Spencer Elwood & Breck Sunlin

Be Afraid of the Dark

Tv EN ↓ 42 episodes

Hello and welcome to Be Afraid of the Dark! We're your hosts Spencer and Breck, and we love Supernatural so much we created an entire podcast to justify rewatching it. Join us every week as we recap episodes, talk about our favorite moments, nominate "best ofs" every episode, and so much more! Grab your journal, load up on rock salt, and hit the road with us. This is...Be Afraid of the Dark!

Author

Spencer Elwood & Breck Sunlin

Episodes

Supernatural 2x1 (“In My Time of Dying”) Rewatch - BAOTD 05.01.2026 34:51

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episode one of season one of Supernatural. Remember, don’t fear the reaper. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedark327 TikTok: @beafraidofthedark327 Spotify playlist for the...

Special: House of Wax (2005) Discussion - BAOTD 22.12.2025 29:10

In today’s very special episode, we tide you over while we prepare season two by discussing the film House of Wax (2005)! This is the movie Jared filmed right before season one aired, so we compare and contrast his performances and soak up all the mid00’s horror cheese. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 #supernatural #supernaturalshow...

Special: Supernatural Original Pilot Script - BAOTD 08.12.2025 35:57

In today’s very special episode, we tide you over while we prepare season two by reading and discussing the original script for the Supernatural pilot! We laugh, we roll our eyes, we question everything. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 #supernatural #supernaturalshow #supernaturaltvshow #supernaturalrewatch #supernaturalreaction #su...

Supernatural Season One Retrospective - BAOTD 24.11.2025 52:07

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about season one as a whole of Supernatural. We also rank our favorite episodes of the season, and duke it out in our kill bracket! Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Spotify playlist for the SPN S1 soundtrack: https://open....

Supernatural 1x22 (“Devil’s Trap”) Rewatch - BAOTD 17.11.2025 40:05

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episode twenty-two of season one of Supernatural. Keep your friends close, and your demonically-possessed fathers closer. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: ...

Supernatural 1x20 + 1x21 (“Dead Man’s Blood” + “Salvation”) Rewatch - BAOTD 10.11.2025 51:35

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes twenty and twenty-one of season one of Supernatural. Please make sure you take pain meds for your psychic vision-induced headaches. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidoft...

Supernatural 1x18 + 1x19 (“Something Wicked” + “Provenance”) Rewatch - BAOTD 03.11.2025 48:21

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes eighteen and nineteen of season one of Supernatural. Remember, an apple a day keeps the evil witch doctor at bay. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: ...

Supernatural 1x16 + 1x17 (“Shadow” + “Hell House”) Rewatch - BAOTD 27.10.2025 47:42

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes sixteen and seventeen of season one of Supernatural. Keep your demons on a tight leash, y’all. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthedark...

Supernatural 1x14 + 1x15 (“Nightmare” + “The Benders”) Rewatch - BAOTD 20.10.2025 50:35

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes fourteen and fifteen of season one of Supernatural. Remember, people are the real monsters. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthedarkpod...

Supernatural 1x12 + 1x13 (“Faith” + “Route 666”) Rewatch - BAOTD 13.10.2025 48:01

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes twelve and thirteen of season one of Supernatural. Keep a close eye out for creepy guys in suits and racist ghost trucks. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod...

Supernatural 1x10 + 1x11 (“Asylum” + “Scarecrow”) Rewatch - BAOTD 06.10.2025 48:29

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes ten and eleven of season one of Supernatural. Maybe avoid taking long walks in creepy orchards, yeah? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidof...

Supernatural 1x8 + 1x9 (“Bugs” + “Home”) Rewatch - BAOTD 29.09.2025 44:59

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes eight and nine of season one of Supernatural. This is your friendly reminder to turn the garbage disposal OFF before working on your sink. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beaf...

Supernatural 1x6 + 1x7 (“Skin” + “Hook Man”) Rewatch - BAOTD 22.09.2025 39:37

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes six and seven of season one of Supernatural. It’s getting yucky this week, y’all. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthedarkpod Spotify p...

Supernatural 1x4 + 1x5 ( “Phantom Traveler” + “Bloody Mary”) Rewatch - BAOTD 15.09.2025 45:18

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes four and five of season one of Supernatural. Ghost and demons and plane crashes, oh my! Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthedarkpod Spo...

Supernatural 1x2 + 1x3 (“Wendigo” + “Dead in the Water”) Rewatch - BAOTD 08.09.2025 40:11

Welcome back to your favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about episodes two and three of season one of Supernatural. What’s scarier, ghost children or regular children? Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthed...

Supernatural 1x1 (“Pilot”) Rewatch - BAOTD 01.09.2025 45:05

Welcome to our Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! This week we have a discussion about the pilot episode of Supernatural, and dig deep into why this is still one of the best pilots in TV history. Follow along as we hit the road with Sam and Dean! Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafrai...

Supernatural Rewatch Podcast - Introducing Be Afraid of the Dark 29.08.2025 5:32

Welcome to your new favorite Supernatural rewatch podcast, Be Afraid of the Dark! Today we explain what our show will be like and let you know what episodes to watch. Buckle up, grab your rock salt, and remember…you know what’s out there. Be afraid of the dark 👻 Find us on our socials 💀 IG: @beafraidofthedarkpod TikTok: @beafraidofthedarkpod #supernatural #supernaturalshow #supernaturaltvshow #...