Matt Shea and Eric Poch

You Didn't Ask For This

Comedy EN ↓ 162 episodes

Is cereal just soup? When, specifically, is Miller Time? How many times can one "circle back?" Join Matt and Eric every other Thursday as they provide you with deep dives, thorough debates, and unnecessary answers to life's least-pressing questions. Submit yours at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.youdidntaskforthis.com

Author

Matt Shea and Eric Poch

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

www.youdidntaskforthis.com

Latest episode

Nov 19, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

58 | Grippable Skull 02.02.2023

Is milk juice? At the movie theater, which armrest is yours? What makes a face punchable? We answer these questions after Matt's dream actions cause him problems and before we get to a circle-back/follow-up on his secret Elf on the Shelf exploits. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood group drama, and whatever else you want us to cover at youdi...

57 | An NFT by Any Other Name 19.01.2023

A simple question submission may have led to a new YDAFT tradition. This week the boys figure out what is on their 2023 Bingo Cards...and invite you to play along! You can fill out a 2023 YDAFT Bingo Card here. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood group drama, and whatever else you want us to cover at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com or @udidntaskpod o...

56 | So Said Meatloaf and So Say I 05.01.2023

How big is personal space? How does one win 'The Game' (which, sorry: you just lost)? Plus: we invent new circles of Hell and Eric completes his half of Google Gripes Season 2, Round 1! Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood group drama, and whatever else you want us to cover at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com or @udidntaskpod on Instagram , T...

55 | Elf on the Chaise Lounge 22.12.2022

Happy holidays, everyone! Since you've all been so good, this year we got you a brand new Definitive Ranking: the 12 days of Christmas! Just what does one do with all these damn birds? Plus: love him or hate him, we're tackling all your questions about the Elf on the Shelf. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood group drama, and whatever el...

54 | Step Into My Office 08.12.2022

What is the best and worst way to spend spoons? Eric finally gets to teach Matt about Spoon Theory before the boys tackle a delicate question: in this era of Toxic Masculinity, "what is the modern day "Test of Manhood"? Plus: the first YDAFT job reference and the season two premiere of Google Gripes. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborh...

53 | Daddy the Magnificent 24.11.2022

What are the ingredients of Humble Pie? What's the oldest trick in the book? Why do millennials hate phone calls? This Thanksgiving, we're grateful to be tackling these questions as we search for a new Turkey Day tradition and wrestle with a challenge from the Thoughtline.  Play out music for this episode: "Don't Take It Out on Me" by PEG and the Rejected. Submit your leas...

52 | Boudoir Feet Pics 10.11.2022

What is the appropriate punishment for coworkers that eat your lunch? How did Pigpen get so dirty and why can't he get clean? We answer these existential dilemmas before heading to the Thoughtline, where two spouses have called on us for counseling. Plus: a brand-new segment of Fun Facts that you certainly didn't ask for. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive ra...

51 | Pillow Talk 27.10.2022

Spooky season is upon us and we've got an episode full of Halloween treats! Namely: what's the worst Halloween candy? What does your Trick or Treat bag of choice say about you? What (fictional) serial killer would you want to be your roommate? Plus: the boys ask each other some personal questions. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood grou...

50 | Soup as Old as Rhyme 13.10.2022

To celebrate the 50th episode of YDAFT, we're welcoming back all of our past guests! These YDAFT Giants return as guest gripers in the much-anticipated season one finale of Google Gripes. But first: we finally cover the burning question from our show's description.   Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood drama, and whatever else you want u...

49 | 1.21 GigaWTF? 29.09.2022

In a themed episode, we go through your least-pressing questions about Sci Fi classic (and Matt's favorite movie) Back to the Future. From so called "plot holes" to speculation on what the characters are up to in 2022, we clean-up the BTTF Continuum for you. Plus: a check-in with Fauntleroy.   Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood dra...

48 | Baby's First Biscuit (LIVE!) 15.09.2022

In YDAFT's first-ever live episode, the boys welcome back Andy "Cookie" Rawlings as they fulfill a request from across the pond: to definitively re-rank Dave Channel's bullshit list of Britain's Best-Loved Biscuits. Click here to see Dave's original list. To see images of each biscuit, visit our Instagram ! The episode was recorded live on the YDAFT YouTube channel on...

47 | Throw the Whole Man Out 01.09.2022

Does Jolene know that Dolly’s man says her name in his sleep, or did she have to find out through song like everyone else? In a world where dogs play poker, what breed would be dealer? The players? Why don't birds poop on the roofs of houses? This episode provides those answers, but only after Matt determines if Eric is a member of The Back to the Future Community. Plus: a dramatic reading of...

