Which Murderer?

In Which Murderer’s Episode 25 Season 5 the girls cover Murders of Passion. Holly starts us off with the murder story involving Martha Freeman and her closet before Mel goes into the murder of David Lynn Harris. Shoutout to our glowing Caitlin for this week’s topic suggestion! Holly starts us off with her experience as a hotel manager this Thanksgiving, Mel decides it's time to become a private de...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 24 Season 5 the girls cover Bullied and Murdered stories. Mel starts us off with the murder story involving Bobby Kent before Holly goes into the horrific crimes of Thomas Nutt. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s topic suggestion! Mel hits a wall for the fourth recording of the evening and makes it weird, Holly updates you on all the animals, Mel struggles to say a word...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 23 Season 5 the girls cover Mormon Murders. Holly starts us off with the origin story and original murder of Joseph Smith before Mel goes into the horrific crimes of Ron and Dan Lafferty. Shoutout to Betty who will never listen to this episode ever for the suggestion! Mel kicks things off with her best Tom Jones songs which go totally unappreciated, Holly recommends you...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 22 Season 5 the girls cover Landlord Murders. Please note murdering your landlord will not decrease your rent. Mel starts us off with the case of Helen McCourt before Holly goes into the story of Todd Greathouse. Which is the perfect name for a Landlord. Shoutout to Michelle for the episode suggestion! The girls take up time you will never get back telling you about som...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 21 Season 5 the girls cover Food Murders. This episode starts off with Holly telling you about Thomas Neill Cream (appropriate for this episode) before Mel goes into the story of Craig Godineux and John Taylor. Shoutout to Kristy for the episode suggestion! The girls are facing the realities of Christmas shopping budgets and £200 turkeys, Holly’s murderer has exactly on...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 20 Season 5 the girls cover Twin Murders. This episode starts off with Mel telling you about Kevin and Karl Dugar before Holly recounts the story of Pete and Pat Bondurant. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion - very interesting! Double trouble this episode with Mel just going for the opening and nailing it, Holly is put under car colour pressure, Mel is on a campaign...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 19 Season 5 the girls cover Catfish Murders. This episode starts off with Holly telling you about Thomas Montgomery before Mel recounts the story of Jenelle Potter. Shoutout to Kirsty and Millie the Cat for the suggestion - fabulous tie in with your furry family member! Who hopefully cannot use a keyboard. Buckle up, these cases are INSANE. Like the people in them. This...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 18 Season 5 the girls cover Murders Involving Sleep. This episode starts off with Mel telling you about Michael Ricksgers before Holly reveals an unusual tale from Spain, the story of Antonio Nieto. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion that was impossible to research! Keep the challenges coming! This week we start off with the sad news of HM Queen Elizabeth II’s death,...

LISTENER WARNING - THIS EPISODE INCLUDE DESCRIPTIONS OF PIGEONS WHICH FOR SOME REASON MAKES PEOPLE LOSE THEIR SWEET MINDS. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED WE GUESS? In Which Murderer’s Episode 17 Season 5 the girls cover Pigeon Murders to Holly’s delight! This car crash of an episode starts off with Holly telling you the story of Keith Walker which traumatises Mel given she re...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 16 Season 5 the girls cover Video Game Murders. Mel starts you off with the story of Daniel Petric before Holly talks about the very sad case of Breck Bednar. Shoutout to Garry for the interesting topic suggestion and excellent nightly shoulder rubs. Mel starts of with a non-murder related story of her charity shop adventures before rolling her eyes at Holly the Pigeon...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 15 Season 5 the girls cover people Murdered While Performing. Holly starts you off with the rise and sad early fall of musician Darrell Lance Abbott before Mel goes on to tell you about a very specific kind of performer named Pippa Bakka. Shoutout to Kirsty for another fabulous suggestion - only a few spots are now left in Season 5 so get your theme suggestions in now!...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 14 Season 5 the girls cover Vegan Murders. Mel starts off with the story of the short life of Crown Shakur before Holly tells you about another tragically short life, that of Ezra O'Leary. Shoutout Mel’s lash girl Alana for causing Christmas panic, Saraid for the theme suggestion and all our fans who are smashing the Whicher Merch sales! Holly circles the planet earth 4...

