Madison Eppley

My Existential Crisis

From world mysteries to strange scientific phenomena, conspiracy theories, paranormal activity, and true crime, join us on Mondays as we talk through all the weird things that make us question our entire sense of self. This is My Existential Crisis.

Author

Madison Eppley

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

podcasters.spotify.com

Latest episode

Feb 9, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

My Existential Crisis Hotline #1 09.02.2026

We're back with something a little different! We start the episode talking about a perilous trip home, then give a few details about Dylan's upcoming art show. Madison talks about the power of routine and how she's planning on adding more structure to her life. In this episode, we take five paranormal questions off of Reddit and give our advice. Are we qualified? With almost eighty epi...

77. Dylan Burn-ger, Certified Greaser™ (The Andrea Yates Case) 20.01.2026

We're here in the new year with episode 77, and Dylan is starting the new year off strong! Dylan tells his very unfortunate tale of being both the victim and the perpetrator of a heinous crime. It all started with a late-night bacon sandwich. It ended with $40 with of bandages and a plethora of new nicknames. This week, Madison tells the story of Andrea Yates, a tragic tale where a woman was f...

76. The Patron Saint of Stepdads (Miraculous Stair of Loretto Chapel) 05.01.2026

We’re back with episode 76 of My Existential Crisis! Dylan talks about getting an Apple Watch, returning an Apple Watch, getting another Apple Watch and thinking of returning it again. Madison goes into her New Year’s resolutions for 2026 before the Crisis Crew discusses alternative openers.  In this episode, Dylan details the story of the miraculous stair, a spiral staircase in the Loretto Chapel...

75. What Debris Do YOU Have in Your Pocket? (Operation Mincemeat) 29.12.2025

It's episode 75, and despite not mentioning it 'til the end, Happy Holidays from MEC to you and yours! We hope you're all staying safe and sane as you! Dylan tells us all about his Burger King experience and not really saving two puppies. Madison tells us of her recent trip to NYC, and Dylan shocks us all by dropping some hidden lore about his own time in the Big Apple. This week, Madi...

74. The Deadliest Tiny Little Guy of All Time (Simo Häyhä) 15.12.2025

We're back with another episode! Madison is stricken once again with another bout of bronchitis. We talk about double lung transplants, high school reunions and learning / not learning to type. In this episode, Dylan talks about Simo Häyhä, the Finnish sniper with over 500 confirmed kills. We talk about his tactics, time in the war, the brutal injury that took him out of combat and his life af...

73. I Don't Deserve the Socks (Katherine Mary Knight: Australia's Hannibal Lector) 08.12.2025

Episode 73 is here and we're getting our groove back! Except, not really cause Dylan made some terrible shoe noises, David shaved his face into a train robbing mustache, and Madison couldn't give blood. But we're TRYING to get our groove back! This week, Madison covers the grisly story of Katherine Mary Knight, also known as the Australian Hannibal Lector and the first woman in Austral...

72. 65 Investigations Before the Age of 20 (The Barefoot Bandit) 24.11.2025

We're backkkkk! Again! After a (shorter) hiatus, we sit down to talk about an eerie moment with a mystery smartphone, Madison's musical mishaps and the invention of tape and glue. On today’s episode, Dylan covers the Barefoot Bandit, a troubled teenager who stole cars, boats and even planes, gaining a reputation as an outlaw folk hero as his crimes continued to escalate.  Thanks for listen...

71. Dylan's Gastrointestinal Distress ( The Austin Yogurt Shop Murders) 04.11.2025

WE'RE BAAAA-AAAACK! Aren't you glad to see us pop up in your feed again? After an unexpected hiatus, we're finally back (almost) just in time for My Existential Crisis' 3 year anniversary! This week, Dylan tells us all about his travel mishaps, while insisting that he's a responsible adult and Madison breaks down into yet again, another existential crisis. That's why she st...

70. I'm Quite Frankly Delightful (The Most Disturbing Parasites) 15.09.2025

Episode 70, we're back! Dylan Bug-ger talks about his recent fight against fleas, "happy hoodies" and smart homes. Madison talks about the breadth of her fascinating/unnerving interests and a disappointing casting decision. In today's episode, Dylan covers the top five most terrifying parasites and one man who loves them just a little too much. He then caps off one of our grossest episodes yet wit...

69. That's Plagiarism, Baby! (The Disappearance of Natasha Ryan) 02.09.2025

It's episode SIXTY-NIIIIIINE! Madison is her most boring, dad-like iteration as she talks about her love of America's greatest past time. (Guys, plant your feet before throwing a baseball, for the love of all that's holy!) Dylan has a livelier time talking about the ROI of Dollar Dogs at a local baseball stadium, dancing his little feet off, and swimming his guppy heart out. This week, Madison cov...

68. In Space, No One Can Hear You Horn (AI Romance) 25.08.2025

Episode 68! 32 episodes from the big 100, we're almost there. Dylan talks about a wholesome moment he saw on his drive and whether airhorns would work in space. Madison discusses her recent 9-hour long Twilight Imperium session before discussing violence around Harrisburg. In this episode, Dylan delves into the emerging phenomenon of AI romance. He talks about Replika, Character. AI and the r/AISo...

67. A Poetic Lone Cooked Pancake (The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell) 18.08.2025

Episode 67 is here and we are back to our regularly scheduled programming! Dylan recalls his coffee drinking foibles, an unnoticed disappearance, and a regifted "little guy." Madison shares her bittersweet emotions after leaving her last show and shares her love of classic musicals (while emphasizing how she is NOT racist.) This week, Madison tells the story of the disappearance of Susan...

