Season 14, Time For A Podcast

When Jess first watched the awfulness that is Route 666, PG joined her and the two recorded their comments, criticisms, and all around disappointment with this episode. This then gave us the idea to do this every single season. So welcome to our first watchalong episode!  Throw in your disk or load up Netflix and get ready to sync the episode along with us. It might be a terrible episode, but now...

John Winchester's life is on the line, but Sam and Dean have no idea what to do. On there own, that is. So they turn to Bobby Singer (YAY!) one of the most experienced demon hunters there is. Will he be able to provide them enough guidance to stop Meg, save John, and defeat the Yellow Eyed Demon? Jess has no idea. She also had no idea THAT ending was coming.  It's a great finale to the first of 15...

Jess experiences her first Carry On Wayward Son and understands all the feels. We later discover that demons are the real reason why babies have horrible blowouts. If you don't know what that is, consider yourself lucky. Sam, Dean, and John have a plan to go after the demon. Will it work or will it fail miserably? Well the show is entering it's 15th season, so take a wild guess. The props Matt tal...

Vampires, the Colt, and John Winchester! What more do you need? Well. How about some angst from Sam and Dean? Because this episode has that too! Jess talks about meeting Tara Strong, Matt mentions a fan theory of how Supernatural made it to 15 seasons, and PG shares MittensMorgul's info about some behind the scenes stuffs from Route 666. (It doesn't make us any happier with that garbage fire) Patr...

There's a horrible painting no one should own, but everyone seems to want to own it. Even Sam. Even though he's pretending. Whatever, it'll make sense! And the little girl is creepy. She's no Missy Bender, but she's still creepy. We reveal a fun fact about Matt's wife, dive into our theory about what was really going on at this auction house, and hear PG try to justify how this episode reminded he...

John Winchester: great hunter, garbage father. That's the consensus around here. Matt really wants to say more, but that goes into spoiler territory, PG makes a clever Harry Potter connection, and Jess loves kid friendly Dean. Oh and the hospital the guys go to has the WORST SECURITY PROTOCOLS EVER!! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam and Dean have a prank war and find two PROFESSIONAL paranormal investigators while they look into the case of a spirit that seems to follow no pattern. We have our very first guest as we welcome Matt's brother, Joe! We wonder about the size of interstates, how old these "children" are supposed to be, and the implications of what happens to a Tulpa when it still exists, but has nowhere to go. N...

You ever make a shadow puppet on the wall? Of like a bird or a bunny? Well imagine if it was a creepy hooded figure with claw hands and somehow started to tear people to pieces! That's kind what this episode is like, but not nearly as dumb. Sam and Dean head to the windy city as Matt, PG, and Jess discuss the finer points of stealth, cost of rent, and how much Jess hates Meg. Patreon Twitter Insta...

While investigating a missing person's case, Sam ends up being the next one taken. Dean is desperate and turns to a law enforcement official who is actually competent. Are there ghosts? Are there hillbillies? Is Missy a goblin? And what's with the magic bracket? There are so many questions and we create a whole new canon completely by accident. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam starts having more premonitions. This time he's seeing the men die in a family he doesn't even know. What's the plan when he can't even get there in time to stop it? Dress up as priests, of course! Matt has questions about why the boys can't break glass, PG gets squeamish once or twice, and Jess just wants to accept her fate if she ever found herself in a life or death situation. Patreon Twitt...

A racist ghost truck? Terrible dialogue? Ignoring pre-established lore? Well that sounds like BuckLemming, all right! Dean receives a phone call from an ex-girlfriend. Someone he fell in love with, told her the truth about his family, then was dumped. Now that she suspects a ghost is the cause of her father's death, she needs his help. That's about as interesting as this episode gets because...wel...

Welcome to our episode where we discuss some feedback from listeners, debate the movie Mean Girls, discuss the finer points of HIPAA, and eventually talk about Supernatural! (We get sidetracked a lot) After a hunt goes wrong, Dean has weeks left to live, but will he have faith as time runs out? Well Sam sure does! They visit a faith healer and what it leads to is a character who needed another sce...

