Season 14, Time For A Podcast

Anna is a woman who is being treated for hearing voices and believing the world is going to end. The one problem is she's not wrong and both angels and demons are after her. While Sam and Dean try to help, Dean learns what Sam was up to with Ruby the last several months. We explain why 42 is the answer to life, the universe, and everything, do some "investigative boobie viewing," and wonder what c...

In a town where a wishing well is actually granting wishes, Sam and Dean have to deal with a talking teddy bear, a young boy with the super strength, and an invisible pervert. We have so many questions about how things work with Teddy, the untouched mac and cheese in Home Alone, and what happens when remote controls go missing. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

It's Halloween and Sam and Dean have to stop a witch from completing a spell that will cause the rising of the demon Samhain. Which just so happens to be one of the 66 seals. Unfortunately, Castiel is there with his friend Uriel who really wants to destroy the whole town. We talk about candy (of course), Little Shop of Horrors, and the value of raw Pop-Tarts. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Faceb...

After contracting ghost sickness, Dean begins to grow afraid of everything. It starts off hilarious (for us) until he halucinates Lilith. Sam has to come up with a really disturbing plan to save his brother. Martha is back and she shares some odd drawings! We discuss the horrors of CPR certification, the finer details of the Japanese language, and that amazing Eye of the Tiger scene. Patreon Twitt...

What are Sam and Dean to do when the monsters they are hunting are black and white versions of Dracula, the Wolf-Man, and the Mummy? It doen't matter because it's all hilarious. We wonder if Ethan Hawke snuck into this episode, we learn a lot about Porky's II, and discuss what movie we would want to live in. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam and Dean get called to help an old friend hunt a Rugaru, a creature that starts out human, but will turn after it feeds on long pig. Can Sam save this man from becoming a monster? More importantly, can he save himself? We discuss the debate between "Cas" and "Cass" (because there is a right answer), wonder what the hell the ground beef was made of, and we talk about goats for a minute. Patreon...

Castiel sends Dean to 1973 where he meets his parents when they were young and in love. But he soon realizes he has a chance to save them from their fates. In an episode where we talk about Tab, we learn about the fish-mobile, and Matt reveals he never read Harry Potter. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam, Dean, and Bobby are confronted by the spirits of people they failed to save. The real Meg Masters, Victor Henriksen, and Ronald Resnick are all back and want revenge. Castiel reveals they were all brought back by Lilith as part of a much larger problem. We give some information about how the final season of Supernatural is being impacted by the coronavirus shutdown, Jess has strong feelings a...

After the ending of Season 3 saw Dean sent to Hell, it can't be as easy as him just being back can it? Oh wait. Yes, yes it can. But how is he back? Are there strings attached? And what has Sam been up to the last four months? With so much to discuss for this very significant and amazing episode, we are joined by talented metawriter MittensMorgul who brings us extra information we never knew about...

We end season 3 with our watchalong tradition! Joe, Matt's brother, rejoins us we watch S3.13 - Ghostfacers. Get your copy and sync up with us! Jess tells us the difficulties explaining Leap Year to a young child, PG is going to buy pet rats, and Matt gets obsessed with the windows in the house. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

There's only 30 hours left in Dean's deal when Bobby figures out where Lilith is. Sam is desperate and wants Ruby's help. This is going to work....right? Jess does this one a bit drunk and threatens to quit the podcast (again), Matt has a theory about why Andy never went evil, and PG is very excited to be on the verge of Season 4. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam tries to find a way to keep Dean from going to hell by hunting down a doctor who figured out how to live forever. We learn not to ask Jess how she knows about inflicting wounds, discuss maggots (probably for too long), and we wonder what Supernatural Clue would be like. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

The spirits of dead loved ones are calling up people. Is it legit? Dean thinks so when he gets a call from John saying he knows how to prevent Dean from going to hell. We try to figure out the perfect all-in-one weapon to combat the creatures of Supernatural, reminisce about talking on land lines, and wonder what it would be like if Kripke tried to trick Jeffrey Dean Morgan into voice acting over...

