Most Wanted

This week Lauren talks about the wrongful conviction of Termaine Hicks. Termaine Hicks served 19 years in jail before he was able to prove his innocence. He was convicted of Rape, Aggravated Assault, Possession of an Instrument of Crime, and Terrorist Threats. He was sentenced to 12.5 to 25 years. Termaine Hicks was released and exonerated in 2020. Sources:  Innocence Project: Termaine Hicks The N...

This week Lauren talks about the wrongful conviction of Johnny Tall. Bear. Johnny Tall Bear served 26 years in jail before he was able to prove his innocence. He was convicted of First Degree Murder. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Johnny Tall Bear was released and exonerated in 2018. Sources:  Innocence Project: Johnny Tall Bear The National Registration of E...

This week Hannah and Lauren talk about Amy Anderton and her relationship with Logan Storm. Sources: Who The Bleep Did I Marry? Weathering The Storm Department of Justice: Oregon teacher who twice fled US sentenced in child pornography case Department of Justice: Former Teacher, Logan Storm, Sentenced to Prison for Possessing Child Pornography and Failing to Appear in Court The Oregonian: Still cla...

This week Sandy and Lauren discuss the crime(s) of Shaynna Sims. Sources:  Who The Bleep Did I Marry?: The Halloween Bride S8 E6 AP News: Oklahoma woman formally sentenced in corpse-slashing case Tulsa News: Woman found guilty of mutilating corpse during 2015 funeral home viewing by Jessica Remer Vice: The Strange Case of the Oklahoma Woman Who Dismembered a Corpse at a Funeral by Simon Davis

This week Sarah and Lauren discuss Mary Kay Letourneau; the teacher who married her former student. A case that received national attention. Sources:  Crime Library: Mary Kay Letourneau Biography.com: Mary Kay Letourneau and Vili Fualaau: A Timeline of Their Forbidden Relationship By Paulette Cohn Biography.com: Mary Kay Letourneau People Magazine: Mary Kay Letourneau and Vili Fualaau: Revisiting...

This week Sarah and Lauren discuss the murder of Doreen Erbert committed by the big bad wolf. Sources:  Snapped: S26 E9 Medium: A Deadly Grudge: The Horrific Halloween Night Murder of Doreen Erbert by Tim Reynolds Oxygen: Man In Wolf Mask Hacks Pregnant Ex-Wife To Death With Machete On Halloween Night by Benjamin H. Smith UPI: Girl recounts grisly Halloween murders by Michael Molinski UPI: Hallowe...

This week Lauren and Taylor discuss the many disappearances of Treva Throneberry. The many identities of Treva Throneberry: Briana Stewart in Oregon, Washington state, and Daphne, Alabama Stephanie Danielle Lewis in Altoona, Pennsylvania Emily Kara Williams in Texas Keili T. Throneberry Smitt Cara Leanna David in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho Keili Smitt, Stephanie Williams in Pennsylvania Emily Kara Willi...

This week Lauren talks about the wrongful conviction of Rosa Jimenez. Rosa Jimenez served 17 years in jail before she was able to prove her innocence. She was convicted of Injury to Child and Felony Murder. She was sentenced to 99 years for injury to child plus 75 years for felony murder. Rosa Jimenez was released in 2021 and exonerated in 2023. Sources:  Innocence Project: Rosa Jimenez Innocence...

Worriers! I'm devastated! This is the first time in three years I've lost audio mid-recording. I'll be back with a new episode next week! This week Amanda and Lauren discuss Tiana Notice  who was stabbed to death on Valentine’s Day, 2009.  Sources:   Deseret News: Connecticut man gets 60 years for killing ex-girlfriend by Associated Press The Tiana Angelique Notice Foundation AP News: Slain woman’...

This week Megan and Lauren discuss the horrible crimes of Erika and Benjamin Sifrit.  Sources:  Snapped: Killer Couples S11 E2 Murderpedia: Erika Elaine Sifrit This Is Monsters: BJ & Erika Sifrit: The Thrill Kill Couple Wikipedia

This week Amy and Taylor join Lauren to discuss the Wichita Massacre of 2000.  Sources:  Crime Library: The Wichita Horror by Denise Noe AP News: Judge denies new sentencing hearing for 2 brothers awaiting execution for ‘Wichita massacre’ by Heather Hollingsworth and Jim Salter The Wichita Eagle: Judge denies Carr brothers’ request for new sentence in death penalty murder case By Chance Swaim Wiki...

This week Lauren and Megan discuss the disappearance and murder of Annie Le. Sources: Crime Library: Annie Le: The Yale Lab Murder by Kristal Hawkins CBS News: Annie Le Case: Grisly Yale Murder "Freaks" Students by Edecio Martinez The New York Times: A Promising Life, Ended In A Basement by James Barron New Haven Independent: Cops Arrest Lab Tech In Annie Le Murder by Paul Bass, Melissa Bailey and...

