Everything Scary

Send us Fan Mail June and Jennifer Gibbons were born on April 11th of 1963.  Even as infants the two had a truly unique bons, and even insisted on being nursed together.  As they grew into toddlers, they made a pact that they would only even speak to each other, and to eliminate the chance of someone over hearing them and understanding, they even had their own language that they invented and only...

Send us Fan Mail So, heres the deal, I know that every Tom, Dick and Harry is doing some version of the Murdaugh case...... But, if you listen to the episode, you will know why I ended up covering this case! and it is still a wild one, it will not disappoint! let us know your thoughts at;  Everythingscary@everythingscarypod.com Patreon.com/everythingscarypod571 Support the show If you’re intereste...

Send us Fan Mail This case hurts my heart in a big way.    Christina Grimmie, started off with her YouTube channel, where she gained millions of followers and dedicated fans that were known as ‘Team Grimmie’   After getting a 4 chair turn around while auditioning for The Voice, Christina’s career took off.  Until one night, an obsessed fan decided that if he couldn’t have her, no one could.    Thi...

Send us Fan Mail Phoebe Handsjuk, was young and beautiful, she did struggle a bit with substance abuse. But she had a great support team, a family who adored her. But sadly on December 2nd of 2010, she….allegedly, either, took her own life accidentally, while consuming alcohol and sleeping pills. or she chose to take her own life, by.....going down a garbage chute!!  There is so much more to this...

Send us Fan Mail In 2011, a lot of people were still trying to crawl out of the debt that was brought on by the recession of 2007.  Richard Beasley saw this as an opportunity.  He would offer, single men, what some might consider the opportunity of a lifetime! they would be offered a free place to live, and would make $300 a week, and all they would have to do is help out around the farm, just com...

Send us Fan Mail Well, this is the 1st episode that we had to re-record because of saying things that did not age well.   This is the case of the amazing Denise Amber Lee, a 21 year old mother of two, who was taken right out of her home in the middle of the day.  Denise, was even able to steal the cell phone of her abductor for over 7 minutes….  As well as Denise’s brave effort, 3 more, separate c...

Send us Fan Mail HAPPY VALENTINES 💘  In late November of 2016,  a young mother of two, Sherri Papini went missing. After she failed to retrieve her kids from daycare, her husband really started to panic. And his panic only elevated, when he found his wife’s phone along a dirt road, with the couples wedding song ; Everything by Michael Buble playing on repeat.  The search was on, but after 22 days...

Send us Fan Mail Ivan Milat, is often referred to, as Australia’s worst serial killer, or the backpack killer.  Ivan was one of 14 children in his family, 10 boys and 4 girls.  The authorities would refer to the Milat boys as ‘feral’. This guy is one of the worst, a dark cloud over a beautiful country.     I have to apologize to any Australian listeners. I do attempt to do the accent,  and, things...

Send us Fan Mail On June 25th, 2007, on Monday night raw in Corpus Christi Texas. The show opens to Vince McMahon standing in an empty stadium, alone in the ring. He explains that in place of the previously planned story line, they would instead be paying tribute to WWE superstar Chris Benoit and his wife Nancy and 7 year old son Daniel. It wasn't until 26 hours later that the truth behind th...

Send us Fan Mail You guys!!!!     This episode was actually the inspiration for the 2016 Zack Galafanakis movie, Masterminds.  Now, this movie had a 34% on Rotten Tomatoes.   BUT I think that may be, because of how silly the movie was,  which is ironic, because it’s kind of scary how close the true story is to the ridiculous movie.   There is an element of true crime.. obviously.   But, it is not...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode we sit through the painful interrogation of Ryan Waller.  On the evening of Christmas Day in 2006, Don Waller went to check on his 18 year old son, Ryan when he  no-showed for Christmas dinner. After failing to get eyes on Ryan, Don called for a welfare check.  When Ryan eventually answered the back door that led to the main bedroom, he looked as if he had been bad...

Send us Fan Mail This was one of the hardest stories I have told.   After, 12 year old Leslie and 16 year old Brookes Douglass were shot and left for dead in their own home, and having lost their beloved parents in the same incident. Their story was only just beginning. These two incredible individuals went on to really make a change in the world.  Their lives following the shooting plays out like...

