Season 14, Time For A Podcast

To help a friend of John's, Sam and Dean agree to have themselves committed to a psychiatric hospital to hunt a monster that is feeding on the patients. Problems arise when they both start to lose their grip on reality. We discuss the many issues we have with the medical staff, wonder if Jared knows how to properly boop, and still feel bad for the monster's pain. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr F...

It's all hands on deck as Sam, Dean, Castiel, Ellen, and Jo all head out to get the colt and then kill Lucifer with it. After things don't go their way, there are casualties. In an episode where Matt accidentally recorded on the wrong audio input, we discuss what a spaghetti junction is, the fun camera tricks, and all of our ugly crying. So much ugly crying. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebo...

Sam and Dean get texted by Becky (on Chuck's phone) and end up at the first ever Supernatural convention surrounded by fans of the books who think they too are just two fans themselves. It only gets worse when a real ghost hunt breaks out and everyone thinks it's part of the LARPing game. We are joined by Nicole, Matt's friend whom he begged to start watching the show over the summer. We discuss w...

Sam wants to seek out help from The Trickster thinking he's the only one powerful enough to help stop the apocalypse. Dean isn't so sure but agrees to try. When the two find him, they fall into a trap and end up stuck in a TV world. Funny episode? Martha's back! We discuss how this episode reminds us of 1992's Stay Tuned, PG gives a hidden message to Matt that refers to the series finale, and our...

When he learns about a traveling card player who bets you years instead of money, Bobby tries to turn back the clock in order to heal his legs. When Bobby loses, it forces Dean to play the same game, but he too comes up short and finds himself 80 years old. We discuss the career of Chad Everett, what would happen if Jess got pregnant again, and then imagined what it would be like if Dean was pregn...

Childhood myths start coming true leading Sam and Dean to discover a young boy is inadvertently responsible for all of it. And it only gets worse from there. We are all exhausted as this was recorded the week of the 2020 election and share how gullible each of us are, our histories with whoopee cushions, and how some theories are so good they must be true (or not). Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr...

People are being killed by the spirits of famous people. Famous people they idolized. Sam and Dean have to deal with that while also learning how to be a team again. But can they? We get into the history of Little Bastard (it's horrific), the absurd reaction to seeing Abraham Lincoln, and how Paris Hilton is far smarter than most people know. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Dean wakes up in a world where the apocalypse has already happened, his friends are different, and Sam said yes to Lucifer. Will he learn the lesson Zachariah wants him to? We are joined by fanfiction author Seperis to discuss the episode that inspired her 1.2 million word story. We also get into the details of downtown Kansas City, how mint is the nuclear bomb of gardening, and the great debate i...

After going their separate ways, Sam and Dean deal with new challenges in their lives. Sam gives up hunting, but struggles with doing nothing people are in trouble. Dean, meanwhile, teams up with Cas to track down an archangel. It doesn't take us long to wonder about angels and pooping (again), the importance of the sexual orientations of angels, and what the worst century was. Patreon Twitter Ins...

Everyone in a small town has been possessed by demons, leaving the few survivors stranded. After Bobby gets a call from Rufus, Sam and Dean try to help out, but tensions begin to boil over. We discuss how even sad Bobby is prepared for everything, how Cas buying a phone would be hilarious, and what the fifth horseman would be. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

With the door to Lucifer's cage open, Sam and Dean are miraculously transported to safety. Though they are out of immediate danger, things are about to get worse as an old enemy reappears and both angels and demons are out for the Winchesters. Jess and PG's mom might be a Supernatural fan, Matt shares his thoughts on the popular movie Pacific Rim, and we wonder if White Jesus will show up. Patreon...

With season 4 is behind us it's time to honor our mid-season tradition to go back to the 13th episode, rewatch, and create a watchalong for you all (if you actually care). So get your copy of the episode, hit play when we tell you, and pretend we are right there with you making all the odd comments that we do. Matt geeks out about having scene Bill & Ted Face the Music, wonders whether or not Sail...