66. One Person's Daemon Is Another Person's Guardian Onion (Daimonions, Daimons and Daemons) 11.08.2025

We're back with episode 66! Dylan has to be put down because of a pulled rhomboid. Madison's life has slowed down, but her brain keeps speeding up. In today's episode, Dylan and Madison talk about Socrates' guiding inner voice, his "daimonion." They trace the idea across centuries, discuss theories and tie past episodes together to arrive at something cohesive. Thanks for...

Bullshit or No Shit: Episode 6 29.07.2025

We're back on our bullshit! We're switching things up again with Bullshit or No Shit, inspired by the 90s show "Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction." Madison share 5 stories, some true, some completely made up, all completely bizarre. It's up to you to decide which is which. At the end, we will reveal which are Bullshit and which are No Shit. Thanks for listening, and if you like...

Cryptid Interview Round 2025 07.07.2025

MEC, My Existential Corp, is interviewing for the highly valued position of unpaid intern. Five cryptids have applied — the Squonk, Mothman, the Pukwudgie, the Thunderbird and Sasquatch. We grade each on what they're wearing to the interview, their poise during the interview itself and their competency with office tools. Who will emerge as the victor? Listen to find out. If you like what you hear,...

65. Commercial Innovation Over Public Safety! (The OceanGate Submersible Disaster) 01.07.2025

We're back with episode 65 and I promise it's worth the wait! This week, Dylan kicks us off my telling us about a morbid omen that laid literally at his feet: a dead crow-sized crow. This sparks a discussion about Dylan's dislike for nature and travel and Madison's apparent love for the Grand Canyon, all in the search of finding what we value. Ultimately, this is one of our most wholesome openings...

64. A Near Miss at Shaffer's (Quantum Immortality) 16.06.2025

What do we cover in the intro? What don't we cover in the intro. We go into the *perfect* French toast recipe, severe hyperpronation, Vicodin, and, of course, baseball. We also talk about Sabrina Carpenter's controversial new album cover. In this episode, Dylan covers quantum immortality, the theory that we continue to live indefinitely, switching into parallel universes to avoid death. We talk ab...

63. The Delightfulness of It All (The Murder of Bob Crane) 11.06.2025

It's episode 63 and we're coming at you with the most wholesome of intros today. We throw it back to driving lessons, Madison's unparalleled parallel parking skills, and Dylan dreaming about dogs made of flowers and skiing with a Greek bust statue. This week, Madison takes us into an Octogenarian's dream with the some old Hollywood gossip: the murder of Bob Crane. A rising Hollywoo...

Bullshit or No Shit: Episode 5 03.06.2025

We're back on our bullshit! We're switching things up again with Bullshit or No Shit, inspired by the 90s show "Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction." Madison share 5 stories, some true, some completely made up, all completely bizarre. It's up to you to decide which is which. At the end, we will reveal which are Bullshit and which are No Shit. Thanks for listening, and if you like...

62. General Decrepit Ruins, At Your Service (The Soul Trap Theory) 27.05.2025

Happy Memorial Day! We're coming at you with episode 62 and we have a rather grim one for you today. But first, Dylan tells us about his new purchase and we're eagerly awaiting the visuals for it. He's also become a hat guy, but wants to make it clear that he's not a fedora guy. Madison talks briefly about her travels from the last 2 weeks where she went to Kenya, Budapest, Vienna,...

61. Aaron the Ripper (The Disappearance and Reappearance of Alicia Navarro) 19.05.2025

We've reached episode 61! Not exactly a huge milestone but impressive nonetheless. Dylan talks about his experience taking voice lessons and gives his best rendition of John Dylnver's "Take Me Home, Country Roads." Madison provides an update on one of the oldest cases in true crime history, the mystery of Jack the Ripper's identity. She also updates us on the Vallow-Daybell case before going into...

60. God Cursed Me and I Said "Thank You" (The Horrors of Microplastics) 12.05.2025

We've reached our 60th episode! And Dylan has reached his 30th birthday. We talk about Oddjob Hats (not a sponsor - yet), Steven King movies, secret cookie recipes and unassuming drug dealers. In this episode, Dylan goes into the emerging panic surrounding microplastics, from its origins to the current day conversation around this growing issue. We go into the health problems caused by micropl...

59. Have You Heard of Mindfulness? (John Wayne Gacy Part 3) 05.05.2025

This week, we conclude our three-part series on John Wayne Gacy. Dylan and Madison talk about their favorite episodes of My Existential Crisis, Dylan's 30th birthday and anxiety-inducing psychiatry calls to discuss anxiety. An important question is posed: Is napping a hobby? For the final part of this series, Madison goes into Gacy's methods, his court case and execution. We talk about the grisly...

58. The One Animal You Won't See on an African Safari (John Wayne Gacy Part 2) 28.04.2025

We're back with part two of our three-part series on John Wayne Gacy. Dylan talks about his disheartening experience with an Instagram scammer and his heartening experience with a large branch. Madison goes into her upcoming trip to Kenya and the tiger-less safari she has planned. In this second part, we follow Gacy's descent into increasingly violent and erratic behavior as investigators...

57. An Unimpressed Confederate Ghost Soldier (John Wayne Gacy Part 1) 21.04.2025

It's episode 57! Dylan and Madison talk for 20 minutes about all the things life has brought them in the last few weeks. Dylan has a creepy crawly scare which sent Madison into "go-mode," and Madison experienced a ghostly occurrence at the Gettysburg battlefield. This week (and the next two subsequent weeks), Madison brings us part one of the account of John Wayne Gacy and his many v...

Listen to the My Existential Crisis podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.