Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Cinema IRL

Comedy EN ↓ 288 episodes

Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy. From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life. Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an...

Author

Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

cinema-irl.donecast.com

Latest episode

Jul 10, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

E163 - I Don't Understand You - What Would YOU Do? 09.07.2025

Ciao, chaos! This week on Cinema IRL, we're diving headfirst into the dark, darkly comedic Italian nightmare that is "I Don't Understand You." Dom and Cole, a loving couple on the cusp of adoption, find their anniversary trip to Italy spiraling out of control faster than you can say "oopsie-daisy" after accidentally killing a dinner host. Get ready for a hilarious dissection of escalating bad deci...

E162 - The Phoenician Scheme - What Would YOU Do? 07.07.2025

Welcome back to Cinema IRL, where we dive deep into films and ask the important questions... like, what *is* "the gap" in international finance? This week, we’re unraveling the stylishly bizarre and utterly baffling world of *The Phoenician Scheme* (Episode 163). Picture this: a family business, corporate intrigue, and enough assassination attempts to make James Bond blush. But trust us, the offic...

E161 - Dangerous Animals - What Would YOU Do? 04.07.2025

Want to know what the most dangerous animal it? Spoiler Alert: It's humans. Y'all are the worst, as Amber and Scott discuss "Dangerous Animals".

E160 - The Life of Chuck - What Would YOU Do? 02.07.2025

Today, Amber and Scott discuss "The Life of Chuck": a delightful mindbender centered around one guy who gave 39 great years.

E159 - Bring Her Back - What Would YOU Do? 30.06.2025

Get ready for a wild ride, folks! This week on Cinema IRL, we dive deep into the unsettling world of "Bring Her Back." A brother and sister stumble upon a disturbing ritual at their new foster home, involving necromancy, body parts, and a desperate attempt to resurrect the foster mother's deceased daughter. Was it a zombie film? A vampire flick? Or something far more sinister involving dark arts?...

E158 - Karate Kid Legends - What Would YOU Do? 27.06.2025

Wax on, wax off, and pizza delivered from New York! This week on Cinema IRL, we're diving headfirst into the latest *Karate Kid* installment, "Karate Kid Legends." We dissect the plot twists (spoiler alert!), debate the characters' fighting abilities, and even uncover surprising real-life parallels. One host shares their Taekwondo tournament experience, complete with a flying sidekick gone wrong,...

E157 - Jane Austen Wrecked My Life - What Would YOU Do? 25.06.2025

Welcome back to Cinema IRL! This week, we're diving headfirst into the awkward world of French rom-coms with "Jane Austen Wrecked My Life." A struggling bookseller, a writer's retreat run by Jane Austen's distant relatives, and a whole lot of romantic confusion – what could possibly go wrong? Our hosts dissect this film's messy love triangles, questionable decisions, and the age-old debate of whet...

E156 - Final Destination Bloodlines - What Would YOU Do? 23.06.2025

Death is coming, and this time it's personal...ly gruesome! This week on Cinema IRL, we dive headfirst (sometimes literally) into "Final Destination: Bloodlines." We discuss Stephanie's family curse, inherited from a grandmother plagued by premonitions. Is Iris crazy, or is she the only one who can outsmart Death himself? We ponder the film's elaborate death traps, debate abandoning cursed familie...

E155 - Lilo & Stitch - What Would YOU Do? 20.06.2025

Aloha, Cinema IRL Ohana! This week, we're hanging ten with Disney's "Lilo & Stitch," a story about a lonely Hawaiian girl and a chaotic, destructive, yet ultimately lovable alien experiment. Join us as we unpack the film's themes of family, belonging, and "Ohana means nobody gets left behind or forgotten." We dive deep into the ethical dilemmas presented, from Nani's questionable life-saving decis...

E154 - The Ruse - What Would YOU Do? 18.06.2025

Welcome back to Cinema IRL! This week, we dive deep into "The Ruse," a thriller that throws more red herrings than a seafood market. Was it the creepy neighbor? The pervy delivery guy? Or maybe even... a ghost? Join us as we dissect the film's plot holes, questionable character choices (seriously, Dale, inviting strangers in?), and the complete lack of "terrifying supernatural occurrences" promise...

E153 - Rosario - What Would YOU Do? 16.06.2025

When a desperate mother makes a deal with a shadowy corporation to save her son, the Cinema IRL hosts dive into "Rosario," a film where the cure might be worse than the disease. They dissect the high-stakes world of black-market cures and corporate assassins, questioning if you should ever trust a company whose business model seems to be "miracles with a body count."  Also, Scott rails on bad writ...

E152 - Sinners - What Would YOU Do? 13.06.2025

This week on Cinema IRL, we're diving into a movie that's part plantation drama, part musical, and ALL vampire horror! That's right, we're tackling a film where sinners seeking a fresh start find themselves facing a bloodthirsty horde. To help us separate Hollywood fact from fiction, we're joined by a very special guest: Von Murder, a real-life, 769-year-old vampire! Von Murder sets the record str...

