Crimes & Closets

Harmony was a sweet 5 year old girl. Both of her parents struggled with substance abuse and she would go into foster care for some time. She would eventually be placed in the custody of her father. Her father was not the person she should have been with. The system failed Harmony. Join us as we discuss this difficult and gruesome case. Sources: https://www.wmur.com/article/harmony-montgomery-timel...

Christopher Meyer was a sweet 10 year old boy who went missing after fishing at a local boat dock near his home in Kankanee County, Illinois in August of 1995. He was later found murdered. 14 years before, in May 1981, 5 year old Tara Sue Huffman was also found murdered in the same area. These 2 families had no idea that through the loss of their 2 children that they would forever be connected to...

Daniel Holtzclaw was a police officer in Oklahoma City. Late one night he pulled someone over on his way home after his shift. The next day she made a complaint against him and then an investigation began and his life was changed forever. Join us as we discuss interesting and controversial case. Sources: 20/20: What the Dashcam Never Saw https://www.enidnews.com/news/timeline-daniel-holtzclaw-alle...

Bobby Kicklighter was a beloved husband, father, and grandfather, a pillar of his community, and the local town historian. When he was randomly shot in his bed at the age of 88 the town of Glennville, Georgia wanted answers. The ones they got were disturbing, confusing, and down right scary. This case is a smaller piece of a larger puzzle but we are honored to tell Mr. Bobby’s story. Join us in th...

Gary was a well-loved Drag Queen in Ohio. He was also the crowned Ms. Gay Ohio in 1995. He made friends easily, but not all were good friends. One became jealous of Brazon and brutally attacked him. Join us as we discuss this sad case. Sources: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/21421773/gary-%22brazon%22-mcmurtry https://www.advocate.com/news/2005/09/15/prosecuting-killer https://www.advocate.co...

Jessica Carpenter was a bright, 17 year old, high school student who was enjoying a summer day at home alone. Unfortunately, her trusting nature led a predator into her home and she was brutally murdered. After 2 years, the killer’s identity was finally revealed and what led him to Jessica’s home that day is truly terrifying. Join us in the closet this week as we discuss the tragic murder of Jessi...

Alexavier was a sweet, 6-year-old boy, in La Crosse Wisconsin. Alexavier, died at the hands of his father's girlfriend. Family called concerned about Alexavier's welfare many times and the system failed him. Raven, his cousin, joins us at the end of the episode to speak about him and the path they are on to seek changes in our system. Join us as we discuss this important case. Petition for...

Marty and Glenna Duram were a happy couple living in a small town in Michigan. One day in May of 2015 both of them were found shot in their home. The case went cold for a year until a very unlikely witness surfaced via a viral video. This case is shocking and has to be a once in a lifetime example that there are eyes and ears everywhere. Join us in the closet this week as we discuss the murder of...

On February 20, 2016, Jason Dalton, a husband and father of 2 children, left his house to take some fares on the Uber app. Little did anyone know he was about to go on a shooting spree, claiming the app to be possessed and telling him to do it. Join us as we discuss this terrifying case. Sources: https://www.foreverstrongfoundation.org/ 20/20 – The Deadly Ride – Season 41 Episode 26 - Hulu https:/...

Mary Wilcox was a 78 year old mother and grandmother who was suffering from heart disease, depression, and Alzheimer’s Disease. She moved in with her daughter, Jeanne, in the rural town of Westford Vermont. On a cold fall day in November 2006, Mary disappeared from this home and was never seen again. It wasn’t until a person came forward over 3 years later that the truth about what may have happen...

William and Patty Prewitt were trying to make the best life for their family. They owned their own business and were struggling to stay afloat, but were doing the best that they could. One night, during a strong thunderstorm, Bill was shot while sleeping and Patty was attacked, or so she said. Patty quickly became the prime suspect. Patty maintains her innocence to this day, but what do you think?...

Glenn Turner and Randy Thompson were both young, healthy, and southern Georgia gentlemen. Both of them died in their early 30’s of remarkably similar illnesses. Once the family made the connection that they had both been romantically involved with the same woman, and died in the exact same manner, the real and chilling truth is revealed. Join us in the closet this week as we discuss the cases of G...

