Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Cinema IRL

Comedy EN ↓ 288 episodes

Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy. From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life. Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an...

Author

Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

cinema-irl.donecast.com

Latest episode

Jul 10, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

E238 - No Other Choice - What Would YOU Do? 30.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are diving into the "killer" paper economy of the acclaimed Korean thriller *No Other Choice*. After 25 years of service, protagonist Mansoo finds himself laid off and desperate enough to launch a fake company just to harvest his competitors' resumes—before deciding that "taking out the competition" should be taken literally. The hosts debate the merits of...

E237 - Anaconda - What Would YOU Do? 28.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are venturing deep into the Amazon—or at least, watching two guys in midlife crises try to do it. They’re breaking down the meta-mess that is *Anaconda*, a film where DIY filmmakers attempt to recreate the J-Lo classic only to end up in a real-life horror show involving fugitive captains and literal bags of gold. Between debating the ethics of "snake sushi"...

E236 - The Plague - What Would YOU Do? 26.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are diving headfirst into the chlorine-soaked trauma of the 2003 film *The Plague*. It’s a world of water polo, questionable hygiene, and a level of middle school bullying that makes Lord of the Flies look like a spa day. Join the hosts as they debate whether twelve-year-old boys are actually sentient humans or just walking, talking containers of locker roo...

E235 - Avatar Fire and Ash - What Would YOU Do? 23.01.2026

"Once you go blue, you’re probably just suffocating." This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are tackling the three-hour-plus marathon that is *Avatar: Fire and Ash*, a film that earns five stars for beauty and significantly fewer for its predictable plot. They dive into the "continuation" (or as Scott calls it, the "repeat") of Jake Sully’s saga, questioning why any tribal leader would ever let...

E234 - Is This Thing On? - What Would YOU Do? 21.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are dissecting the surprisingly poignant film, *Is This Thing On?* Join them as they explore a couple's messy divorce and their individual journeys of rediscovery through stand-up comedy and sports. Prepare for some relatable post-breakup chaos and a deep dive into identity.

E233 - We Bury the Dead - What Would YOU Do? 19.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, we're diving into the undead chaos of *We Bury the Dead*. Join hosts Scott and Amber as they navigate a post-apocalyptic Tasmania where a military experiment unleashes a zombie-like plague. Get ready for a wild ride of body retrieval, questionable military decisions, and a special guest appearance from zombie correspondent Jimmy to break down the science (or lack thereof).

E232 - Song Sung Blue - What Would YOU Do? 16.01.2026

This week on Cinema IRL, we're diving into the surprisingly emotional and sometimes baffling story behind the Neil Diamond tribute band film, *Song Sung Blue*. Join us as we unpack the whirlwind romance, questionable life choices, and unexpected turns of fate that befall its protagonists, all while debating the merits of keeping your word and the importance of, you know, basic healthcare.

E231 - Not Without Hope - What Would YOU Do? 05.01.2026

This week, we're diving into the gripping (and frustrating) true story behind the film *Not Without Hope*, recounting a fateful 2009 fishing trip in the Gulf of Mexico. Four friends, including two NFL players, find themselves clinging to their capsized boat, battling the relentless ocean after a string of baffling decisions. Join us as we unpack how hubris and a shocking anchor mishap turned a day...

E230 - Marty Supreme - What Would YOU Do? 02.01.2026

This week on CInema IRL we're diving headfirst into *Marty Supreme*, a film about a young man's chaotic pursuit of becoming a table tennis champion. Get ready for a wild ride through hustles, high-stakes matches, and questionable decisions, all set to a quirky soundtrack. It's a lot, even for those of us who consider ourselves "extra."

E229 - Ella McCay - What Would YOU Do? 29.12.2025

This week, we delve into the political comedy-drama "Ella McKay", where an idealistic lieutenant governor's sudden ascent to the state's highest office quickly devolves into delightful chaos. She's not just facing the pressures of her new role; she's also wrestling with a blackmailing reporter, an infuriatingly entitled husband whose blunders know no bounds, and a family that's a masterclass in dy...

E228 - One Hundred Nights of Hero - What Would YOU Do? 26.12.2025

This week, we're diving into the delightfully absurd yet terrifying world of *100 Nights of Hero*, where our protagonist Cherry finds herself in a literal "fuck or be fucked" situation. Neglected by her husband, she has 100 days to get pregnant or die, all while her spouse makes a shocking wager with a "dangerously seductive" visitor. Get ready to unpack a bizarre, patriarchal society where women...

E227 - The Running Man - What Would YOU Do? 24.12.2025

Forget your typical game shows, because this week we're strapping in for the ultimate deadly reality TV: "The Running Man". We follow Ben, a man so down on his luck he's trading survival for a paycheck, as he evades professional assassins and a bloodthirsty public. Join us as we unpack the chillingly prescient themes of deepfakes and media control, along with debates about selling out your princip...