Ed & Harry are back and they have assembled a paranormal investigative team to look into one of the most haunted houses in the world. The problem is they have no idea what they're doing and are going to die. Thankfully, Sam and Dean wanted to tackle this same house. Joe, Matt's brother, rejoins us to share a very interesting theory about the ghost in this episode. We learn about Matt's beard insec...

Sam and Dean are arrested (again) by Special Agent Victor Henriksen (again), and have demons after them (again!) Jess has a new room just for podcasting, we figure out the formula for making a character look brilliant, and we discuss getting tattoos for when the podcast is finished. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam wakes up and relives the same Tuesday over and over and over again. What makes it worse? Dean dies every single day. What's not worse? This episode is hilarious! We are joined by Steph (@thegingerpire) and Ally (@theallyverse) from the podcast Two Chicks and the Plural of Apocalypse (@TwoChicksPod). We discuss who should sponsor each of our podcasts, the origin of "pig 'n' a poke," and wonder...

Sam and Dean discover Bobby has fallen into a coma and may be trapped inside his worst nightmare. When they fight back against the guy who did, Dean is forced to face what scares him most: the truth! We discuss what would happen if Jess was trapped by a crazy person in a dream world, what a permanent record looks like, and Matt explains what a big lipped alligator moment is. And since this is the...

Sam and Dean find a hex bag that leads them to a coven a witches. But where there are witches, there are demons and Ruby warns the Winchesters to get out of town before it's too late. We discuss the going rate the Tooth Fairy gives for an adult tooth, how Jess being into The Craft is the least shocking thing ever, and how this coven is quite lame. #ToothTummy Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Faceb...

Colorful lights, decorated trees, and....mild weather? It must be a Supernatural Christmas as Sam and Dean come across two gods who just want to play kindly (see "murderous") next down neighbors.  TheXPhial, our original review contest winner, join us. We call BS that Dean doesn't know Mary Poppins, how Colin Ford was the best choice to play young Sam, and embrace a lot of our dark humor. Patreon...

Gordon decides it's time he breaks out of jail and go after Sam. The problem is that he forgot Sam and Dean are hunting vampires and it only gets worse from there. We talk about how the fashion choices of the women stand out for the wrong reasons, why 30 is not the new old, and we get distracted by Jessica's cat. Oh and we praise the return of the Jesus-mobile and think Spider is the worst nightcl...

Bella's back and wants to help the Winchester's solve a case that involves a ghost ship and an angry spirit. All Dean has to do is dress up real nice, and Sam has to woo a rich old woman. We talk for a bit about showers, wonder what Dean's porn star name would be, and learn the difference between the Cardassians and the Kardashians. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Fairy tales come to life as Sam and Dean try to figure out how a girl in a coma is causing the big bad wolf and other fantasy creatures to attack innocent people. In an episode with the least amount of closure (possibly ever), we're sad that we'll never know who that frog really was, but agree that Dean is lying when he says he doesn't know anything about Grimm's Fair Tales or Disney movies. Patre...

Is there a demon in this town or did everyone all collectively decide to start a party? That's the question that leads Sam and Dean to investigate what's going on in what should be a halfway closed factory town that looks more like the strip in Vegas. We remind Jess of the blood contract she signed that prevents her from binge watching, Matt can't let the M&M debate go, and he also sneaks his sist...

Sam and Dean find a lucky rabbit's foot, but Sam's luck runs out when a thief by the name of Bella steals it from him. Martha is back in an episode where the El Sol hints continue and where we discuss the glory and wonder of the Jesus-mobile, what John Winchester would have been like on Hoarders, and get excited by the first appearance of a Biggerson's and Bobby saying "idjit". Patreon Twitter Ins...

Dean wants to relive some of the highlights from his youth. This means seeking out a woman he had a very sexy weekend with. But then discovers he may have fathered her child. And just his luck, there's a monster to hunt too! Matt made a recording boo boo so this is going to start with lower quality audio for a bit. Along the way, we discuss that table saws and horror always lead to one thing, that...