Skip or Scream

Brandon of Terrorific is back on the mic this week. We get into Maggie’s questionable choice to screen Bring Her Back at her own bachelorette party, whether pasta water has to be boiling before the noodles go in, and a heated debate occurs over whether shower curtains should be left open or closed, as Kassie recaps Other Mommy (2026). She sat through it twice for you. Never say we don’t sacrifice...

Welcome back, When we last left off, our hosts were in a perilous position, coming to you from an abandoned radio station with a Halloween broadcast that had gone awry. Forced to continue the show (and continue enduring some seriously unsettling tales recorded by their friends in the Collective), the entity on the phone has not only started to make those stories a reality, but It has now begun to...

Episode 51: Vivarium Maggie’s Letterboxd era officially paid off, Imogen Poots sports the most chic microbangs ever, and we discuss whether a pit full of googly eyes is scary, as Maggie recaps Vivarium (2019). Patrons picked this one! Question of the Week @ 18:55 Movie Info @ 23:11 Recap @ 29:15 Skip or Scream? @ 1:22:54 Watch trailer here (No trailer this week because it spoils the movie) Join ou...

Welcome, Tonight we come to you from an abandoned radio station for a very special Halloween two part series to broadcast some of the scariest stories, urban legends and real events live on air. Five friends have broken in with the plan to create something spectacularly and unforgettably spooky but their night is about to take a twisted turn when something sinister that was lurking within the conf...

Episode 50: Friday the 13th Fifty episodes in, and this week we're getting into Maggie's on-air resignation over when exactly we watch the trailer, a camp counselor who will only read by candlelight, and a loon-call drinking game that would land you in the hospital, as Kassie finally walks Maggie through Friday the 13th (1980).  Question of the Week @ 10:31 Movie Info @ 14:29 Recap @ 22:34...

Episode 49: Run Rabbit Run Before we head to Fantastic Fest, we're celebrating our first director comment on socials, reliving the Jellystone Park trip we were never fancy enough for as kids, and arguing over whether the kids' table was actually the best table while Maggie recaps Run Rabbit Run (2023). Question of the Week @ 7:38 Movie Info @ 11:21 Recap @ 17:27 Skip or Scream? @ 1:10:43 W...

Hellcat (2026) This week we've got Megan and Missy from Grimly joining us, and things spiral almost immediately as we dive into glizzy lore and Maggie's ever-expanding "hear me out" cake. Maggie and Kassie recap the new Shudder original Hellcat (2026). Two unserious podcasts, one very serious taxidermy-related conversation. Question of the Week @ 18:55 Movie Info @ 30:39 Recap @...

Follow along as we teach you about convex surfaces, Maggie describes the meal that changed her life, and we recap the 2026 body horror, Saccharine. Question of the Week: 8:20 Movie Info: 14:49 Recap: 20:57

Episode 46: You’re Next (2013) Maggie recorded this one three IPAs deep and fully copping to it, Kassie had to publicly apologize for badmouthing our guest’s name, and somehow we still found time for an impromptu audio real estate tour of a 9,000-square-foot mansion that's been sitting vacant for fifteen years as Maggie and Kassie recap You're Next. Question of the Week @ 11:47 Movie Info...

Episode 45: Evil Dead Rise (2023) Hold onto your scalp, because this week Maggie recaps the gruesome Evil Dead Rise. Tune in as we discuss Applebee’s trios, Staphanie the protector, and workshop exactly what it would take to lure each other out of sisterly estrangement.  Question of the Week @ 4:28 Movie Info @ 10:33 Recap @ 22:36 Skip or Scream? @ 1:05:29 Watch trailer here Join our Patreon here!...

Grab your Diet Pepsi and your canned beans, because this week we cover what we determined is one of the sickest (not in a good way) movies we have covered on the pod, The Sadness (2021). Fair warning: This is the only movie so far that came with its own consent button before we could even watch the trailer. Question of the Week @ 7:51 Movie Info @ 12:45 Recap @ 18:36 Skip or Scream? @ 1:36:20 Watc...

Episode 43: Seven Nights of Darkness (2011) ft. Unknown, Unsolved, Unseen This time around we we calculate exactly how much a haunted asylum stay is worth in 2026 dollars, Kassie's personal hell of people with zero body awareness, and the haunted asylum room that would destroy Frank as Maggie recaps Seven Nights of Darkness (2011). Plus, we have guests! Frank and Sage from Unknown, Unsolved, U...

Episode 42: The Monkey (2025) Join us this week as we discuss the wonder that is off-brand cereal, what exactly 67 horses can do to a sleeping bag, and why you should never clean your face with rubbing alcohol before checking for a gas leak, as Kassie recaps Osgood Perkins’ The Monkey. Question of the Week @ 10:56 Movie Info @ 19:54 Recap @ 29:15 Skip or Scream? @ 1:14:38 Watch trailer here Join o...

