Madison Eppley

My Existential Crisis

From world mysteries to strange scientific phenomena, conspiracy theories, paranormal activity, and true crime, join us on Mondays as we talk through all the weird things that make us question our entire sense of self. This is My Existential Crisis.

Author

Madison Eppley

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

podcasters.spotify.com

Latest episode

Feb 9, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

56. Big Chair Problems & Pastry Chef Aspirations (The Mystical Mount Kailash) 07.04.2025

Another week, another episode! Dylan talks about his problematic purchase of an overly large office chair, bemoaning the reaction of his coworkers. Madison makes an enemy of a curb, talking in graphic detail about the tumble she took. Dylan then goes on to discuss the mysterious Mount Kailash, a place of great religious significance in many Eastern religions. The mountain, never formally summited,...

55. My Happy Meal Ass & a Bubble Wrap Salesman (The Death of Tina Watson) 31.03.2025

We're here with episode 55 and we're feeling some weird energy today. We're joined by Binx in the studio today while we talk more about Madison's recent cruise, Dylan's selfish habits, banana milk, childhood nostalgia, and much more this time around. We just can't seem to shut up. This week, Madison brings the story of the death of Tina Watson. It's both solved and unso...

54. Taming the Tain & Syncing the Hemis (The Dark Side of Meditation) 24.03.2025

We're back with another episode! We hear more about Dylan's ski trip to Vermont, all the whacky falls and the surprising fact that you can, actually, get sunburned when it's snowy and cold. Madison tells us about her Google Bot costume, created with duct tape and determination for a surreal birthday celebration. This week, Dylan covers the dark side of meditation, going into facts and...

53. A Hairline Fracture in My Sanity & Wasabi Schwabe (Third Man Syndrome) 19.03.2025

We're slightly delayed, but BACK with episode 53! This week, Madison talks more about her upcoming travel plans, some upside down pineapple lore, fears of human trafficking, and Somalian pirates, but that's just a normal Tuesday for her. Dylan provides no comfort at all, but still remains incredibly optimistic despite the troublesome state of the world. Don't worry though, we've go...

52. Fatal Prosciutto & Little Tiny Guys (Bashar the Extraterrestrial) 10.03.2025

Episode 52 is here, and it's a weird one. We talk about a close call with a (near) fatal appetizer, precognitive knowledge of raffle drawings and the growing conversation around telepathy in people and pets. Is it real, and if not, how do our cats know when to come to the door when we arrive home? There's literally no other explanation. This week, Dylan is covering Darryl Anka (Darryl, not...

51. 2020 Thrive, 2020 Drive & Wig Talk (The Story of Blanche Monnier) 03.03.2025

We're on episode 51 and we are having the time of our lives. Madison has won a trip to KENYA, where she will embark on a 20 hour flight for a total of over 2 days of travel. She's going to be pumped full of inoculations and root beer-flavored malaria pills in order to have the opportunity of a lifetime. Dylan, equally as impressive(?), is *maybe* driving across the country in the fall, but that's...

50. Tactical Feeling & An Unimpressive Ice Crystal (Is Water Sentient?) 24.02.2025

We're officially over the hill with episode 50! It's been a long journey, but we've loved every bit of it. We're especially unhinged this week with lots of passionate conversation and fun facts. Madison rants about society's lack of knowledge on how to use roundabouts properly and indulges us all in a traffic safety lesson. Overall, we've determined that we're upon the end times and Dylan informs...

49. An After-After Birthday and a Puckered Blowhole (The Girl Who Talked to Dolphins) 18.02.2025

After a very very (very) long unintentional hiatus from technological and viral illness, we are BACK with episode 49! This week, the duo get caught up on all the things they've missed talking about over the last month: wedding planning, a broken shelf, devilish cats, etc. Madison brings the tragic, sensual star-crossed tale of Margaret Lovatt and Peter... the dolphin. While the story is not as tit...