E226 - Rental Family - What Would YOU Do? 22.12.2025

Ever felt the crushing weight of societal expectations or just longed for a little more family drama (the paid kind, of course)? This week, we're diving into Rental Family, a thought-provoking film where Brendan Fraser plays an American actor in Tokyo hired to fill all sorts of crucial (and sometimes cringe-worthy) roles in people's lives. Join us as we unpack the surprisingly human connections th...

E225 - Eternity - What Would YOU Do? 19.12.2025

Pack your bags for the afterlife, because this week we're talking about the film Eternity! In a cosmic convention center where souls have just seven days to pick their forever home from options like "Mall World" or "Pearly Gates Club Classic," Joan faces a truly impossible choice. She must decide between the first love who patiently waited 67 years for her return and the husband she spent 65 years...

E224 - Five Nights at Freddy's Two - What Would YOU Do? 17.12.2025

Amber and Scott head back to the haunted pizzeria for *Five Nights at Freddy's 2*, comparing it to the "most effed up Chuck E. Cheese takeout experience ever." They dissect a sequel bursting with "Swiss cheese" plot holes, baffling character decisions, and an unexpected cameo that thrilled the audience. Join them as they unpack why this blockbuster is a fun ride for fans, even if it's far from an...

E223 - Wicked for Good - What Would YOU Do? 15.12.2025

We truly didn't have "Wicked Witch X Scarecrow sex scene" on our 2025 bingo card, but Wicked for Good delivered anyway! Join us as we unpack the second installment, where Elphaba, now an exiled activist, fights to expose the Wizard's lies and free Oz's silenced animals. We dig into Glinda's complex role as an 'inside woman' navigating a corrupt system, the surprising origins of some classic Oz cha...

E222 - Zootopia 2 - What Would YOU Do? 13.12.2025

Get ready for a deep dive into *Zootopia 2*, where Judy Hopps and Nick Wild stumble into a twisty conspiracy involving a powerful, villainous family and a mission to clear the name of Zootopia's true visionary. We're talking everything from cleverly hidden adult jokes and questionable family loyalty to the hilarious challenges of an "opposites attract" partnership. * How the film might have been w...

E221 - Nuremberg - What Would YOU Do? 05.12.2025

All Rise! Cinema IRL is now in session. The honorable Amber and less-than-honorable Scott presiding. On today's docket: Nazis, after watching Nuremberg

E220 - Vincent Must Die - What Would YOU Do? 03.12.2025

This week, we're diving into the bizarre world of Vincent Must Die, a film where people inexplicably want to punch, stab, and slash our protagonist for no reason. Join us as we unpack the baffling phenomenon of targeted, out-of-the-blue violence and Vincent's increasingly desperate attempts to survive. We're talking about the practicality of nondescript clothing, the perils of romance when your da...

E219 - Anniversary - What Would YOU Do? 01.12.2025

This week, we're diving into Anniversary, a film that paints a chilling picture of a future America where a radical movement called "The Change" takes hold. Join us as we unpack how a seemingly well-adjusted family gets swept up in the chaos, testing loyalties and unravelling their lives. We’re talking government overreach, dangerous ideologies, and whether you’d sacrifice your family for your pri...

E218 - Regretting You - What Would YOU Do? 28.11.2025

This episode of Cinema IRL unpacks the twisty, emotional rollercoaster that is Regretting You. We’re talking devastating betrayals, secrets unearthed, and the awkward moment your daughter catches you kissing your husband's former best friend. Prepare for some spicy takes on grief, regret, and why you should probably clean out your husband’s toolbox.

E217 - Tron:Ares - What Would YOU Do? 26.11.2025

This episode of Cinema IRL takes on Tron: Ares, a film that proves AI's potential for both saving the world and, you know, blowing it up. The crew unpacks the digital-to-physical transfer, the ethics of sentient code, and whether we're destined to be enslaved by our own creations. Prepare for a deep dive into digital dangers and a philosophical debate about 3D-printed food.

E216 – The Smashing Machine - What Would YOU Do? 25.11.2025

The crew dives into the biopic of MMA legend Mark Kerr—aka the Smashing Machine—unpacking his early UFC glory, opioid spiral, and a love life that kept him on the edge of a gun. From the “punch‑machine” gag that proves you can laugh while punching a bag to the moment Dawn holds a gun to her own head, the episode balances hard‑hitting analysis with a dose of irreverent banter.

E215 - Shelby Oaks - What Would YOU Do? 24.11.2025

In this episode, we dissect the bizarre horror‑comedy “Shelby Oaks,” where a YouTuber’s missing‑sister saga turns into a full‑blown demon baby crisis. We riff on the film’s over‑the‑top paranormal pranks, the 12‑year‑long mystery, and a side‑story about a guy who “needs to keep his genitals attached.” The crew laughs (and cringes) at the absurd dialogue while pointing out the deeper, spooky underc...

E214 - Bugonia - What Would YOU Do? 23.11.2025

This week, the podcast crew dives into the bizarre world of Bugonia, where conspiracy theorists abduct a CEO convinced she's an alien. Turns out, they might be onto something, leading to a series of increasingly absurd and darkly comedic events. Was the heavy-handed music score a manipulation tactic, or just a distraction?

Listen to the Cinema IRL podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.