Sam and Dean have a fight so Sam hitchhikes. Along the way he meets Meg. Dean goes and takes care of the hunt their dad sent them on. Well...as best he can by himself. It gets awkward. And then he gets a shotgun butt to the face. Meanwhile, there is a freaky scarecrow that needs human sacrifices so it can help the town have really good apples. Yes, really. PG has a theory that this is actually abo...

You're not the boss of me!!!  Okay so Sam is a bit miffed at Dean. And there's a little tension between them. Don't worry though. Sam shoots Dean square in the chest with a shotgun filled with rock salt. Oh. Uhhh...maybe worry a little? We also jump into the debate we had about Dean's leather jacket and how he got his hands on it back in the Pilot. It was quite the rabbit hole we fell down. Patreo...

How does this show bounce back from the awfulness that was Bugs?! Well with one of the best episodes of the season, of course! Sam is having nightmares about a family in trouble in their childhood home so he and Dean head back to where it all began. Is it the thing that killed their mom? They aren't sure. Dean puts in a heartfelt call to John begging for help, but will he answer? Regardless of wha...

Considered by many to be the worst episode of Supernatural. And we aren't going to disagree. An episode so bad that we felt the only way to make it entertaining was to watch it together and mock it. Yes there are bugs. Yes they are killing people. And yes it's pointless. It's not a good episode, but we still had fun. I mean how often does a character die so terribly stupid that it causes uproariou...

Aren't you glad you didn't turn on the light? Wait...is that even the right urban legend? Well it doesn't matter because there's a hook, man!  Sam and Dean go where Dean has never gone before: college! Sam creeps on one young girl while Dean tries to creep on all the rest! Eh. Whatever. Just go with it. After all, we finally get to see some bones salted and burned! And the No Closure Award? Oh tha...

No you aren't seeing double, that's really two Deans on your screen. And boy does it look awful! But that transformation scene is still cool, even if the goo puddle it leaves behind glows in the dark for no reason. We're watching Skin! One of the better monster of week episodes of season 1. It has a lot of small problems (one of which annoys Jess to no end), but the highlights really outweigh thos...

Bloody Mary. Bloody Mary. Bloody Ma-  Nope. Sorry. Can't do it.  Sam and Dean come across the....you-know-who legend. Turns out she isn't just killing people, but instead she's exacting a twisted sense of vengeance against those with a dark secret. And who else has a dark secret? Why it's our very own Sam Winchester! It was a first time watch for PG as we discuss the episode that turned Matt from...

No survivors.....except there were a bunch of survivors. Doesn't matter! That's hardly the biggest problem with this episode when it comes to what does and doesn't go on during a flight. Sam and Dean take to the skies (much to Dean's chagrin) to battle what seems to be their first EVER demon. I mean. It's definitely the first demon they are directly facing in the show, but like....ever? Seems that...

With no leads as to where their dad is, Sam and Dean head down the road and begin looking for random cases to solve. People vanishing while swimming certainly seems to be their kind of weird. Matt and PG freak out over the toy soldier reference while Jess has to stop herself from wanting to watch more. Is she converting already? We also start noticing a weird pattern in the episodes. Spoiler alert...

After Sam's girlfriend (Jess) gets royally fridged, he joins Dean on the road to find their dad. Will John be at the coordinates he left for his boys? Probably not, but our Jess doesn't know that! We continue with our show discussing the second episode. We learn that the most important tagline in the show's history came  ridiculously  early, that Sam was serial-killer scary even back then, that me...

Our second episode is all about the first episode of Supernatural. Do you remember the first time you watched the Pilot? Well Jess sure as hell does! And there are going to be some opinions. Including questions about Dean's amazing leather jacket cleaning abilities. Being our first episode, we're figuring a lot of things out. Things progress. Honest. On November 2, 1983 something found its way int...

Supernatural. The CW's cult TV series that is about to enter into its 14th season. It's kind of crazy to think that considering when it had it's very first mid-season break, the people involved weren't sure it would come back. Yet here we are! This brings us to our show! Matt is an obsessive fan who has been watching since the show premiered September 13, 2005. PG is a fanfiction author who loves...