Joel

You Can’t Make This BS Up!

Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Author

Joel

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

rss.com

Latest episode

Jan 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

The Shocking Murder of Danielle Marshall (59) 30.01.2026

Uncover the harrowing true crime story of the Danielle Marshall murder in Powder Springs, Georgia—a chilling case that shocked a quiet Atlanta suburb. In this episode of “You Can’t Make This BS Up,” host Joel Davis delves into the brutal 2013 homicide of 23-year-old single mom Danielle Marshall, gunned down in her home while her infant daughter Eva crawled amid the bloodshed. Explore the toxic ex-...

The Baton Rouge Serial Killer: Derrick Todd Lee’s Reign of Terror (58) 19.01.2026

Buckle up for a chilling deep dive into one of Louisiana’s darkest chapters. Host Joel Davis uncovers the twisted life of Derrick Todd Lee, the smooth-talking predator who terrorized Baton Rouge and beyond from 1998-2003. Posing as a charming everyman, he stalked, raped, and brutally murdered at least 7 women—leaving bodies in swamps, homes soaked in blood, and a community in fear. From his troubl...

The Shallow Grave Jealousy Trap (57) 14.01.2026

What happens when a single mom of four tries to move on from a toxic ex… and he decides she can’t? In January 2024, 32-year-old Kayla Laray Atwood drops her kids off at daycare and school in Pensacola, Florida—like any normal day. She never comes back. Her phone goes dark. Her family panics. Police release a chilling photo: Kayla climbing into a yellow Penske truck with a guy she met on a dating a...

Betrayed in the Shadows: The Brutal Murder of Alishah Pointer (56) 12.01.2026

Dive into the heart-wrenching true crime story of Alishah Pointer, a vibrant young woman whose life was stolen on the eve of her 22nd birthday in East Cleveland, Ohio. Uncover the twisted web of revenge, betrayal by a trusted friend, and unimaginable torture that led to her tragic end. Join host Joel Davis as we explore the chilling details, the hunt for justice, and the enduring pain of a family...

A Rising Star Lost: The Tragic Story of Cleveland Rapper Ahlotta (55) 26.12.2025

In this emotional episode, we delve into the life and tragic death of Breneisha Lightfoot, the talented Cleveland rapper known as Ahlotta. A resilient young woman dedicated to her music, community, and saving lives from gun violence, Breneisha's bright future was cut short on the eve of her 26th birthday by domestic abuse. We explore her inspiring journey, the devastating events of July 2023, and...

Onlyfans and her new man took her life. (54) 11.12.2025

Delve into the chilling North Texas murder-suicide that exposed how one OnlyFans page can shatter lives. Shady Oaks Shadows uncovers Stephanie Ingram’s fierce rise as a mom-turned-creator, her jealous partner Anthony Thornton’s spiral, and the silence after gunfire—forty-five minutes of family secrets, court files, and what safety really means online. No fluff, just facts that keep you up.

Recorded Rage: The Murder of Rahim Grant by Ciera Harp (53) 21.11.2025

Summary This episode delves into the tragic story of Raheem Grant, a talented rapper known as Red Beazzy, who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend Sierra Harp. The narrative explores the complexities of their relationship, the events leading up to the murder, and the subsequent investigation and trial. It highlights themes of jealousy, obsession, and the consequences of toxic relationships, ultimatel...

Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 2 (52) 10.11.2025

Summary This podcast episode delves into the chilling story of Nancy Doss, also known as the Giggling Granny, who allegedly killed at least 11 people, including her husbands and family members. The host, Joel, narrates her life, marriages, and the dark events that led to her becoming a notorious figure in true crime history. The episode explores themes of mental health, societal perceptions of wom...

Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 1 (51) 07.11.2025

Takeaways Joel expresses gratitude for listener support and engagement. Nancy Doss, known as Nanny, had a troubled childhood with an abusive father. Nanny's early life was marked by hardship and limited education. She married Charlie Braggs at a young age, escaping her father's control. Nanny's marriage to Charlie was tumultuous, leading to the mysterious deaths of their children. After her divorc...

Murder, Love, and Betrayal: The Alicia "Shayne" Mills Lovera Story (50) 23.10.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic story of Alicia Shane Mills-Lavera and her lover Brett Ray, who conspired to murder her husband, Kelly Lavera. The conversation covers the background of the individuals involved, the investigation that followed Kelly's suspicious death, and the subsequent trial that led to the conviction of both Alicia and Brett. Joel reflects on the moral implica...

Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too Good To Be True pt 3 (49) 16.10.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel shares personal updates and dives into the tragic case of Yuri Jenkins, who orchestrated the murder of his wife, Makeeva. The conversation explores the complexities of the trial, the motivations behind the crime, and the eventual sentencing of Jenkins and his accomplices. Joel emphasizes the importance of accountability and the consequences of one's actions, drawing p...

Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too Good To Be True pt 2 (48) 03.10.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel reflects on the growth of his podcast and expresses gratitude to his listeners. He delves into the tragic case of Makaiva Jenkins, a young mother who was murdered in her home. The investigation reveals a complex web of suspects and motives, raising questions about the events leading up to her death. Joel emphasizes the importance of community awareness in true crime a...

