Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt
Cinema IRL
Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy. From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life. Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an...
Author
Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 10, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
E213 - After the Hunt - What Would YOU Do? 22.11.2025 28:43
This week, we delve into "After the Hunt," where a Yale professor finds herself entangled in a campus scandal when a student accuses a colleague of misconduct, stirring up secrets from her own past. This thriller boasts Julia Roberts, a heavy-handed music score, and bizarre close-ups of hands--as if the actors were perpetually auditioning for a hand-modeling gig. The team dives deep into the he-sa...
E212 - If I Had Legs I'd Kick You- What Would YOU Do? 21.11.2025 23:06
This week, the podcast crew analyzes the strangely-titled film, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You. The movie follows Linda, a therapist dealing with a lot: a sick child, a missing husband, and a burgeoning crush on her equally-terrible therapist. Is this descent into madness a cautionary tale, or just a melodramatic mess?
E211 - Good Fortune - What Would YOU Do? 20.11.2025 37:53
This week, the podcast crew watches Aziz Ansari's "Good Fortune," a movie where a well-meaning angel swaps the lives of a struggling gig worker and a wealthy venture capitalist, leading to chaos and surprisingly relevant social commentary. They dissect the movie's laugh-out-loud humor and explore all the "What Would You Do?" scenarios that arise when money and morality collide. Was the movie's soc...
E210 - Roofman - What Would YOU Do? 19.11.2025 18:31
This week, we analyze "Roofman," the true story of Jeffrey Manchester, who earned his nickname by robbing McDonald's through their roofs! After escaping from prison, he hides out in a Toys R Us, leading to an unexpectedly complicated life on the lam. Can a life of crime coexist with romance and social obligations?
E209 – Coyotes - What Would YOU Do? 18.11.2025 23:21
In this episode, the podcast crew subjects themselves to a movie about a family terrorized by coyotes, and the results are as predictable as they are painful. Was it horror? Was it comedy? The only thing for sure is that it was bad PR for our four-legged friends.
E208 - Good Boy - What Would YOU Do? 17.11.2025 24:34
In this episode, the podcast crew watches "Good Boy," where a very good boy named Indy becomes the star of a haunted house thriller. But is the plot as good as Indy's acting? They dive into the movie's shortcomings, the brilliance of Indy's performance, and debate the ethics of gifting taxidermy to vegans.
E207 – Dead of Winter - What Would YOU Do? 16.11.2025 26:46
This week, we brave a snow-covered landscape for "Dead of Winter," where a seemingly innocent fishing trip turns into a fight for survival. When a fisherwoman witnesses a kidnapping, she has to decide how far she's willing to go to save a life. The burning question: is a liver worth more than a life?
E206 - One Battle After Another - What Would YOU Do? 14.11.2025 28:26
In this episode, the podcast crew dives into a twisty Leonardo DiCaprio flick where a revolutionary dad and daughter duo try to outrun a past filled with bank heists and betrayals. When a blast from the past resurfaces, it's one battle after another for this off-grid family. But the real question is: Can you ever truly escape your history, or is it destined to catch up with you in the most unexpec...
E205 – Doin' It - What Would YOU Do? 12.11.2025 34:39
In "Doing It," a virgin sex-ed teacher hilariously fumbles her way through adolescence, relationships, and the wild world of sex. This movie is a classic case of something that was very entertaining, but also very terrible. Get ready to laugh and cringe as they unpack all the awkward moments, the questionable advice, and the surprisingly poignant moments in this raunchy comedy.
E204 – Him - What Would YOU Do? 10.11.2025 26:45
This week, the gang tackles "Him," a new film about a football player's, uh, *unique* training experience. Turns out, when your childhood hero invites you to his compound, you might end up dodging more than just footballs. The burning question: how much are *you* willing to sacrifice for success?
E203 - A Big Bold Beautiful Journey - What Would YOU Do? 07.11.2025 34:00
Hang on to your trauma because this week we're diving headfirst into "A Big, Bold, Beautiful Journey" where a couple of randos meet at a wedding and their rental car GPS leads them on a bizarre, door-filled adventure through their pasts. Will they find love? Will they rewrite history? Or will they just end up with really high mileage on their Saturn coupes? Screw the critics – we're here for the f...
E202 - My Mother's Wedding - What Would YOU Do? 05.11.2025 22:25
Buckle up for a wild ride as we dissect "My Mother's Wedding," a film about three sisters returning home for their mom's *third* wedding. With a twice-widowed mother about to marry a man whose last name is, yes, Love Glove, family secrets and suppressed tensions bubble to the surface in hilariously awkward ways. Get ready for sibling drama, marital infidelity, and some serious daddy issues, all se...
