Sinners Among Saints

Send us Fan Mail Could the twisting narrative of a novelist's life hold the key to a real-life mystery? This week's episode peels back the layers of Michael Peterson's world, from his fervent advocacy for military involvement in Vietnam to the depths of a family tragedy that would stun a community. Lindsay and I, offer a candid look at family dynamics, the unforeseen challenges that...

Send us Fan Mail Ever felt the chill of a home that refuses to warm, despite the thermostat's promises? Our latest chat opens with the all-too-common struggle of seeking comfort in the small things—be it battling the cold or staying awake through your favorite show. But as we peel back the layers of day-to-day life, we sink deeper into the abyss of the human condition, exploring the darkness...

Send us Fan Mail Our discussion with a somber look into the life of Pedro Alonzo Lopez. Dubbed the Monster of the Andes, his story is a chilling testament to the sinister depths some can plunge. Our narrative takes you through his tumultuous childhood, the horrific crimes that left entire communities in South America reeling, and the maddeningly lenient punishment that followed. Our episode peels...

Send us Fan Mail As we navigate the complexities of human nature and the sometimes dark side of relationships, Megan and I, Lindsay, are here to share a journey through the lives of those caught in the web of love, ambition, and deceit. This week on Sinners Among Saints, we bring to light either the harrowing story of Lisa Northon or the  cold blooded murder of her husband. From the allure of a Ha...

Send us Fan Mail Hold onto your hats, history buffs and mystery lovers - we're jumping into the scandalous love affair of the early 20th century that shook a small church community to its core. Picture this: secret rendezvous, a minister and a choir singer entangled in forbidden love, and a farmhouse purchase that screams, "Scandal ahead!" Dive into the Hall-Mills murder case with u...

Send us Fan Mail Ever wondered what secrets lie hidden in the whispers of cults or what chill-inducing tales your local paranormal hotspot might hold? Join us, Megan and Lindsay, as we leap into the new year shedding light on the shadowy corners of human experiences.  Picture this: a man claiming to be centuries old, unearthly origins, and a following that hangs on every outlandish word he preache...

Send us Fan Mail On Christmas Eve 2011, Za'Zell Preston would spend her last moments fighting for her life in front of her three children. Her murderer was none other than her husband. A man that had no regard for his wife or the children in his home. He is a horrific monster that deserves far more than he got in the end.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Face...

Send us Fan Mail This week we head to Colorado to talk about the brutal and horrific murder of Kelsey Berreth. Kelsey was a loving mother and devoted fiance until her beloved, Patrick Frazer, decided to plot her murder with his ex girlfriend and current mistress Krystal Lee. Luckily Patrick isn't half as smart as he thinks he is and makes some crucial mistakes  long the way. Listen tomorrow i...

Send us Fan Mail Join us this week as we discuss a case that is one of Utah's most infamous cases. In June of 2002, 14-year-old Elizabeth Smart was kidnapped out of her own bedroom by a homeless man who had once worked on their home. After 9 months of torture by the hands of her captor and his wife, Elizabeth is found and what she has done with her life since then is remarkable.  Support the...

Send us Fan Mail This week we are back in Utah for a pretty well known case. We are discussing the case of Mackenzie Lueck, a 23 year old college student who was attending the university of Utah. She was living her best life until a terrible match from an online dating site would introduce her to an absolute monster who would go on to murder poor Mackenzie on their first meeting. Tune in this week...

Send us Fan Mail Happy Thanksgiving! We are so grateful for all of your continued support!! This week we finish the story of Jerry Brudos. He continues on to murder three more women; Jan Whitney, Karen Sprinker, and Linda Salee. Although he thinks he is smarter than the police, he is caught one month after his last kill. We talk about his conviction, sentence and what happens with his wife and two...

Send us Fan Mail In January 1968, a young encyclopedia sales woman would set out for an appointment she had with someone to show them her product. Unfortunately the rainy weather would smear the address on her paper and this would send her to a home that would change the course of her existence and would begin a spree that would later take the lives of 3 more women. Tune in this week for part 1 of...