E151 - Hurry Up Tomorrow - What Would YOU Do? 11.06.2025

Buckle up, listeners, because this week's episode is a wild ride... or maybe just a confusing one. We bravely (or foolishly) dove into a film starring The Weeknd as, well, The Weeknd – a musician whose life takes a bizarre turn after a chance encounter. One minute he's on tour, the next he's tied to a bed in a hotel room. What follows is a chaotic blend of obsession, arson, and questionable decisi...

E150 - Watch The Skies - What Would YOU Do? 09.06.2025

This week, Amber and Scott tackle a UFO thriller that proves the truth really is out there - and it's probably more traumatic than you'd expect. When a young girl's father gets abducted by aliens and replaced with someone else, our hosts dive into the age-old question: what's worse, losing your dad to extraterrestrials or having to explain that to your therapist later? Swedish alien hunters are ap...

E149 - The Accountant 2 - What Would YOU Do? 06.06.2025

Amber and Scott return to discuss why your CPA probably isn't as exciting as Ben Affleck's autistic action hero accountant. Because apparently, the first film didn't fully explore the thrilling world of tax season meets tactical combat operations. This week they're asking the important questions: Is your accountant missing out on being a killer, and are you missing out on way more than just tax wr...

E148 - Friendship - What Would YOU Do? 04.06.2025

mber and Scott dive into the uncomfortable truth about adult friendships with a film that's basically a masterclass in social awkwardness. As they discuss, if you don't have friends by the time you're an adult, you're probably screwed - but this movie suggests that making new ones might be even worse. When suburban dad Craig's attempts to make an adult male friend spiral completely out of control,...

E147 - Fight or Flight - What Would YOU Do? 02.06.2025

Amber and Scott tackle an airplane battle royale mashup that somehow manages to cram assassins, flight attendants, and tech bros into one gloriously chaotic action-comedy. Because nothing says 'relaxing flight' quite like a plane full of killers with questionable weapon-smuggling skills and even more questionable survival instincts. Our hosts dive into the important questions: How exactly did all...

E146 - Thunderbolts* - What Would YOU Do? 30.05.2025

Amber and Scott are up for some reject superheroes after diving into Marvel's latest team of misfits who probably got kicked out of the good superhero groups for a reason. That mysterious asterisk in the title remains unexplained because, as our hosts admit, it didn't come up - but hey, at least someone had to type it. This week they're exploring what happens when you take all the B-list heroes an...

E145 - The Surfer - What Would YOU Do? 28.05.2025

Amber and Scott discuss The Surfer, where Nicholas Cage is full-on Nicholas Caging harder than ever - and yes, it's exactly what you probably think. When a man returns to his beachside hometown in Australia and gets humiliated by local surfers claiming ownership over the beach, things escalate wildly out of control in true Cage fashion. Our hosts explore what happens when childhood wounds, territo...

E144 - Warfare - What Would YOU Do? 26.05.2025

Amber and Scott take on a very real and unflinching look at modern warfare through the eyes of soldiers who lived it, because sometimes the most important stories are the ones that make us the most uncomfortable. Written and directed by Iraq War veteran Jay Mendoza and Alex Garland, this film embeds audiences with a platoon of American Navy SEALs in an Iraqi family's home during a real-time operat...

E143 - Until Dawn - What Would YOU Do? 23.05.2025

Special guest Jimmy joins Amber and Scott to tackle a horror film that asks the ultimate question: are you scared of dying, especially if you knew you'd just restart the night a little more screwed up than before? When a group finds themselves stalked by a masked killer and horrifically murdered one by one, only to wake up back at the beginning of the same evening, our hosts explore the psychologi...

E142 - The Shrouds - What Would YOU Do? 21.05.2025

Amber and Scott discover that death and technology don't mix particularly well after watching a film about a tech entrepreneur who's developed software that lets the bereaved witness their loved ones' decomposition process. Because apparently, someone thought what grief really needed was a live stream of decay with premium subscription features. Our hosts dive into this premise that had so much po...

E141 - The Wedding Banquet - What Would YOU Do? 19.05.2025

Amber and Scott navigate the complex world of chosen family, cultural identity, and accidental pregnancy in a film that combines a staged straight wedding with some very real complications. When trying to get pregnant, accidentally getting pregnant, and doing this within the context of gay couples creates one really messed up situation, our hosts explore how love, immigration, and family expectati...

E140 - The Legend of Ochi - What Would YOU Do? 16.05.2025

Amber and Scott ask the important question: what happens when you cross The Lord of the Rings with The Muppets? Okay, maybe not exactly that, but you get the picture as they dive into a fantasy adventure that involves a lot of CGI special effects and creatures known as the Ochi. When a young girl in a remote northern village embarks on the adventure of a lifetime to reunite a baby Ochi with its fa...

E139 - The Amateur - What Would YOU Do? 14.05.2025

Amber and Scott prove that nerdy guys can definitely kick some ass when needed, especially when you kill their wife and they decide to come after you. Charlie Heller is a brilliant but deeply introverted CIA decoder whose life gets turned upside down when his wife dies in a London terrorist attack, and when his supervisors refuse to take action, he takes matters into his own hands. Our hosts explo...

Listen to the Cinema IRL podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.