Kelly and Thomas Crain had one child left living with them, 14-year-old, Alex. It was the same for Alan and Diane Johnson, with 16-year-old Sara. Neither set of parents would know their time together would be cut short, and at the hands of their own children. Join us as we discuss these similar cases, with different motives, but they are equally sad. Sources: https://murderpedia.org/male. C/c/crai...

Carly Ryan was a sweet and fun loving 15 year old living in Stirling, Southern Australia. She loved to spend time online, especially chatting with her special friend, 18 year old Brandon Kane. Or so she thought. It turned out that Brandon was not everything he said he was and sadly, Carly fell victim to a deceitful online predator named Gary Newman. This case is tragic and reminds us of the danger...

Michael and Susan met in college and both majored in international business. After graduating they married and became quite the power couple. Then one day they disappeared and were found in their submerged car in the everglades. What happened to the Nobley's? Sources: www.naplesnews.com www.tampabay.com www.brandenton.com

Siam was a 20 year old, aspiring teacher and traveler. She was trying to make money to go to school when she became a sensual masseuse, and started advertising on an adult booking website. I was through this website she met a dangerous predator. Join us as we discuss this case. Sources: https://www.news24.com/news24/insider-in-siam-lee-case-found-murdered-on-durban-sports-ground-with-her-hands-cut...

21 year old Karen Winslett and 19 year Annette Huddle were both beautiful and smart young women in the primes of their lives. Unfortunately, they came across a man who was charming but had evil intentions, and they both lost their lives to him. After 7 years on the run, Paul Steven Mack was convicted of Karen’s murder, and later confessed to Annette’s murder on his deathbed. Join us in the closet...

Glenys Heyward endured mental and physical abuse at the hands of Neil Heyward for 20 years. When she finally chose to leave him and claim a portion of the business and property she helped make successful, Neil planned her murder and used her children to help him. Please join us as we discuss this heinous crime. Sources: Inside Crime Season 2 Episode 4 on Prime Video https://www.abc.net.au/news/200...

Mark Himebaugh was an 11 year old boy living in the small community of Del Haven, New Jersey. He mysteriously went missing near his home in November of 1991, and has never been seen again. Did Mark fall victim to a drowning accident? Was he abducted? Did he run away? The family and investigators believe that someone knows something. Where is Mark?  If you have any information about the disappearan...

Brian Barrett was a 22-year-old aspiring teacher. He excelled in baseball in high school and every one loved Brian. Brian's only mistake was befriending Thomas Montgomery, a co-worker of his, and Talhotblond, a gamer on a gaming website. A love triangle begins, and Brian is the one who turns in a victim. Join us as we discuss this case, which has a super interesting twist at the end. Sources:...

Savannah Smith was a happy 8 year girl, playing with her friends and family in and near her home in 2006. Sadly, she trusted a young man with horrific intentions that no one saw coming. She was later found brutally murdered in a nearby town. Thankfully, her soulless killer will remain behind bars and out of society for the remainder of his life. But we can never truly feel at peace knowing he stol...

Julie was a student studying fashion, at Orange Coast College, where she met Sam Herr, a war veteran who went back to school after returning from war. Julie and Sam had the misfortune of befriending, Daniel Wozniak, who also lived in the same apartment complex as Sam. Daniel was in financial trouble and decided his only way out was to hurt his friends. Join us as we discuss this sad case. Sources:...

Larry McNabney was a charismatic, successful, and wealthy attorney in the Sacramento, California area. He was also well known in the quarter horse showing circuit. In September 2001, Larry went mysteriously missing. His wife, Elisa, and her best friend, Sarah, attempted to keep the law practice running in his absence. When Elisa also went missing, dark secrets and the truth about where the McNabne...

Sierah and Josh met when they were little and became high school sweethearts. in 2016, Sierah was 20 years old and going into her junior year of college and was on summer break. Sierah rode her bicycle to see Josh one evening. Josh rode his motorcycle next to her for a few miles, but then let her finish the rest on her own. She never made it home. Join us as we discuss this chilling case. Sources:...

Sean Daugherty was a happy, smart 12 year old boy who had just arrived home from a wonderful vacation with his family. One ordinary afternoon in April of 2022, Sean was found hanging from the family’s swingset in the backyard. His death was quickly assummed to have been a suicide, but here are many details and aspects that do not line up. Sean’s family continues to fight for justice in hopes that...