Matt, PG, & Jess
Season 14, Time For A Podcast
An obsessive fan, a fanfiction author, and a first time viewer go through every episode of Supernatural.
Author
Matt, PG, & Jess
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jun 28, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
3.01 - The Magnificent Seven 19.01.2020 1:49:01
Dean has one year to live and a whole bunch of demons are on the loose. Sam looks for answers, Bobby is awesome, and the Seven Deadly Sins are on a rampage. Matt and PG discuss their time at the Cincinnati Comic Expo, Jess wonders about Blondie McKnife Face, and we all talk about our very important and complicated shoe needs. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
The Spoiler Episode 14.01.2020 1:03:56
SPOILERS! SPOILERS! ALL OF THE SPOILERS! (Special thanks to @littlegreyfish and @MittensMorgul for tracking down the clips used for our spoiler warning sound bytes) Matt and PG talk A LOT about Supernatural together, geek out over it, and share theories all the time. It's kind of the first domino in this whole podcast. Usually they have to talk in code around Jess in order to not spoil her, but no...
Watchalong - Houses of the Holy 12.01.2020 48:40
As we fall in between seasons, we want you get the experience of watching an episode with us. Is it any good? We don't promise that. Is it entertaining? That's up for debate. But it is available! The three of us got together to rewatch S2.13 Houses of the Holy, and we invite you to sync up your copy with us and imagine that we are terrible rejects from MST3K. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Face...
2.22 - All Hell Breaks Loose Part Two 05.01.2020 1:43:43
What is Dean supposed to do? Not make a good decision, that's for sure. But hey, without it we wouldn't have the show we have today. And in the end, it's the one finale you can walk away from feeling good. We create a scoring system for death that includes nearly dying and actually dying, imagine what a Supernatural Myth Busters would be, and Jess says a few words about the dearly departed Ash. Pa...
2.21 - All Hell Breaks Loose Part One 29.12.2019 1:55:08
The Yellow Eyed Demon is ready to put his plan for all the psychics into place which means Sam gets taken. Dean can't handle that (and never gets any pie as a result). We discuss why you should never tow a tow truck, how Matt will never help a child because he knows what happens when you do, and provide some facts about David Hasselhoff. Additionally, Jess has a lot of feelings about what happens...
2.20 - What Is And What Should Never Be 22.12.2019 1:39:38
Dean has a run in with a Djinn and wakes up to find that his mom never died when he was a kid and that he and Sam never became hunters. Is this a dream come true or a nightmare? We make some hair conditioner suggestions, ignore that Samantha Smith is waaaaay too young to be Jensen Ackles' mom, find out that Jess burned down a white nightgown store, discuss the merits of midwestern waving, and wond...
2.19 - Folsom Prison Blues 15.12.2019 1:23:07
Sam and Dean get arrested, are sent to prison, and discover that FBI Special Agent Henriksen knows where they are. The good news is they planned for two of those things (whoops). We wonder about the government agents who monitor our search history, If Henrickson is sexist, and how Dean assimilates into prison culture really quick because it's his first stable environment in a long time. We also ma...
2.18 - Hollywood Babylon 08.12.2019 1:40:58
In a very meta episode where Sam and Dean head to Hollywood to investigate a haunted set, we discuss Derpy the pony, create our own urban myth in "Bloody Cancel", and we spread lies about whether or not people could always see in color. You also get a very behind the scenes discussion as we go off on a weird tangent about our scheduling problems. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2...
2.17 - Heart 01.12.2019 1:35:30
It's a classic story: boy meets girl, boy falls in love with girl, girl becomes werewolf and eats people. Classic for Supernatural at least. We make our first request some fan art. We ask a "would you rather" question that makes no sense. And we talk about plans to watch the worst movie ever. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By: kpearldesign.com
2.16 - Roadkill 24.11.2019 1:09:30
Sam and Dean seemingly stumble across a hunt (or do they?!). They find a woman who is being chased by a ghost and she doesn't know why (or does she?!). There's lots of questions here that may or may not be obvious. We have questions about ghost blood, if a new house in the middle of nowhere is scarier than an old house, if a spirit has a subconscious, and if ghosts need to smash through windows. K...
2.15 - Tall Tales 17.11.2019 1:52:26
Sam and Dean each try to tell their side of a story to Bobby as the two are mad at one another. But is someone just playing a trick on them? We're joined by Jess' friend (and our Fandom Trumps Hate auction winner) Martha! We learn what children name their toys and books to read (for a while), discover that Sam has amazing alligator scale detection abilities, and there is more than one instance of...
2.14 - Born Under A Bad Sign 10.11.2019 1:30:53
Sam goes missing and when Dean catches up, something bad has definitely happened. Is Sam turning into the monster he feared he would become? We debate about Bon Jovi, wonder if Jess' husband Matt should be a surrogate for our Matt, and Jess' dog Luna makes her first appearance. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By: kpearldesign.com
2.13 - Houses of the Holy 03.11.2019 1:32:06
Is it a vengeful spirit or an avenging angel? Will Sam kill an innocent person? Will Dean fess up to his actual emotional issues? Look none of that matters. What matters is when you feel spiritual ecstasy, your perm goes away. We also may trail off into some more serious conversation for once. Just a bit. A little. Some... Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By: kpearl...
2.12 - Nightshifter 27.10.2019 1:40:11
Sam and Dean have to track down a Man-Droid! Well...if you believe the very unstable night guardsman at the bank where they accidentally take a bunch of people hostage leading the FBI to try and stop them. Look, it's really complicated! We are joined by Alisha Grauso, film critic, editorial lead of Atom Tickets, and all around Supernatural fan. Find her on Twitter and Instagram @AlishaGrauso and v...
2.11 - Playthings 20.10.2019 1:44:58
There's creepy children so you know it's going to be a good one! We also see the ground work laid for Dean's crush on Daphne. Don't worry. Just another 11 seasons for it to payoff! We then get into a discussion about Dean overcompensating. Is it part of the character? It is the writers baiting fans? Is it just done for laughs? We have opinions on this. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Sea...
2.10 - Hunted 13.10.2019 1:42:42
A recap with Gordon all over it? Looks like Gordon is back! (groan) Oh but there is a new, quirky character introduced! (hurray!) It's Ava and she's awesome. We question the labels on prescription medication (and get a real answer), see more of Sam and Dean's training and use of code words, and wonder if pop rocks lead to anxiety. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By...
2.09 - Croatoan 06.10.2019 1:27:21
"Are you infected?!" "No, are you?!" "No!" "You could be lying!" "So could you!" So things were going great for the Winchesters. And this back and forth between Dean and the Sarge wasn't even the worst part. (Oh Sam...) We talk about how modern day smart phones would have warned this poor town that it was doomed, how creepy the Tanner family is, Matt's wish for how the series should end, and how...
2.08 - Crossroad Blues 29.09.2019 1:44:12
We have an important follow up in regards to our contest from two episodes ago! We also get into one of the most important episodes in the show's history. A lot of significant things get set up. Like a lot. But Jess doesn't get that yet. Instead she wants to focus on what her last meal would be before a Hell Hound took her. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By: kpea...
2.07 - The Usual Suspects 22.09.2019 1:37:22
Linda Blair guest stars as Sam and Dean get themselves arrested. Which is bad. But then Sam figures out how to escape. Which is good! But Dean is still in jail. Which is bad. Okay this could take a while. Matt geeks out over a Steve McQueen reference (again), PG shares her inside knowledge on the creepiness of Jess' basement, and Jess makes us wonder about the connections between Supernatural and...
2.06 - No Exit 15.09.2019 1:48:19
We announce our contest winners! But really, thanks to all of you who participated. We appreciate every single one of you! Jo finds a case, does all the leg work, but has to be rescued. What?! We take issue with this. Also, who doesn't move out of their apartment the very second black goop falls on them. Screw that noise. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created By: kpearld...
2.05 - Simon Said 08.09.2019 1:21:13
What happens when Sam and Dean meet another person with special powers like Sam does, but are completely different? And what happens when that person is the coolest dude? And then what happens when that coolest dude has an evil twin? So many questions! We learn some history of what women did their menstrual cycle (none of it is accurate), think Weber looks way too much like Elijah Wood, and are ge...
2.04 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things 01.09.2019 1:44:55
ZOMBIES! Errr...zombie. One zombie. Just one. Not as scary? We talk about how Angela had the misfortune of knowing not one, but two awful men. We also discuss which character (at this point) we would want to be. How about you? Our contest continues with its second and final week! Listen in and find out how to enter and what you win! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Created B...
2.03 - Bloodlust 25.08.2019 1:44:46
Sam and Dean dive deeper into the world of hunting as they meet Gordon Walker, an expert vampire hunter, for the first time. But is he someone to learn from or fear? Get ready for a cameo from Jess's dog, our reference to Aaahh!!! Real Monsters, when we notice Ty Olsson as a DIFFERENT vampire, and when we share our disappointment with what Looney Tunes led us to think life would be like. We also h...
2.02 - Everybody Loves A Clown 18.08.2019 1:29:09
"Mommy, Daddy, they shot my clown!" Best line ever. We meet Ellen and Jo Harvelle and get to visit the Roadhouse for the first time. We find out that Sam is afraid of clowns. We also found out why Matt hates clowns. Then there's a discussion about real serial killers, the ages of the actors, and Jess finds her favorite character in Ash. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook Season 2 Logo Creat...
2.01 - In My Time of Dying 11.08.2019 1:25:53
Time to begin Season 2! We wonder what the show would be like if it was on HBO, Matt has so many problems with how TV hospitals are managed, PG has questions about how the CPR is depicted, and Jess talks about Grey's Anatomy so clearly this is a podcast about a medical show, right? Picking up where Season 1 left off, the Winchesters are trying to avoid the Yellow Eyed Demon. Well...actually John i...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.