48. My Bare Hands & A Communal Mail Slot (The Murder of Robert Eric Wone) 13.01.2025

Welcome to episode 48! We're diving into 2025 with lots of goals and growth! We're getting bronchy honky tonky squonky up in here! We're losing our minds and diving headfirst into existential dread after last week's episode... This week, Madison brings a real doozy. If you wanted something simple, this is not it. Madison covers the unsolved and incredibly mysterious murder of Robert Eric Wone. It'...

47. Binaural Beats to Shift Your Reality To (Google's Willow Chip & Parallel Universes) 06.01.2025

New year, new us! Welcome to episode 47 and a brand new year! Twenty-twenty-five, twenty-twenty THRIVE, am I right? Surprise surprise, Madison is sick again, but Dylan is feeling better than ever. We aren't ones for resolutions, but Madison's goal is going to be carrying Madame Zeroni up the mountain to fix her lungs. This week, Dylan breaks our brains by talking about Google's recent breakthrough...

46. A Tinfoil Hat & the Star Trek Parallel (The Mystery Drones Over New Jersey) 30.12.2024

It's episode 46 and we're just jumping right into our story today! In this episode, Dylan dives deep into the recent mysterious drone and orb appearances over New Jersey and across the globe. We speculate their origins, how much the government knows, and the best and worse case scenarios of these sightings. We're talking aliens, orbs, and parallel universes. In case you thought we were sane, this...

45. Two Gleeks and an Anheuser Schnauzer (The Circleville Letters) 24.12.2024

It's episode 45 and although the opening banter got cut a little short, it certainly wasn't lacking depth. Our very own Madison is now a betrothed woman! Now if only she can stop hurting her fingers so she can put on that ring. This week, Madison covers the decades-long mystery of the Circleville letters. It's giving Agatha Christie, it's giving James Patterson, it's giving Gossip Girl vibes. If n...

Cryptid Beauty Pageant 2024 17.12.2024

Welcome to a special episode of My Existential Crisis! Today, we aren't pitting our beloved cryptids up to fight with their strength; this week, they're fighting with their fierceness in a Cryptid Beauty Pageant! Our six fabulous contestants are the Squonk, Sasquatch, Mothman, Thunderbird, the Loch Ness Monster, and the Mongolian Death Worm. We'll judge their beauty, charm, and talent on a scale o...

Bullshit or No Shit: Episode 4 10.12.2024

We're back on our bullshit! We're switching things up again with Bullshit or No Shit, inspired by the 90s show "Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction." Madison share 5 stories, some true, some completely made up, all completely bizarre. It's up to you to decide which is which. At the end, we will reveal which are Bullshit and which are No Shit. Thanks for listening, and if you like what you hear, take th...

44. My Dumb Ass & the Banana Factory (The Mysterious Death Of Jonathan Luna) 02.12.2024

It's episode 44 and we've got some good stuff for you today! This week Madison discusses her not-so-near death experience with tetanus and David's homemade chicken nuggies. Dylan talks about his recent audition experience for a short film and how he misunderstood an improv exercise. We also received an email from a listener with her own theory about the Jon Benet Ramsey case. To inform ourselves b...

43. A Busted Rhomboid & a Space-Faring Furry (The Story of Suzanne Sevakis) 26.11.2024

Episode 43 is here! We're back bigger than ever before with one of our longest episodes despite inly covering one story. Dylan talks about his recent gym experience as a Certified Jock™️and his other experience playing a 10-hour board game where he played a space cat person. Madison talks about the show she just finished and her aspirations for her long-awaited break. This week, Madison tell us th...

42. A Gustatory Hallucination & My Deity, Big Bird (The Bardo Thodol) 18.11.2024

It's episode 42 of My Existential Crisis and also the 2nd anniversary of its inception! After an unintentional hiatus and technical difficulties, we are back and stronger than ever! That is, despite the grim nature of the world. But, no matter! This week, Dylan takes us on a journey through the afterlife with the Bardo Thodol, the Tibetan Book of the Dead that is meant to help direct a soul throug...

41. Not THAT Much of a Loser & a Pickle Phobia (The Final Fantasy Cult & Herb Baumeister) 07.10.2024

Welcome to episode 41, where Dylan and Madison descend into utter madness. Seriously, they're on a different level this episode. I don't know what to tell you. Dylan starts talking about his fall fashion choices and Madison talks about her improv class's recent performance including an American tragedy, the Muppets, and hospice care. This week, Dylan covers the Final Fantasy Cult which gets Madiso...

40. Mundune Interactions & Nephewtism (Extreme Performance Art & the Salem Witch Trials) 24.09.2024

We made it to episode 40!!! Madison tells us all about her recent trip to Boston where she laments the amount she paid in parking and all the pee she stepped in. Dylan tells us about his adventures with lucid dreaming and shares some excerpts from his dream journal. Inspired by Madison's most recent BS or NS episode flub, Dylan tells us about some of the most well known extreme performance art...

39. Slot Wheels & Blackjack Deals and a Cake Situation (Rosemary Kennedy & Determinism) 09.09.2024

It's episode 39 and we're starting off strong with climbing metaphorical mountains to emotional, spiritual, and social progress and we end poorly with bleeped out casinos and comparing funerial preparation of dead bodies to cake construction. Madison starts with the tragic tale of the forgotten Kennedy (yes, of THAT Kennedy lineage), Rosemary. Although her life was tumultuous for the way s...

38. Squonk ASMR & A Haunted Nissan Juke (MEC Podcast Trivia & Cotard's Syndrome) 26.08.2024

Hey Crisis Cuties! It's episode 38 and that becomes incredibly relevant for Dylan's part of the episode. First, Dylan regales us with the terrifying tale of his broken car fob and his not-so near death experience because of it. Madison has very little to say for once except that she will forever hold a grudge for those who didn't tell her about Squonkapolooza. This week, Dylan has some...

Cryptid Tournament Bracket #2 12.08.2024

*airhorn blast* Welcome to the showdown of a century! Here, the ookiest, spookiest cryptids will face off in a fight. Based on what we know from lore, Dylan and Madison will debate on who will be the victor. Will Nessie take the crown? Will the Jersey Devil live up to his name? Will the Batsquatch give his cousin a run for his money? Let us know who YOU think would win! Once that’s squared away, t...

37. A Cheddar Bay Biscuit Scheme and a Skeleton Baby (H.H. Holmes & The Black Paintings of Francisco Goya) 30.07.2024

Episode 37 is here and we start off by seeing how poorly our minds are melded. Madison has a LOT to share about her fever dream of a trip to Maine, so buckle up. Dylan tells us about his summer staycation that is much less interesting, but still valid. This week, Madison tells the very long (and maybe not entirely true) story of H.H. Holmes. Dylan brings his love of art history to the MEC cesspool...

Bullshit or No Shit: Episode 3 15.07.2024

We're back on our bullshit! We're switching things up again with Bullshit or No Shit, inspired by the 90s show "Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction." Dylan and Madison each share 3 stories, some true, some completely made up, all completely bizarre. It's up to you to decide which is which. At the end, we will reveal which are Bullshit and which are No Shit. Thanks for listening, a...

36. Mormons Be Crazy & Forbidden Boba (The Kidnappings of Jan Broberg Part 2 & The Worst Drinks Ever Made) 03.06.2024

We're over halfway through our dirty thirties on episode 36! Dylan and Madison take an accidental existential tangent through classic literature, recent past times, and ham costumes. Madison finished the infuriating tale of the kidnappings of Jan Broberg. It starts off like a rocket and we go downhill from there. Dylan tries lifting our spirits by disgusting us with the most disgusting drinks...

Listen to the My Existential Crisis podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.