Episode 41: Shelby Oaks(2024) This week, Maggie comes crawling back to eat her words about Obsession, we debate what we'd actually do if the other one went missing, and Mia makes some deeply questionable navigation decisions as Maggie recaps Shelby Oaks (2024). Twelve years in a demon cult basement and Riley's bangs still look better than yours, so maybe take notes. Question of the Week @...

Episode 40: Obsession (2026) This one’s a doozy. This week we discuss the One Wish Willow's very strict terms and conditions, Kassie’s similarities to Freaky Nikki, and a sandwich with a surprise ingredient as Kassie recaps Obsession (2026). Bear really said "what's so bad about being with me?" and we said go to therapy, sir. Question of the Week @ 6:40 Movie Info @ 11:44 Recap @...

Episode 39: What You Wish For (2023 Join us this week as we discuss Kassie’s issues with the Backrooms font, a very informative Crawfish Corner courtesy of a listener, and how to identify if a tongue has herpes as Maggie recaps What You Wish For (2023). A horror / thriller you've definitely never heard of starring a “that guy.” Question of the Week @ 5:49 Movie Info @ 8:46 Recap @ 17:31 Skip o...

Episode 38: Hokum (2026) Join us this week as we discuss husband of the pod finally making his on-mic debut, diabetic solidarity, and the unhinged moral philosophy of Fuck, Marry, Kill as Maggie recaps Hokum (2025). Featuring a donkey that will haunt your dreams, Adam Scott playing a complete and utter dick, and our most chaotic guest yet, James, who didn't even know he agreed to do this. Ques...

Episode 37: Faces of Death (2026) Join us this week as we discuss a very exclusive children's swimming lesson enrollment process, the dark side of doomscrolling for a living, and a killer who loves reading his own comments, as Kassie recaps Faces of Death (2026). Was this movie actually banned in other countries? Which chat-topping pop start has a cameo ? And is Dacre Montgomery actually named...

Episode 36: Match (2025) ft. Terrorific Join us this week as we discuss a very honest Tinder bio, the surprisingly rich genre of practical effects involving sweet potatoes, and the most unhinged mama's boy situation we've ever encountered, as Brandon of Terrorific recaps Match (2025). Dating apps have never looked more terrifying… and we've seen some shit. Question of the Week @ 14:20 Movie Info @...

This Week: Cursed (2005) Join us this week as we discuss Bowling for Soup's secret Hollywood aliases, who among us is brave enough to catch a fly with their bare hand, and debate who in this movie is actually the gay one as guests Chelsea and Sydney, of Spooky Tuesday,  recap Wes Craven and Kevin Williamson’s Cursed (2005). Question of the Week @ 15:36 Movie Info @ 24:00 Recap @ 31:10 Skip or Scre...

This Week: Primate (2025) Join us this week as we debate whether legless lizards are just snakes in denial, learn that Hawaii is a rabies-free paradise, and discover that the best way to portray a murderous chimpanzee is to just put a guy in a suit , as Maggie recaps the 2025 creature feature, Primate . Question of the Week @ 5:20 Movie Info @ 11:58 Recap @ 17:46 Skip or Scream? @ 1:05:15 Watch tr...

Episode 33: Totally Killer (2023) feat. Final Girls PodcastKassie is back, and we brought reinforcements. This week we're joined by Kellie Nicole Hill and Sarah Spurlock, co-hosts of Final Girls, a podcast that examines horror through a feminist lens by dissecting one iconic final girl per episode. Safe to say this might be our most academically credentialed episode yet. We chat with the ladie...

This Week: Slaxx (2020) Could this be the most unhinged movie we have ever covered on the pod? I think so. Listen in as we discuss serving looks in elementary school, recent movies that underwhelmed us, and what can happen if your favorite hard pants take control as we recap the Shudder Original, Slaxx.  Question of the Week @ 12:08 Movie Info @ 19:44 Recap @ 22:34 Skip or Scream? @ 55:21 Watch tr...

This Week: The Village (2004) feat. Gleek of the Week and Allison Dodge Kassie is out this week, so Maggie is holding it down solo, with a little help from some very special guests: Andrew McGuire, from Gleek of the Week, and Allison Dodge, previous guest of the pod and former Gleek of the Week co-host. Join the crew as they catch up on life and determine if M. Night Shyamalan’s twist on this one...

We have 2 amazingly special guests on this ep, Ash and Ally, from the pod Sips and Screams. So not only do you get one set of sisters this week, but two sets! Things get “viral” as we reminisce on the nostalgia of the late 00’s and discuss the “screen horror” Unfriended: Dark Web. Question of the Week @ 14:53 Movie Info @ 25:33 Recap @ 38:51 Skip or Scream? @ 1:51:22 Watch trailer here Join our Pa...