This week Lauren is joined by Amy and Taylor and they discuss the horrible murder of 9-year old Elizabeth Olten. Sources:  ABC News: Alyssa Bustamante, 15, Pleads Not Guilty in 9-Year-Old's Stabbing NBC News: Police: Girl, 15, dug grave anticipating killing The Guardian: Missouri teenager handed life sentence for killing nine-year-old Murderpedia: Alyssa Dailen Bustamante Let’s Go To Court: Patreo...

With everything happening in the United States right now, Lauren couldn't bring herself to get a new episode out that felt like quality material, so welcome to another rebroadcasted episode! I seriously hope this is the last one! This week Lauren and Amanda discuss a local case! A local Chaska, Minnesota man committed the biggest betrayal of his life. Sources: State of Minnesota v. Everson St. Pau...

Hi Worries! I am here giving you a bonus episode due to a death in the family. Enjoy Amanda telling us about Torts!  Sources: Amanda's Tort's Textbook Savannah Cats for sale nearby Iwanna Savannah the #1 Savannah cat breeder in the USA offering Savanah kittens for sale

Welcome to part 2! This week Lauren and Amanda talk about how the six suspects become known as the Beatrice Six and how their story ends. We also find out who actually killed Helen Wilson. You don't want to miss this conclusion! Sources:  HBO Max: Mind Over Murder Death Penalty Information Center: Nebraska Exonerees Awarded $28 Million, Prosecutor Says Case Made Him Oppose Death Penalty 10/11 News...

We are starting the year off with Lauren talking about a case that she has not stopped thinking about since 2021.We have a familiar person back recording with Lauren this week and next week! This week Lauren and Amanda discuss the murder of Helen Wilson, a 68-year old widow who was brutally murdered in 1985. This case will have you question so many different things and the truth will shock you! So...

Happy New Year! We are starting the year off with a solo episode! Lauren decided to dive a little deeper into a case that she hasn't stopped thinking about since she heard about it in 2023. Did Robert Roberson kill his daughter Nikki Curtis? Or was it an accident? Social media: Tiktok: laurenlikesshttyfoodInstagram: laurenlikesshittyfood Sources: Innocence Project: What to Know About Robert Robers...

This week Lauren and Amanda discuss an infamous heist planned out by masterminds. You can watch Super Heists on E! and SYFY  Sources: Super Heists Season 1 Episode 3: A Van Full of Dollars  Blog Prep Scholar: The True Story of David Ghannt and the Loomis Fargo Heist posted by Hayley Milliman All That’s Interesting: Inside David Ghantt’s Infamous Loomis Fargo Heist In October 1997 by Wyatt Redd The...

This week Sarah and Lauren discuss horrible manipulation and parental alienation. Sources:  48 Hours: Karrie’s Choice Season 32 Episode 21 The Star Gazette: Karrie Neurauter, manipulated into helping kill mother, released from prison by Jeff Smith CBS News: "I had to choose": Did a father brainwash his daughter to help plan her mother's murder? by Erin Moriarty NBC New York: New Jersey Man Gets Li...

This week Sarah and Lauren discuss the two people betrayed by the same woman. Sources:  Crime Library: Marriage, Money and Murder: Steven and Celeste Beard by David Krajicek All That’s Interesting: The Chilling Story Of Celeste Beard, The Texas Woman Who Orchestrated The Murder Of Her Millionaire Husband by Rivy Lyon Snapped: Behind Bars: Celeste Johnson Beard Wikipedia

This week Amy and Taylor join Lauren to discuss the death of Lisa Cutler. Could it have been an accident, a suicide or a murder? Sources: Oxygen: Accident, Suicide, or Murder: Dead in the Water Forensic Tales: Lisa and Chad Cutler NBC News: Drowning is one of the hardest homicides to prove. These investigators want to change that by Cara Tabachnick Herald Review: Cutler Death No Accident, Experts...

This week Amanda and Lauren covered the rise and fall of the crypto king, Gerald Cotten. Sources: CBC: “Quadriga CEO’s widow speaks out over his death and the missing crypto millions” by Cassie Williams with additional reporting by Andrew Chang CBC: “Crypto exchange Quadriga was a fraud and founder was running a Ponzi scheme, OSC report finds” by Tara Deschamps Coindesk: “Gerald Cotten” by Nikhile...

This week Chelsea and Lauren discuss a murder in Alaska. Sources:  Dateline: A Walk In The Rain Season 31 Episode 5 The Nome Nugget: Owens’ murder conviction stands by Sandra L. Medearis Oxygen: Investigation Into Alaskan Teen's Murder Reveals Shocking Killer: "Evil Comes in Different Forms" by Jill Sederstrom Oxygen: 'I Believe He Was Gonna Kill Again': Alaska Cop Murders Native Girl, Then Stages...

This week Lauren and Josh discuss the disappearance and murder of Steven Williams. Sources:  Oxygen: Snapped Season 25 Episode 5 USA Today: Husband killed in murder plot begged wife, police say by Justin L. Mack Daily Journal: Final suspect in murder sentenced by Jacob Tellers Twisted Love: The Murder of Steven Williams by Gina Glob IndyStar: Husband killed in murder plot begged wife, police say b...