E201 – Twinless - What Would YOU Do? 04.11.2025 27:15
In this episode, we unravel the dark and twisty film "Twinless," where a complicated one-night stand leads to accidental tragedy, and then to some seriously questionable choices. We're left pondering friendship, grief, and the ethics of befriending someone under false pretenses. Plus, we spend way too much time dissecting the finer points of post-hookup texting etiquette.
E200 - The Long Walk - What Would YOU Do? 27.10.2025 37:24
It's our 200th episode and we're celebrating by watching "The Long Walk," a Stephen King adaptation that's basically the Hunger Games but with more walking and significantly more death. Prepare for a deep dive into psychological torture, questionable life choices, and some surprisingly bad math.
E199 - Splitsville - What Would YOU Do? 22.10.2025 30:54
This episode dives into the messy, complicated, and at times, bewildering dynamics of "Splitsville." We dissect an open marriage that goes hilariously off the rails and a relationship that could give even the most seasoned therapist a headache. Get ready for a wild ride of infidelity, unexpected pairings, and the eternal question: what *would* you do?
E198 - The Man in My Basement - What Would YOU Do? 20.10.2025
This episode unpacks the utterly bonkers and baffling premise of "The Man in My Basement," a film that leaves us questioning everything from its plot holes to the protagonist's hygiene habits. Get ready for a deep dive into a peculiar rental agreement and questionable life choices.
E197 - The Baltimorons - What Would YOU Do? 17.10.2025
This episode unpacks the surprisingly layered, and at times baffling, Christmas Eve adventure of Cliff, who chips his tooth and ends up on an unexpected journey with his emergency dentist, Dee Dee. From awkward dental etiquette to ex-husband drama, they dissect all the bizarre choices and questionable decisions made in "The Baltimorons"
E196 - The Threesome - What Would YOU Do? 15.10.2025
This episode tackles a film that, while not a documentary, hilariously explores the messy chaos of adulthood, stemming from a spur-of-the-moment threesome. Get ready for a deep dive into complicated relationships, unexpected pregnancies, and the double standards that come with it all.
E195 - The Roses - What Would YOU Do?' 13.10.2025
This episode dives into the cinematic train wreck that is "The Roses," a film that sadly forgot to learn from its iconic predecessor, "The War of the Roses." Tune in as the hosts dissect the downfall of a picture-perfect couple whose love story devolves into a hilariously bitter, materialistic war of wills, complete with deep fakes and questionable hosting skills.
E194 - The Toxic Avenger Unrated - What Would YOU Do? 10.10.2025
Welcome to Cinema IRL, where the hosts dissect "The Toxic Avenger" with a healthy dose of skepticism and a whole lot of sass. They tackle the movie's baffling plot points, questionable transformations, and the sheer absurdity of a hero whose superpower involves potent pee. Expect sharp critiques and a good laugh at this gloriously campy B-movie.
E193 - Eden - What Would YOU Do? 08.10.2025
Forget paradise, this "Eden" is a godforsaken island where civilization's castoffs create their own brand of hell. Expect backstabbing, murder, and questionable hygiene as a group of outsiders devolve into a primal struggle for survival.
E192 - Trust - What Would You NOT Do? 07.10.2025
Amber and Scott dive into "Trust," a thriller where a disgraced Hollywood starlet's remote cabin getaway turns into a horrifying fight for survival. They unpack the questionable decisions, the plot contrivances, and the absolutely baffling escape attempts, all while trying to recover from the movie's audacity.
E191 - Freakier Friday - What Would YOU Do? 29.09.2025
When two people switch bodies its pretty freaky. When four people switch bodies, well, it has Amber and Scott discussing the aptly named "Freakier Friday"
E190 - The Knife - What Would YOU Do? 26.09.2025
Just an FYI, if someone breaks into your house, and you, um, neutralize them, that's called self-defense. You don't need to paint any picture other than that, and you certainly don't need to be a lying family who lies, discussed after watching "The Knife"
E189 - Americana - What Would YOU Do? 23.09.2025
Amber and Scott discuss "Americana," a crime thriller centered around the theft of a priceless Native American ghost shirt. The film follows a waitress and a veteran as they pursue the stolen artifact, encountering violence, cultural clashes, and unexpected twists along the way. Their journey involves a surprisingly good child actor, a loveable but impulsive veteran, and a darkly comedic look at c...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.