46 | Mansplaining Mansplaining 18.08.2022

Road trips are full of questions and this episode, we're answering them all. Well, okay...some. Such as: are Swedish Fish gummies? What are the roles and responsibilities  of each passenger in the car? Do other states besides New Jersey prohibit you from pumping your own gas...and what happens to you if you do? Plus: new neighborly nonsense in a fresh Neighborhood Watch. JUST ANNOUNCED: Episo...

45 | The Doughletariat 04.08.2022

Is the Pillsbury Doughboy a cannibal? If it's neither here nor there...where is it? What's the creepiest thing you can say when passing someone on the street? This is the eclectic group of conundrums facing us on episode 45, along with a fresh batch of Local Legends, and Matt's new special journal. Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhoo...

The Best of Episodes 31-40 21.07.2022

Our July has been a bit hectic so you'll have to wait a little longer for episode 45, but in the meantime please take enjoy reliving the very best of episodes 31-40! While you wait... Submit your least pressing questions, local legends, definitive rankings, neighborhood drama, and whatever else you want us to cover at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com or @udidntaskpod on Instagram , Twitter, and F...

44 | Mozzarella is a Team Player 07.07.2022

What kind of cheese is the best cheese? And in what form? And how many slices of American Cheese is too many? We answer all of these questions from a cheesy Twitter thread plus: does farting make you heavier? Why does nature pre-slice oranges and grapefruits? Then: the thrilling conclusion to round three of Google Gripes. Want more Google Gripes? Round One 32 | Pouch Me, Mama 34 | Unregistered Met...

43 | Sell Out, Cash In 23.06.2022

What happened to Fuzzy Wuzzy's hair? When does sooner end and later begin? Is breakfast for dinner...still just breakfast? We dissect these conundrums, dig into Ben and Jerry's recommendations,  and start a brand new round of Google Gripes. Want to catch up on the first two rounds of Google Gripes? Here's your guide: Round One 32 | Pouch Me, Mama 34 | Unregistered Method Acting Roun...

42 | Win One for the Quacker 09.06.2022

We are thrilled to be joined by psychedelic folk artist and former YDAFT Local Legend...Lewis Mallard! If you missed our previous report on Lewis (episode 37), Lewis travels the streets of Hamilton, Ontario as a giant duck. We interview Lewis about his experiences as an avian artist while Lewis asks questions about powdered milk and D&D characters. We also work together to formulate a fair tra...

41 | Depending on the Vibe... 26.05.2022

What is the correct way to make a PB&J? It's a question everyone has an answer to...and we are no exception. We duke it out over this culinary staple before examining what the Tooth Fairy does with all those teeth, what you see when life "flashes before your eyes" and spend a great deal of time on Reese and his various peanut butter products. Plus: a brand-new closing segment br...

40 | Booty Scoots 12.05.2022

Are there more windows or wheels? This week we take the viral TikTok question a little bit deeper before tackling what the world would look like if Cephalapods had become the dominant creature on Earth. Plus: the return of Fast Five and we celebrate 40 episodes by answering some personal questions. Got a question for the show? Submit your least pressing questions at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com or...

39 | "K." 28.04.2022

This episode is all about etiquette and protocols: how do you get a guest to leave your house? What's the most unethical use of PowerPoint? Is ending a sentence in a text without punctuation passive aggressive? Plus: we debut a long-requested closing segment and respond to the beef the boys at Effin' Cultured started with us. Got a question for the show? Submit your least pressing questi...

38 | The Deuce is Loose 14.04.2022

Joining us this week is special guest and patron saint of podcasting Zack Deuce! Together we solve the pressing issues facing the world today: what happens if you're scared half to death twice? Why do we say something is "out of whack" and what IS "a whack?" How many chickens does it take to kill an elephant? Then: Matt and Eric interview Zack about life in the world of re...

37 | You Can't Conceive of Cary Elwes 31.03.2022

This week we dive into a YDAFT investigation to find out: Is anything in The Princess Bride truly "inconceivable?" Plus: what's the difference between a sketch and a skit? We close things out with two new Local Legends...after Matt starts things off with an injury. Got a question for the show? Submit your least pressing questions at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com or @udidntaskpod on I...

36 | Truecuterie 17.03.2022

What is Dr. Pepper's doctorate in? Is St. Patrick's Day overrated, underrated, or perfectly rated? How do you create the perfect charcuterie board using only items found at 7-11? This episode we're building that board and answering these questions plus bringing you more 1-star Google reviews. Got a question for the show? Submit your least pressing questions at youdidntaskforthis@gma...

35 | On the Advice of My Counsel 03.03.2022

This week we welcome attorney and YDAFT Giant Carisa Hatfield to the show! Carisa brings an existential question about one's strength before we dive into picking a non-DeLorean vehicular time machine and  getting a lawyer's advice on the legality Ariel's contract in The Little Mermaid. Got a question for the show? Submit your least pressing questions at youdidntaskforthis@gmail.com...

Listen to the You Didn't Ask For This podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.