Eye for an Eye

As Lisa and Matt prep for season two, we wanted to bring you guys a taste of our bonus series exclusive to our Patrons. Eye for an Eye is all about whether or not the punishment fits the crime. However, there are many cases that leave us just as baffled and have theories we could spend hours discussing that are still unsolved or the person is no longer around to hold accountable for the classic "E...

Happy Halloween to our Eye for an Eye family!  Here is a special mash up of all things creepy and spooky from our fellow podcasters and listeners just for all of you! Special thanks to: Samii, Host of The Hidden Staircase Podcast Heather, Host of Nature vs Narcissism and Pending Status Podcast Scott, Host of Pending Status Podcast Carla, Go Postal Podcast Karen, STAT! Tales Podcast Darren, True Cr...

If you are a horror/thriller movie buff like us, you probably already know that there are more "misses" than "hits" out there when it comes to our beloved genre. You probably spend more time looking for a half decent horror flick than you do actually watching them. Well horror movie junkies, get ready to FEAR A LITTLE MORE (see what I did there? Fear no more? But we wanna fear a little more? ok by...

Join Lisa, Matt, and Special Guest John Ryan as they wrap up season one and unravel the deepest rooted scandal in the history of the NCAA. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want so check it out below! https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod...

Imagine being locked in a coffin-like box for 23 hours a day for seven years. This nightmare was Colleen Stans reality. As unfathomable as it is, that wasn't the part of this case that had people talking the most.... Join Lisa and Matt as they go over Colleen Stans kidnapping, the idea of Stockholm's Syndrome, the power of brain washing and ultimately, whether or not Colleen's captors punishment f...

By day Gilberto Valle was a family man, a loving dad and husband, and a devoted member of the NYPD- however, when night time rolled around and his family was fast asleep in the next room- Gilberto would log into his computer and become something much more nefarious. He would become "Girlmeathunter" Join Lisa and Matt as they recount the secret live of Gilberto Valle, also known as the Cannibal Cop...

Do you believe in ghosts? Do you believe if you follow the proper channels you can contact your deceased loved ones? Sisters Annie and Jessica Andrews had just lost their mother to cancer and were willing to do whatever it took to contact her just one more time. They lit some candles and began a seance to contact their mother. They did not realize this would be the beginning of something much more...

Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day. While an Eye for an Eye covers the more serious cases, we wanted to bring you a new mini series, the grand baby-- if you will, of the most absurd, funny, confusing cases we could grasp our crime obsessed phalanges on. We promise by the end of every minisode of WTH3, you too,...

With a last meal of steak, lobster tail, apple pie, vanilla ice cream and 7-Up, followed by a 48-hour fast while watching The Lord of the Rings Trilogy, Ronnie Lee Gardner seemingly was at peace with his fate. He was to die by firing squad- a method that had last been used 14 years prior. Join Lisa and Matt as they recount the troubled life and controversal death of Ronnie Lee Gardner and whether...

If you are a horror/thriller movie buff like us, you probably already know that there are more "misses" than "hits" out there when it comes to our beloved genre. You probably spend more time looking for a half decent horror flick than you do actually watching them. Well horror movie junkies, get ready to FEAR A LITTLE MORE (see what I did there? Fear no more? But we wanna fear a little more? ok by...

On the afternoon of August 28, 2003, a local pizza delivery man, Brian Wells, set out to deliver two large pizzas. What started as a typical delivery, ended up becoming one of the most shocking criminal cases that the town of Erie PA has ever seen. Join Lisa, Matt and their special guest host Jeff, as they break down truly one of the most bizarre criminal cases to date. When this case broke, inves...

Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day. While an Eye for an Eye covers the more serious cases, we wanted to bring you a new mini series, the grand baby-- if you will, of the most absurd, funny, confusing cases we could grasp our crime obsessed phalanges on. We promise by the end of every minisode of WTH3, you too,...

On the afternoon of August 28, 2003, a local pizza delivery man, Brian Wells, set out to deliver two large pizzas. What started as a typical delivery, ended up becoming one of the most shocking criminal cases that the town of Erie PA has ever seen. Join Lisa, Matt and their special guest host Jeff, as they break down truly one of the most bizarre criminal cases to date. When this case broke, inves...

Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day. While an Eye for an Eye covers the more serious cases, we wanted to bring you a new mini series, the grand baby-- if you will, of the most absurd, funny, confusing cases we could grasp our crime obsessed phalanges on. We promise by the end of every minisode of WTH3, you too,...

When a beloved flight attendant disappears without a trace, family and friends begin to think the worst. Why would a woman who adores her kids and is at the top of her professional career up and leave with out letting her loved ones know? One question remained, what happened to Helle Crafts? Join Lisa and Matt as they go through what lead up to Helle Crafts disappearance and how detectives, Helle'...

Setting and breaking all kind of athletic records, Aaron Hernandez was known as a beast on the football field. Unfortunately, this term of endearment would come to have a very different meaning for Aaron. Was Aaron Hernandez a troubled man who was a product of his circumstances or could numerous head injuries be solely to blame? Join Lisa and Matt as they recount the tragic rise and fall of Aaron...

If you are a horror/thriller movie buff like us, you probably already know that there are more "misses" than "hits" out there when it comes to our beloved genre. You probably spend more time looking for a half decent horror flick than you do actually watching them. Well horror movie junkies, get ready to FEAR A LITTLE MORE (see what I did there? Fear no more? But we wanna fear a little more? ok by...

If you are a horror/thriller movie buff like us, you probably already know that there are more "misses" than "hits" out there when it comes to our beloved genre. You probably spend more time looking for a half decent horror flick than you do actually watching them. Well horror movie junkies, get ready to FEAR A LITTLE MORE (see what I did there? Fear no more? But we wanna fear a little more? ok by...

When gasoline meets a lit match, fire is imminent. That’s the dynamic Erika and BJ Sifrit had. The question wasn't whether or not these two committed a heinous crime, but more so, which one pulled the trigger? Join Lisa and Matt as they unpack all sides of the story t0 unveil whether or not Erika and BJ's punishments fit their crime and help decipher who was the match and who was the gasoline? Als...

Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day. While an Eye for an Eye covers the more serious cases, we wanted to bring you a new mini series, the grand baby-- if you will, of the most absurd, funny, confusing cases we could grasp our crime obsessed phalanges on. We promise by the end of every minisode of WTH3, you too,...

Should a child who commits a heinous crime spend the rest of their life in jail? Should the age of the convicted play a part in sentencing? Join Lisa and host of Streamin n Screamin Kara as they peel back the layers regarding the life and crime of Eric Smith and the implications of committing a crime at a young age. Lisa and Kara also let you know how a banana helped point investigators right to E...

The internet is a bitter-sweet place. There is one side, the sweet side, that is full of sage advice, yummy recipes, pictures of puppies, and endless knowledge at the click of a button. The bitter side, however, is where internet trolls flourish. Where you can hide behind a fake name and picture and endlessly harass complete strangers. Where you can openly idolize the worst members of society. Whe...

When twelve year old Tia Sharp was reported missing by her grandma, suspicions regarding her disappearance quickly arose. Over eighty police officers were assigned to the search, and 800 hours of CCTV footage were collected to find the missing girl. Unfortunately, on August 10th everyones worst fear was realized- Tia had been murdered. Join Lisa, Matt, and our special guest and dear friend to the...

If you are a horror/thriller movie buff like us, you probably already know that there are more "misses" than "hits" out there when it comes to our beloved genre. You probably spend more time looking for a half decent horror flick than you do actually watching them. Well horror movie junkies, get ready to FEAR A LITTLE MORE (see what I did there? Fear no more? But we wanna fear a little more? ok by...

Who's to blame for the deaths of so many? Is it the hospitals who let Charles Cullen slip through the cracks for so many years? Or is Charles Cullen solely to blame? Can we prosecute someone for hundreds of crimes if they only admitted to some? How do families find solace in the healthcare system after seeing firsthand how a deranged man completely slipped through the cracks? Charles Cullen was no...