Rachel David and his seven children as well as a small group of faithful followers of the same thing. The story...

Episode 8: The murder of Gordon Church 04.11.2022

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay takes us back to 1988 to cover one of the most vicious hate crimes in our country and unfortunately most people don't even remember the name of the victim. This is the murder of Gordon Ray Church. Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!   patreon.com...

Bonus Halloween Episode!! 31.10.2022

Send us Fan Mail Hey sinners we decided that you all deserved a special Halloween episode as a thanks from us for being such amazing supporters! We seriously love you all and hope you enjoy a little break from murder to learn about a couple spooky Utah locations! Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now hav...

Episode 7: Ronnie Lee Gardner 28.10.2022

Send us Fan Mail This week Megan takes on a trip through the life and death of Ronnie Lee Gardner. Most Utahans know who he is merely because he is not only the last person executed in Utah but he's is the last person to be executed by the controversy firing squad method. We'll take a look at a childhood most can't even fathom and an adulthood that was brought about most of all by c...

Listen to the Sinners Among Saints podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.