Spencer Elwood & Breck Sunlin

Be Afraid of the Dark

Tv EN ↓ 42 episodes

Hello and welcome to Be Afraid of the Dark! We're your hosts Spencer and Breck, and we love Supernatural so much we created an entire podcast to justify rewatching it. Join us every week as we recap episodes, talk about our favorite moments, nominate "best ofs" every episode, and so much more! Grab your journal, load up on rock salt, and hit the road with us. This is...Be Afraid of the Dark!

Author

Spencer Elwood & Breck Sunlin

Episodes

Supernatural Season Three Retrospective - BAOTD 06.07.2026 1:08:47

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about season three of Supernatural as a whole. Let’s all be sad together! Buckle up, grab your rock salt and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, Kristyna McCullough, Rachel Jokinen, Megan Kelterborn, M...

Supernatural 3x16 (“No Rest for the Wicked”) Rewatch - BAOTD 29.06.2026 33:49

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about the season finale of season three of Supernatural. Things are getting REAL. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, Kristyna McCullough, Rachel Jokinen, Megan Kelt...

Supernatural 3x14 + 3x15 (“Long-Distance Call” +“Time Is on My Side”) Rewatch - BAOTD 22.06.2026 52:50

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes fourteen and fifteen of season three of Supernatural. RIP to a real one. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, Kristyna McCullough, Rachel Jokinen, Mega...

Supernatural 3x12 + 3x13 (“Jus in Bello” + “Ghostfacers”) Rewatch - BAOTD 15.06.2026 50:39

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes twelve and thirteen of season three of Supernatural. Are you prepared to face ghosts, even when others will not? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, K...

Supernatural 3x10 + 3x11 (“Dream a Little Dream of Me” + “Mystery Spot”) Rewatch - BAOTD 08.06.2026 51:45

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes ten and eleven of season three of Supernatural. 🎶Heatttt of the moment 🎶Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, Kristyna McCullough, Rachel Jokinen, Meg...

Supernatural 3x8 + 3x9 (“A Very Supernatural Christmas” + “Malleus Maleficarum”) Rewatch - BAOTD 01.06.2026 48:52

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes eight and nine of season three of Supernatural. Keep your teeth inside your mouth, okay? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Fellow Hunters (Our Patrons): Jennifer Sharp, Chelby Black, Kristyna McCullough, Rach...

Supernatural 3x6 + 3x7 (“Red Sky at Morning” + “Fresh Blood”) Rewatch - BAOTD 25.05.2026 57:19

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes six and seven of season three of Supernatural. Keep an eye out for ghost ships, y’all. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Patreon Link: https://patreon.com/BeAfraidoftheDark?utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=j...

Supernatural 3x4 + 3x5 (“Sin City” + “Bedtime Stories”) Rewatch - BAOTD 18.05.2026 49:04

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes four and five of season three of Supernatural. An apple a day…turns you into a vengeful spirit? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedar...

Supernatural 3x2 + 3x3 (“The Kids Are Alright” + “Bad Day at Black Rock”) Rewatch - BAOTD 11.05.2026 56:14

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes two and three of season three of Supernatural. Keep an eye out for creepy kids. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Link to Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeAfraidoftheDark?utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=join...

Supernatural 3x1 (“The Magnificent Seven”) Rewatch - BAOTD 04.05.2026 43:26

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episode one of season three of Supernatural. Better stock up on some holy water. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Link to Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeAfraidoftheDark?utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=join_link&amp...

Exciting Announcement - BAOTD 29.04.2026 9:17

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! We have some very exciting news: we’re starting a Patreon! Please check it out and let us know what you think. More tiers to come! In the meantime, buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Link to Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeAfraidoftheDark?utm_medium=unknow...

Special: Taking Supernatural Personality Quizzes - BAOTD 20.04.2026 34:58

In today’s very special episode, we tide you over while we prepare season three by making Spencer take Supernatural-themed personality and trivia quizzes! Is he more of a Sam, or a Dean? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 #supernatural #supernaturalshow #supernaturaltvshow #supernaturalrewatch #supernaturalreaction #supernaturalrecap #s...

Special: Would Sam & Dean Survive? Horror Movie Edition - BAOTD 13.04.2026 39:40

In today’s very special episode, we tide you over while we prepare season three by debating what horror movies the brothers could survive! Will they be up to snuff, or will they fold under pressure? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 #supernatural #supernaturalshow #supernaturaltvshow #supernaturalrewatch #supernaturalreaction #supernat...

Supernatural Season 2 Retrospective - BAOTD 30.03.2026 1:02:22

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have an overall discussion about season two of Supernatural. It can only get worse from here! Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playlist for the SPN S...

Supernatural 2x22 (“All Hell Breaks Loose, Part 2”) Rewatch - BAOTD 23.03.2026 32:37

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episode twenty-two of season two of Supernatural. It’s the end of the beginning. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playlist fo...

Supernatural 2x20 + 2x21 (“What Is and What Should Never Be” + “All Hell Breaks Loose, Part 1”) Rewatch - BAOTD 16.03.2026 50:20

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes twenty and twenty-one of season two of Supernatural. Welcome back to Bummer Central. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotif...

Supernatural 2x18 + 2x19 (“Hollywood Babylon” + “Folsom Prison Blues”) Rewatch - BAOTD 09.03.2026 58:09

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes eighteen and nineteen of season two of Supernatural. What’s better than movie magic? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotif...

Supernatural 2x16 + 2x17 (“Roadkill” + “Heart”) Rewatch - BAOTD 02.03.2026 46:03

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes sixteen and seventeen of season two of Supernatural. Get ready to be bummed out! Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify pl...

Supernatural 2x14 + 2x15 (“Born Under A Bad Sign” + “Tall Tales”) Rewatch - BAOTD 23.02.2026 47:46

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes fourteen and fifteen of season two of Supernatural. A diva returns, and a diva is born. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spo...

Supernatural 2x12 + 2x13 (“Nightshifter” + “Houses of the Holy”) Rewatch - BAOTD 16.02.2026 51:46

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes twelve and thirteen of season two of Supernatural. We are so screwed. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playlist for...

Supernatural 2x10 + 2x11 (“Hunted” + “Playthings”) Rewatch - BAOTD 09.02.2026 53:33

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes ten and eleven of season two of Supernatural. Always vet where you buy your antiques. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spoti...

Supernatural 2x8 + 2x9 (“Crossroad Blues” + “Croatoan”) Rewatch - BAOTD 02.02.2026 51:03

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes eight and nine of season two of Supernatural. Be careful who you make deals with, ya hear? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327...

Supernatural 2x6 + 2x7 (“No Exit” + “The Usual Suspects”) Rewatch - BAOTD 26.01.2026 53:10

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes six and seven of season two of Supernatural. Who’s up for pea soup? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playlist for th...

Supernatural 2x4 + 2x5 (“Children Shouldn’t Play With Dead Things” + “Simon Said”) Rewatch - BAOTD 19.01.2026 58:27

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes four and five of season two of Supernatural. Simon Says can be a deadly game. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playl...

Supernatural 2x2 + 2x3 (“Everybody Loves a Clown” + “Bloodlust”) Rewatch - BAOTD 12.01.2026 54:37

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes two and three of season two of Supernatural. Humans might be scarier than evil clowns. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spot...