Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Cinema IRL

Comedy EN ↓ 288 episodes

Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy. From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life. Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an...

Author

Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

cinema-irl.donecast.com

Latest episode

Jul 10, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

E188 - Weapons - What Would YOU Do? 19.09.2025

Amber and Scott discuss the mystery thriller "Weapons," where nearly an entire class of children vanishes, leaving only one student and a community searching for answers. The film uses an intriguing, multi-perspective storytelling style, but leaves some plot points unresolved. The hosts debate the film's strengths and weaknesses, engaging in their signature "What Would You Do?" segments about the...

E187 - The Home - What Would YOU Do? 17.09.2025

Amber and Scott discuss "The Home," a horror film where a young man performing community service at a retirement home uncovers a terrifying, decades-long conspiracy involving the residents' agelessness. They debate the film's plausibility, explore the ethical dilemmas faced by characters, and delve into some truly bizarre and darkly comedic moments. Expect plenty of "What Would You Do" scenarios a...

E186 - The Bad Guys 2 - What Would YOU Do? 15.09.2025

Amber and Scott, joined by their resident werewolf correspondent Morty, review "The Bad Guys 2," an animated film about reformed criminal animals struggling to navigate life as good guys. They discuss the film's themes of redemption, societal perception, and the challenges of changing one's identity. The episode also features their signature "What Would You Do" segment, exploring ethical dilemmas...

E185 - The Naked Gun - What Would YOU Do? 13.09.2025

Amber and Scott, joined by a surprise guest (or are they?), delve into the comedic chaos of "The Naked Gun." They discuss the film's absurd humor, Liam Neeson's performance as Frank Drebin Jr., and the movie's surprisingly relevant commentary on class and societal power dynamics. Prepare for a wildly unpredictable conversation filled with tangents and possibly audio proof of Scott losing his mind.

E184 - Sketch - What Would YOU Do? 08.09.2025

Amber and Scott, joined by Scott's mom Donna, discuss the film "Sketch," a PG-rated horror movie where a girl's drawings come to life. They explore the film's themes of grief, family communication, and the importance of emotional outlets, interwoven with hilarious tangents and a "What Would You Do?" segment. The episode also features a fun discussion about the film's unusual production and distrib...

E183 - The Fantastic 4: First Steps - What Would YOU Do? 05.09.2025

Amber and Scott discuss the 2025 Fantastic Four film, focusing on the absurdity of the plot and the characters' questionable decisions. They debate the moral dilemma of sacrificing a baby to save the Earth from Galactus and delve into the unexpected subplot of Johnny Storm's crush on Silver Surfer. The conversation takes humorous and unexpected turns, exploring various "what would you do" scenario...

E182 - House on Eden - What Would YOU Do? 03.09.2025

What happens when a director watches a little too much Blair Witch Project and says "Hell, I can do that with a haunted house?". You get the movie Amber and Scott are discussing today, House on Eden

E181 - Oh, Hi! - What Would YOU Do? 01.09.2025

I know handcuffs can help to keep a relationship spicy, but this was too much spice as Amber and Scott discuss Oh, Hi!

E180 - Together - What Would YOU Do? 29.08.2025

Everyone likes a good two-for-one...until you're one of the two. Amber and Scott tackle the metamorphic thriller, Together

E179 - The Smurfs - What Would YOU Do? 22.08.2025

What's blue, talks funny, and is three apples tall? No, it's not your emo baby brother, it's what Amber and Scott are discussing today: The Smurfs

E178 - I Know What You Did Last Summer - What Would YOU Do? 20.08.2025

Today Amber and Scott discuss what everyone should know by now: When you eff around, eventually you're gonna find out.

E177 - Eddington - What Would YOU Do? 19.08.2025

You think national politics are rough? You should try small town local politics. I hear its....killer, as Amber and Scott discuss Eddington.

E176 - Abraham's Boys: A Dracula Story - What Would YOU Do? 16.08.2025

Turns out Van Helsing was kind of a dick, as Amber, Scott, and our guest Von Murder discuss after watching Abraham's Boys: A Dracula Story.

E175 - Superman - What Would YOU Do? 14.08.2025

It's a bird! It's a plane! No, it's a box office bonanza! Amber and Scott discuss the movie Superman.

E174 - Skillhouse - What Would YOU Do? 08.08.2025

Social media can sometimes feel like a life or death game to our younger generation. That mindset will serve them well as Amber and Scott discuss Skillhouse.

E173 - Sorry, Baby - What Would YOU Do? 06.08.2025

Being a writer can be hard, but it shouldn't be casting couch hard Amber and Scott discuss after watching "Sorry, Baby"

E172 - Elio - What Would YOU Do? 04.08.2025

I envy the protagonist of today's movie, "Elio". He wants to get off this planet to find something more. I just want to find some kind of intelligent beings. Would Amber and Scott blast off? Let's find out.

E171 - F1 The Movie - What Would YOU Do? 02.08.2025

It was a 2 1/2 hour movie about car racing. Thank god it wasn't NASCAR, though, as Amber and Scott discuss "F1 The Movie", not to be confused with "F1 The Tornado" which was a little weak.

E170 - Jurassic World Rebirth - What Would YOU Do? 29.07.2025

Today, Scott puts his stamp on the world of Paleontology by naming the absolute ugliest dinosaur ever as he and Amber discuss "Jurassic World Rebirth"

E169 - Bride Hard - What Would YOU Do? 25.07.2025

If Bridesmaids had a baby with Die Hard, but Bridesmaids drank a lot of alcohol while pregnant, you would get Amber and Scott's movie today: "Bride Hard"

E168 - 40 Acres - What Would YOU Do? 21.07.2025

Humans and Zombies and Cannibals, oh my! Jimmy stops by to debate, well, whether he should have stopped by after Amber and Scott watched 40 Acres.

E167 - Materialists - What Would YOU Do? 18.07.2025

New boyfriend or old boyfriend? Rich boyfriend or poor boyfriend? Having a boyfriend, or not having a boyfriend? You'd think these questions might be easier for a matchmaker, but as Amber and Scott discuss after watching "Materialists", not so much.

E166 - M3GAN 2.0 - What Would YOU Do? 16.07.2025

Hold on to your vaginas, everyone's favorite murderous AI bitch is back as Amber and Scott discuss Megan two point oh.

E165 - 28 Years Later - What Would YOU Do? 14.07.2025

This week on Cinema IRL, it's just Scott and Jimmy as they dissect "28 Years Later"... without Amber's calming influence. Scott struggles to keep the show on the rails as they delve into the rage-filled world of the "R" virus zombies. Jimmy, our resident zombie expert, draws sharp distinctions between the "R" virus and his own "T" virus, leading to some surprisingly philosophical and hilarious deb...

E164 - How To Train Your Dragon - What Would YOU Do? 11.07.2025

At first I wanted to get a Miniature Cow, but are you telling me getting a pet dragon is on the table? Because if so, hell yes! Amber and Scott discuss "How to Train Your Dragon"

Listen to the Cinema IRL podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.