Deeply Unsettling

Send a text Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text This is the terrifying and heartbreaking survival story of Jessyca Mullenberg. She was introduced to trauma at a young age and was held captive for 104 days by a man who everyone swore was an asset to their community.  Jessyca was finally rescued because a restaurant manager recognized the man who was holding Jessyca captive from Americas Most Wanted. This is a rough one.  Be sure to f...

Send a text Do you ever find yourself saying,”Well if anyone could do it,it’s her. “ about a friend or family member who is mentally and physically prepared to take on a task that no one else could. Well it seems as though Juliane was the only one who could survive what she went through. She fell two miles from an airplane while strapped to her seat only to find herself in the middle of the jungle...

Send a text Have you ever considered stealing a plane?  Maybe not. Colton however attracted a fan base while getting the clever nickname of the Barefoot Bandit mainly for leaving chalk footprints at the crime scenes but also once wrote C-ya! At no point did I know where this case was going to go next.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases...

Send a text After the titanic we thought we had learned our lesson. Unfortunately the Eastland Tragedy showed us just how unprepared we were. One of the deadliest days in the history of Chicago that is rarely spoken about, but is the day that 22 entire families were lost among hundreds of others.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we ar...

Send a text How far would a mother be willing to go to protect her family from harm? How do you protect your loved ones from something you can't see? This was the turmoil that surrounded Doris Bitter. Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us...

Send a text Hey Creeps!!! We are back! This week Erin talks about the mystery surrounding Michael Rockefeller.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, it helps us out! Wanna send us an email? send it to: deeplyunsettling@gmail.com !

Send a text We love a good recovery story and when Timothy Treadwell wanted to work on sobriety he took the advice of one of his sponsors to visit the world and see the bears in Alaska. Timothy took that small bit of advice and made it his life goal, to be one with the bears. Unfortunately this story does not have a happy ending.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pict...

Send a text It summer time and Erin is surfing and Rachael is at the beach. So let's talk about a case that will remind us why we hate ocean with a burning passion. This is the worst case scenario for a scuba diver and while it was a terrible accident, there is people who believe that this wasn't an accident at all. This week we are talking about Tom and Eileen Lonergan and their trip to...

Send a text This week Erin ties up the Osage Murders and you won’t expect how this ends. We also talked about Erin’s democracy book club pick and her husbands kindergarten picture.  Make sure you follow us on instagram to see everything we are talking about! Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate an...

Send a text Welcome to our first two parter!! This week Erin begins to tell us about the Osage Indian Murders of Oklahoma. This one was wild and truly heartbreaking. Be sure to listen next week to figure out the rest! Follow us on instagram at deeply unsettling to see all the things we are talking about! And be sure to rate and review our podcast! Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettl...

Send a text A video surfaced a few years ago that looked so disturbing it had to be fake, but it wasn't. The woman suffering in that video was Marilyn Stanley, a victim of domestic abuse, disoriented and looking for help. This week we dove in the Zombie Woman of Seattle and a million other tangents. We also started our mini-segment of our own creepy bookclub. Be sure to follow us on instagram...

Send a text Welcome to the wormhole of Rachael’s mind. This week we talked about the bubonic Plague and how it changed the world we know today. Let us know how you feel about this episode, it’s a little different than our normal vibe.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettling. We post pictures every week of the cases we are talking about. Also be sure to rate and review our podcast, i...

Send a text This case hits too close for everyone here is the United States but it still needs to be heard. Amy Bishop was fighting to get tenure approved at her place of employment and had been repeatedly denied. The next steps she took were absolutely unthinkable.  Be sure to follow us on instagram so you can see this monster and all the other things we talk about.  Be sure to follow us on insta...

Send a text Do you believe in aliens? This week we talk about the Hill Abduction, the ones who seem to start it all. Betty and Barney Hill weren't able to recount their abduction experience until they were under hypnotherapy and the details revealed are unsettling. Be sure to follow us on instagram @deeply.unsettling so you can see what we talk about! Information for this episode came from al...

Send a text When seasoned fisherman Salvador Alvarenga set out to fish in his boat like he had done countless times before, he never could've imagined how quickly the sea could turn on him. Just in time for boating season here on the Jersey Shore, Erin reminds us how unforgiving the ocean can be. If you like us be sure to rate and review, and follow us on instagram so you can see what we are...

Send a text Let's get creepy shall we? If you have small humans with dolls, this will be even more unsettling for you. This week we talked about Robert the doll's origin and where you can visit him now if you're looking to add some dark energy to your life. Information for this podcast was found at: https://www.ghostsandgravestones.com/key-west/robert-the-doll https://en.wikipedia.o...

Send a text Hey!! We’re back!! Welcome to our 25th episode! This week Erin brings us up to date on the escaped convict Casey White and Vicky White the corrections officer that facilitated the escape. We also had a full house while we were recording so it’s a wild ride. Hope you enjoy!!! Information for this episode was found on CNN, ABC news, NY post and Independent. Uk.co Be sure to follow us on...

Send a text First we have a pretty interesting update on the Devil’s Rocking Chair and then we dove into the urban legend ( or is it real?) of the Jersey Devil. The local boogeyman Erin and I have grown up avoiding without much explanation as to why.  Information for this episode was found on Wikipedia, weird NJ and my own personal experiences.  Be sure to follow us on instagram @ deeply unsettlin...

Send a text What is safer then sending your kids to a summer program where they are picked up and dropped off by the bus? Well apparently a lot.  I am surprised that our long ancestral tie to bus driving never taught us about this nightmare of a bus ride.  Information for this episode was found on Wikipedia, YouTube and Morbid podcast.  Be sure to follow us on instagram to see pictures of all the...

Send a text We have gone in caves, we have dived under the water, now let's climb a mountain, specifically Mount Everest. Making it to the summit of Mount Everest is a legendary feat, so we can only assume the deaths trying to accomplish this accolade are also unlike any other. This we are talking about the deaths on Mount Everest. Information for this episode was found at: https://allthatsin...