Send us Fan Mail In this weeks episode, we discuss the murder of the beautiful Dorothy Stratten, at the hands of her jealous husband, Paul Snider.  Dorothy was a rising star. As Paul said she was ‘on a rocket ship to the moon’  We also touch on the invention of The Chippendales dancers , and all the string of crimes that came from that.   All because of one man.  Support the show If you’re interes...

Send us Fan Mail TRIGGER WARNING (sexual assault, murder)  This is a very bad man. Scotland is undeniably one of the most beautiful countries on the planet, sadly we all have some people from where we live that we are not willing to claim, and Peter Tobin is that person for Scotland.  His rein of terror lasted for over a decade. And it very literally plays out like a horror story.  This is the cas...

Send us Fan Mail In 1924 construction started on The Cecil hotel. In downtown LA. It was meant for business men and elite socialites  looking for a cheap place to stay for a night. With a lobby full of alabaster statues, marble floors, a stained glass window in ceiling, the glamour however stopped there.  The rooms left a lot to be desired, and when the Great Depression hit in 1929 and The Cecil t...

Send us Fan Mail In September of 2021, the world watched and prayed for the safe return of Gabrielle ‘Gabby’ Petito.  Gabby and her boyfriend Brian, decided to set off on a trip to see the country, while living out of a Ford Transit van that Gabby had saved up for, and turned into a small living area. But when Brian returned home to Florida, with Gabby’s van and debit card and no Gabby, it didn’t...

Send us Fan Mail This is the story of Herbert Webster Mudgett.   You probably know of him as H.H Holmes. One of the most prolific serial killers of all time. Obsessed with death, but also a passion to scam other people and companies out of money proved to be a very deadly combination.   This, along side with his vision and ability to create useful gadgets, led to what we have all heard of today as...

Send us Fan Mail This is the case of Laci and Scott Peterson (and baby Conner’s story too)  On Christmas Eve of 2002, Laci Peterson, who was in her 8th month of pregnancy went missing.    It was discovered, that her husband, Scott Peterson had been cheating on his beautiful wife. Not only was he cheating but he had told his girlfriend that he had recently “lost” his wife, all before she had even g...

Send us Fan Mail The story of the Ken and Barbie Killers.. More like the Dollartree version of Ken and Barbie.  This is the case that turned Lynn into the true crime fanatic that she is today.  Most Canadians should know this case. If not please prepare yourself.  Paul Bernardo  And Karla Holmolka….  These two were monsters. They sought out innocence, and felt entitled to take it.  TRIGGER WARNING...

Send us Fan Mail Who doesn’t love a bright beautiful helium filled balloon? And what is better than one balloon? How about 2 million colourful, helium filled balloons! In September of 1986, Cleveland was a city that was struggling.  They had the highest unemployment rate in the country, by a landslide. So, how do you get back on the map? Release 2,000,000 balloons!!  What could possibly go wrong?!...

Send us Fan Mail In 1986 two sisters tried having a seance, in hopes that they could hear from their beloved mother, whom they had just recently lost.  What followed was weeks worth of bangs from within the walls and terrifying messages being written on the walls, was this a spirit? A demon? Human…..? And sadly, that is only the tip of the iceberg with this story.  TRIGGER WARNING; this one contai...

Send us Fan Mail Brian Draper and Torrey Adamcik were obsessed with horror movies. They made the  decision to take that obsession and turn it into reality by targeting a small town girl who considered them her friends. Please rate and review on whichever podcast platform you listen from and join us on Instagram @everythingscarypod. Get in touch at everythingscarypodcast@gmail.com  Support the show...

Send us Fan Mail Dolly, Dolly ,Dolly. This is the wild tale of Dolly Oesterreich, a woman who could not be satisfied.   While she lived in the home with her husband Fred, Dolly moved her new flame into the attic of their home unbeknownst to Fred.  But when Fred did finally find out it was already too late.. Support the show If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates,  an...

Send us Fan Mail In an event that plays out like a movie, 3 young men, hijack a school bus with 26 students, ranging in age from 6-14. The kidnappers literally buried the kids alive. Tune in to find out what happens in this wild tale. Support the show If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates,  an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our re...

Send us Fan Mail In the 1980’s a diabolical serial killer was tormenting the state of California, seemingly getting worse every time he moved within the state. But decades later,  one true crime enthusiast, may have had the heart and the desire to pull it all together and solve this mystery, but would she be able to get him, before he got her? Support the show If you’re interested in receiving bon...