Euri Jenkins aka Mr. Too good to be true PT 1 (47) 30.09.2025

Summary This conversation delves into the tragic story of Makava Jenkins, a vibrant entrepreneur and mother whose life was cut short by a violent crime. The host reflects on her background, the community of Belle Glade, and the circumstances surrounding her murder. The discussion highlights the impact of her life and the investigation that followed, raising questions about the motives behind her d...

The Murder Case of Sasha Skare (46) 25.09.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic case of Martell DeRoyan, a rising music producer and cousin of Beyoncé, who was murdered by Sasha Scared, a woman with a troubled past. The conversation explores Martell's life, his career in the music industry, and the complexities of his relationship with Sasha. Joel reflects on the events leading up to Martell's death, the investigation, and th...

Robert "Terry" Ellison - Evil Is Inside of Me (45) 14.09.2025

Summary The episode delves into the life of Terry Ellis, exploring his troubled past, family dynamics, and the impact of his actions on those around him. It covers his early behavior, family background, violent tendencies, military and legal troubles, and the eventual consequences of his actions. Takeaways Terry Ellis was born to a white mother and a Lumbee Indian father, with his father absent fr...

The House Party Killer – The Tyler Hadley Case (44) 05.09.2025

In July 2011, 17-year-old Tyler Hadley of Port St. Lucie, Florida, did the unthinkable. After weeks of planning, he brutally murdered his parents, Blake and Mary-Jo Hadley, in their own home. Hours later, he threw a wild house party with dozens of classmates—while his parents’ bodies lay hidden in the master bedroom. This episode takes you deep inside the shocking case: Tyler’s troubled childhood,...

Bumpy Johnson: Harlem's Notorious Gangster (43) 30.08.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel shares personal updates and transitions into the captivating story of Bumpy Johnson, a notorious gangster from Harlem. The conversation explores Johnson's early life, rise to power, and the challenges he faced in the criminal underworld. Joel reflects on Johnson's legacy, his impact on American culture, and the lessons that can be learned from his life. Takeaways Joel...

A Friendship Turned Deadly: The Story of Jimella and Tiffany (42) 19.08.2025

Takeaways The podcast introduces a tragic story of betrayal and murder. Jamila and Tiffany were lifelong friends with a complicated relationship. Tiffany's jealousy led to a horrific crime against her best friend. The story highlights the impact of mental health and unresolved issues. Tiffany's actions resulted in the loss of multiple lives, including children. The community rallied to support Jam...

From Fame to Infamy: Jennifer Mee's Journey (41) 17.08.2025

Takeaways Jennifer Mee's story highlights the impact of childhood trauma. Fame can have unexpected consequences on mental health. The influence of relationships can lead to poor decision-making. Jennifer's hiccups brought her fame but also led to her downfall. The importance of addressing mental health issues early on. Trauma can shape preferences in relationships and choices. The legal system's r...

The Dark Side of Love: The Laura Ackerson Case (40) 11.08.2025

Takeaways Joel shares his personal struggles with his AC and financial issues. The story revolves around Laura Ackerman and her tumultuous relationships. Grant Hayes is depicted as an abusive partner with a victim mentality. Laura's journey highlights the challenges of escaping an abusive relationship. Amanda Perry enters the story as a significant figure in Grant's life. The custody battle betwee...

Unraveling the Tragic Case of Jonelle Melton (39) 06.08.2025

Summary In this episode, Joel discusses the tragic case of Janelle Melton, a dedicated teacher who was murdered in her home. The conversation covers the investigation, the suspects involved, and the eventual resolution of the case. Joel reflects on the impact of the crime, the challenges faced by the victim's family, and the importance of seeking justice. The episode also highlights the role of a...

Maurice Fayne: From Reality Star to Federal Prison (38) 01.08.2025

Keywords PPP loans, Maurice Fane, Love and Hip Hop, scamming, federal prison, fraud, Black Friday, podcast, financial crime, reality TV Summary In this episode, Joel Davis discusses the story of Maurice Fane, a reality TV star who became embroiled in a major PPP loan fraud scheme. The conversation covers Fane's rise to fame, his fraudulent activities during the COVID-19 pandemic, the federal inves...

Unmasking a Con Artist: The Sabrina Taylor (37) 18.07.2025

Summary This podcast episode delves into the case of Sabrina Taylor, a con artist who deceived her friends and community by fabricating a story about suffering from multiple sclerosis. Through emotional manipulation and a web of lies, she exploited the generosity of others, leading to significant financial and emotional damage for her victims. The episode explores the details of her deception, the...

Love, Lust, and Betrayal: Marjorie Orbin (36) 16.07.2025

Summary This episode delves into the chilling true crime story of Jay and Marjorie Orban, exploring themes of love, betrayal, and murder. It recounts Jay's disappearance, the discovery of his remains, and Marjorie's subsequent trial and conviction for his murder. The narrative highlights Marjorie's manipulative behavior, her relationships, and the tragic impact of her actions on her family. Takeaw...

Samuel Little the Most Prolific Serial Killer in USA History (35) 14.07.2025

SummaryThis episode delves into the life and crimes of Samuel Little, the most prolific serial killer in U.S. history. From his troubled childhood to his manipulative tactics and eventual capture, the conversation explores the psychological aspects of his criminal behavior and the societal failures that allowed him to evade justice for so long. The discussion also highlights the impact of his acti...

Listen to the You Can’t Make This BS Up! podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.