Send us Fan Mail This week we take a horrific trip to Krakow, Poland you discuss the horrific torture and murder of a 23 year old university student Katarzyna Zowada. This poor girl was getting her life back together and finally on a good path after suffering a devastating loss. Just when her life is turning around for the better, she is taken by an absolute monster! Tune in for the insane case! S...

Send us Fan Mail In 1933, two French sisters murdered their employers, after 7 years of loyal employment. Christine and Lea Papin, spent their childhoods with a cruel mother who sent them away very early in life to be raised by the nuns in the Catholic orphanage, Bon Pasteur. The girls quickly knew it was them against the world which may have led to what happened that fateful night in 1933. Tune i...

Send us Fan Mail This week we start with creepy and end with murder! This case is one of the most bizarre and terrifying I've ever heard about! Daniel Laplante had a really sad childhood and in his teens he starts robbing houses and playing mind games with his victims. This turns into stalking but this stalking case is next level!! This boy begins living inside the walls is his stalking victi...

Send us Fan Mail This week we jump back to 1947, America in the height of war. With World War II just ending and the Cold War ramping up we were on edge to say the least but nothing could prepare the American people for what was coming next. On June 24, 1947 Kenneth Arnold would report a sighting of nine unidentified flying objects and once that hit the media we couldn't stop the sightings fr...

Send us Fan Mail To continue our spooky October theme, this week we will be discussing where some of our Halloween traditions started.  We cover Halloween itself and how's it has evolved, truck or treating, Jack o lanterns, and costumes. We will also cover the origin stories of the creepy vampire and body Mary!  It's like a fun and creepy history lesson with your bestie♥️  Support the sh...

Send us Fan Mail Join us this week as we head to Mansfield, Ohio to take an in depth look at the Ohio State Reformatory. It opened in 1896 and ran until the 1990s. While there were the typical death and violence, this building also houses many stuck souls. It has been the focal point of many movies and music videos over the years, including The Shawshank Redemption.  Support the show Thanks for al...

Send us Fan Mail This week Lindsay takes you to Montana to the Crow reservation to discuss the very sad tale of Roylynn Rides Horse, a Native American woman who was left alone to suffer unthinkable pain. She's was a mother, daughter, Aunt, sister, cousin, and friend. Her case didn't get much attention, which is the unfortunate reality for many missing and murdered indigenous women. We ho...

Send us Fan Mail Just before Christmas in 1997, a family had their world turned upside down when a fire broke out in their home. All family members were taken out of the home except 10 day old Delimar Vera. Delimar was asleep in the upstairs bedroom and when her mother, Luzaida, reached Delimar's room she was no where to be found. Wrought with panic, Luzaida was evntually forced outside by th...

Send us Fan Mail This we cover part 2 of the Ken and Barbie killers, Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo. We delve into the torture and murder of Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French, 2 young girls.  We then discuss the downfall of this couple, the deal with devil,  the trial and beyond!! There so many twists in this case so hang on and Tune in for this insane sin! Support the show Thanks for all the sup...

Send us Fan Mail For this episode, Lindsay takes us on a ride to Canada to discuss one of their most infamous cases. Paul Bernardo is the Scarborough rapist and is terrible enough on his own but when he meets his other half Karla Homolka, things get even worse. These two rape and torture teenage girls and go on to do do other horrific things, including the murder of three victims. Hold onto your p...

Send us Fan Mail This week we are heading to World War II era Italy where the love and devotion of one mother for her son goes beyond anyone's imagination. In the mind of Leonarda Cianciulli, she's only protecting her son but at what cost and to who? Tune in this week for tht story of The Soap Maker of Correggio.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook...

Send us Fan Mail This week we are headed to the small town of Casper, Wyoming to hear a horrific, harrowing, and very sad tale involving two sisters. The oldest sister has a truly inspiring will to live and help her little sister but unfortunately that isn't enough. This is the story of The Fremont Bridge.  Support the show Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram,...

Send us Fan Mail This week we take a murder reprieve and instead take a look into what one cult expert refers to as "the most destructive cult in history". We take a look into Keith Raniere and what he posed as a "self-help" organization called NXIVM. On the outside you think you are getting some self-help courses to be a more successful and better person but what you really ge...