All the seals have broken but one. Sam works with Ruby to find Lilith and get strong enough to kill her. Dean is taken by the angels and discovers that he is meant for a greater purpose. We suggest things a person can do with a Tony Award, what the episode would have been like with Whoopi Goldberg, and go over the random things we've said in the past that we should turn into stickers. Patreon Twit...

Sam is locked in the panic room and forced to detox from the demon blood, but it does not come without consequences. As Dean struggles with what the right decision is, he turns to Castiel who demands loyalty. We spend some time discussing desserts (because of course), the fear every parent has when things are too quiet, and get side tracked talking about Lilith Fair. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumb...

Castiel needs to get an important message to the Winchesters. When Sam and Dean go to meet him, the angel is gone, but Jimmy, the vessel, is alive and well. We question if angels need to poop, debate the correct word for what Sam is, and what it would be like if Jess was Castiel's vessel. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

A phone call sends Sam and Dean to meet Adam Milligan: John's 19 year old son. Is this kid brother for real? All the two Winchesters knows for sure is they can't agree on what to do with him. We discuss how terrible the Impala must smell, what John's erotic pen name would be, and the struggles of the middle child. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam and Dean stumble across a series of books called Supernatural that detail many of their past hunts. The author is a lonely recluse who had no idea his characters were real. Unsure if he is controlling their lives, they find out that Lilith is about to be in town. Sam thinks this is the perfect time to strike while Dean wants to run. We have to wonder if anyone dealt with the spirit that Sam an...

Dean Smith and Sam Wesson are two guys who work for the same company. The building they work in is haunted, but they don't know anything about how to fight ghosts. After finding an instructional video on how to deal with ghosts, they ready themselves for their first ghost hunt. What is going on?! With a surprise cameo from the Ghostfacers, Matt's brother Joe makes a surprise visit to podcast. We d...

Demons find a way to kill angels, but no one is sure how. With Alastair captured, Dean is called to torture him for information. Sam is worried his brother lacks the will to get the job done and calls upon Ruby to get stronger. We are joined Liz, our OTHER review contest winner who decided to pick this very dark episode to discuss with us. We talk Pinky and the Brain, TV shows could break Alastair...

A reaper goes missing and suddenly no one can die in a small Wyoming town. Sam and Dean investigate and discover a seal is about to be broken and need to become ghosts in order to stop it. We come up with a strange movie concept, figure that Death lost his scythe in a game of Battleship, and think that ghost concentration is similar to making a poop face. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

The call of a Siren's song lead several men to murder their wives. The problem is that it is also going to lead Sam and Dean to murder each other. We wonder what Sam and Dean would have done if they needed to be lawyers, discuss a lot of Donkey Kong Country, and the internet cake phenomenon. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

When a ghost is possessing the students at their old High School, Sam and Dean revisit moments from their past. Will the advice Sam received from a teacher be the push he needs as an adult? In an episode all about thinking back to your days in High School we reminisce about KaBlam!, point out the S.E. Hinton reference, and discuss the wonderful acting of Colin Ford. And just because it's season 4...

Sam and Dean head to magic week where everyone is a better con artist than they are, and someone is using real magic to kill other magicians. In an episode all about sad old men we talk about grandpas, card tricks, and when camera tricks were invented. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

It's a ghost! Wait...not really! What is it? It's a poorly written episode that we will do everything in our power to try to figure out. After reaching 1,000 downloads in a month for the first time we share how we want to celebrate with you! We also discuss how people steal photos, how a wolf will shoot your tires, and how hunting people is a problematic story line. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumbl...

Sam and Dean figure out what makes Anna so special and how they can use it to their advantage against both angels and demons. We tell a story about a cake, another story about LeVar Burton, and we try to figure out when Castiel was originally supposed to die (spoiler: we don't). Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook