Crit & Fumble

In the crevices of the Carag mountains a rushing waterfall deadens the sound of a man gone insane and his evil machinations. What secrets lie in these caverns? Join our adventurous party as they get one step closer to discovering the source of these troubling arcane forces. Played on Daggerheart.

𝑪𝒓𝒊𝒕 & 𝑭𝒖𝒎𝒃𝒍𝒆 returns with "𝔸𝕟 𝕌𝕟𝕗𝕠𝕣𝕥𝕦𝕟𝕒𝕥𝕖 𝕌𝕤𝕖 𝕆𝕗 𝕄𝕒𝕘𝕚𝕔”, a brand new 𝑫𝒂𝒈𝒈𝒆𝒓𝒉𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕campaign DM’d by Russ Morland in his theatrical, chaos-loving, 10-part-campaign debut. In our premiere, the party crashes headfirst into trouble: a tavern chase, an ominous skyship, potion peddling, unstable magical loot, and a vicious direwolf attack that leaves a small town reeling… with guidance from a sus...

"𝔸𝕟 𝕌𝕟𝕗𝕠𝕣𝕥𝕦𝕟𝕒𝕥𝕖 𝕌𝕤𝕖 𝕆𝕗 𝕄𝕒𝕘𝕚𝕔" is Russ Morland’s (aka Lurk Loves You) first full campaign with 𝑪𝒓𝒊𝒕 & 𝑭𝒖𝒎𝒃𝒍𝒆, and we’re diving into it with 𝑫𝒂𝒈𝒈𝒆𝒓𝒉𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕, the bold, theatrical new TTRPG from Darrington Press  Meet the new party. Reconnect with familiar faces. Witness our first chaotic dive into the 𝑫𝒂𝒈𝒈𝒆𝒓𝒉𝒆𝒂𝒓𝒕 system in this pre-campaign one-shot filled with terrible flirting, questiona...

Step behind the curtain with the Crit & Fumble crew as we unpack the making of Underworld . Hosted by our GM and resident chaos conductor Gavin Vickery, this behind-the-scenes episode dives into the moments that worked, the ones we totally overlooked, and what surprised us most along the way. We answer some great listener questions, reflect on the arc as a whole, things we missed, and surprisi...

They’ve come too far to turn back. Cherie, Bastion, Maydor, Sküggi, and Ophelie push through the depths of Wailscar, chasing answers wrapped in shadow, lies, guilt, violence, and pride. The truth behind the Underworld’s cruel game lies within reach, but so does the edge of ruin. Debts come due. Secrets unravel. Trust falters. The final confrontation demands more than strength and not everyone will...

As Wailscar folds in on itself, reflections twist into revelations. A younger, merciless Ophelie stalks from the past with eyes too familiar. Maydor drifts through guilt he thought he’d buried, but never stopped bleeding. In the Oracle’s silence, Cherie is handed a blade and the weight of a choice no one else could make. Sküggi, when offered a reflection, chooses tone he failed, and the ache that...

The battle for Bloodhearth reaches its brutal peak as the party faces a monstrous champion in a trial of strength, fire, and resolve. But victory is only the beginning. Beyond the arena lies Grayspire—a place of shifting halls, fractured memory, and reflections that cut deeper than steel. As old tensions flare, two party members begin to unravel a connection that runs far deeper than they imagined...

In Bloodhearth, the air hangs heavy with smoke and heat. Blades clash. A cursed weapon is dragged from the fire and gripped with shaking resolve. Statues dusted in ash watch in silence, their cryptic warnings echoing as the party presses deeper into the trial. Ahead, a monolith of a gate looms… sealed by design, veiled in mystery, and unwilling to open without cost. One falls in the attempt, burne...

The cracks are starting to show. Whispers. Side glances. A quiet shove that nearly becomes a blade. The weight of what they’ve done, and what they’ve hidden, presses down on the group like never before. No one says it out loud, but the trust is thinning. As they prepare to face the brutal trials of Bloodhearth, tempers flare and loyalties bend. If the fire doesn’t break them… something else might....

They say you’re only as young as you feel. After battling a demon and watching a friend vanish into death, the weight of the Underworld begins to show. Bastion is back—but not untouched. Dark dreams creep in. A relic burns with buried power. And trust wears thin among the living. The party presses on, soul-weary and splintering, while a certain witch watches... waiting. There’s no youth left here....

In the bleak heart of the Underworld, where every step echoes with the weight of the past, the party finds themselves surrounded by smiles that hide daggers. They can’t trust anyone— not the unnervingly cheerful hag, not the silver-tongued demon offering bargains, and maybe… not even each other. A relic, long thought lost, glimmers beneath ash and bone. A choice is made. A truth is buried. And whe...

The party pushes deeper into the 𝖀𝖓𝖉𝖊𝖗𝖜𝖔𝖗𝖑𝖉… and things only get stranger. A floating corpse, soul-sucking leeches, and a cursed trinket are just the beginning. Their gear? Held hostage by a grizzled merchant demanding soul shards as payment. Their only guide? A soft-spoken seer who knows too much. And that hag with the warm smile? Yeah… no way that’s normal. Dark choices, twisted bargains, and sh...

As we kick off this new campaign, our adventurers find themselves trapped in the unsettling Underworld of  Ashmourn . Stripped of their gear and confronted by ghostly echoes of themselves, they encounter a mysterious little girl who holds the key to their predicament. As they navigate this twisted realm, the party grapples with their fears and memories, challenging them to confront their pasts. Wi...

In this episode of  Tales from the Table , we take you behind the scenes of our last arc in the  Pirates of the Lost Fleet campaign. Join the crew as we break down the chaotic high-seas action, unexpected character moments, and the wild curveballs that kept both the players and the DM on their toes. From daring naval battles to mysterious map fragments, we reflect on how the last few episodes came...

With one player missing, the crew jumps into a one-shot using Goblin Quest , the chaotically hilarious RPG by Grant Howitt . What follow is pure goblin mayhem. The five clutches of goblins, each played by one of our players, unite for a mission of supreme importance: infiltrate the Curious GoblinCon , pose as craft vendors, and assassinate the infamous bugbear Astin Sean to recover the Gobling Kin...

Join us around the table as Sean, the GM for our Vaesen prelude, gets relentlessly pelted by questions from Chelsea! (The rest of us ask some questions too).

Our investigators uncover the truth behind the death of Archibald Prescott, but just as things are looking up, the mystery takes a deadly turn. Join the Crit and Fumblers for the thrilling conclusion of Vaesen - Prelude. Played on Vaesen.

Part 1 of a two part VAESEN adventure, DMed by Sean Murray. Join the investigators of the Society as they unravel a truly sticky situation. When a body is discovered on the shores of the inner harbour, covered in a strange ichor, the group must piece together the clues to uncover the identity of this John Doe and the circumstances of his untimely demise. Will they unravel this tangled web of magic...

The crew of the Scurvy Lady face off against the Tide Sovereign and fight to save Sargasso. Played on D&D.

The crew of the Scurvy Lady prepare for the coming battle with the Tide Sovereign. Played on D&D.

Su, Warbles, Darvin and Eldric pursue the Heart of the Tides with their band of merry, and mostly willing, crew. Played on D&D.

Su, Darvin, Warbles, and Eldric fight to get their ship and crew back, Mawrow bides his time in the dungeon with his new cell mate. Played on D&D.

Join us around the table as we chat about our first community night and get another behind the scenes look with Chelsea, our Dungeon Mistress for the Pirates of the Lost Fleet campaign.

Eldric learns more about the source of his magic and makes a choice. The crew finds the Heart of the Tides. Played on D&D.

A long awaited meeting with the leader of Sargasso brings unexpected revelations, Warbles meets with a face from his past, Eldric takes a trip, the crew find a mysterious guardian at the steps to the Heart of the Tides Played on D&D.