ADDITIONAL LISTENER WARNING FOR THIS EPISODE, THERE IS A PARTICULARLY UPSETTING CASE COVERED ABOUT A CHILD IN THIS WEEK’S EPISODE WHICH WE FELT WAS IMPORTANT TO DISCUSS GIVEN THE TOPIC THIS WEEK. LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED. In Which Murderer’s Episode 13 Season 5 the girls talk about Social Media Related Murders. Holly begins this week with the very sad story of Molly McLaren before Mel goes t...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 12 Season 5 the girls cover victims who have been Murdered by an Ex. Mel is up first with the case of Ellie Gould (not the singer) followed by Holly with the story of Joseph Oberhansley (hard to say). Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics! And yes at some point we will be mixing them up a bit. The girls give you a fascinating gli...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 11 Season 5 the girls talk about victims who have been Murdered by Police. It’s Holly’s turn to start this week with the bonkers story of NYPD member Charles Becker before Mel goes all sportsy with the case of Dalian Atkinson. Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics! And yes at some point we will be mixing them up a bit. Also huge...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 10 Season 5 the girls talk about Car Murders. Mel starts off with the case of Priscilla Ford (no relation probably to the car people) before Holly tells you about Dernell Renauld Stenson the baseball player. Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics! Mel is facing reality with a wonderful case of Covid after her wedding and honeymoon...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 9 Season 5 the girls talk about White Van Man Murders. Holly starts you off with the case of driver James Martin before Mel goes into the tragic story of Matthew Tvrdon. Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, even though it wasn’t really what you suggested and more what we decided….but you got us there so…..SHOUTOUT. You will learn a great many things about white...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 8 Season 5 the girls talk about People Who Were Framed for Murder. Mel starts off with the case of Robert Spangler before Holly covers the crazy story of Chaskel Werzberger. Shoutout to Cheryl again for the awesome theme suggestion! Also mentioned is listener Kristy who had a mystery box left on her property and ARE YOU OK? Holly pretends to be professional, the girls t...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 7 Season 5 the girls talk about Angel of Death Murders - which Holly questions literally every nurse she meets about. Holly starts off with the case involving Kimberly Clark Fowler before Mel covers the massive Dr. Shipman story. Shoutout to Cheryl again for the awesome theme suggestion! Also the facebook group members as a whole - we love watching you. In a non creepy...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 5 Season 6 the girls talk about CCTV Murders - tricky to navigate! Mel starts you off with Hannah Graham before Holly tells you about the case of Sierra LaMar. Shoutout to Cheryl for the awesome theme suggestion! Also Nicole from Virginia for the traumatising fan mail which we adored. The girls talk about the ‘C-Word’ once again, Holly has invented new methods of feedin...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 5 Season 5 the girls talk about Divorce Murders - tricky to navigate! Holly starts you off with Irene Paterson before Mel tells you about the massive case of Broderick v. Broderick. Shoutout to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion! Also to our Facebook followers for some hilarious discussions - especially surrounding clowns. The girls talk about drinks and Holly’s S...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 4 Season 5 the girls talk about Murder for Survival cases. Mels starts off with the tragic tale of Valerie Bacot before Holly takes you back in time to the tale of Richard Parker and the code of the seafarers. Shoutouts to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion and Michelle for the A+ supply of puppy and dog photos. It’s Rosie the dog’s birthday and the girls tell you...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 3 Season 5 the girls talk about Online Dating Murders. Holly is first (which she forgets) and tells you about the disturbed killer Carl Langdell before Mel tells you all about Khalil Wheeler Weaver - which you absolutely cannot say five times fast. Shoutouts to the mystery review leaver who used a phrase that made the girls research mid-recording and grow at least 2 bra...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 2 Season 5 the girls take a listener suggestion and cover Bus Driver Murders. Mel starts you off with the story of Darren Vickers before Holly tells you about Keith Bettison. Shoutouts to Jim who suggested this week’s topic and took Holly’s flagrant competitive challenging with grace (turns out she is not the F1 driver she thought), Cheryl for some good sleep advice and...

The first episode of Season 5 brings you Murders Solved by Dogs! Holly kicks things off with the story of Shantay Leann Leyba-Huntington before Mel tells you about Duane Daniels who had quite the racket going in London. Shoutouts to Kristy who suggested this topic (which was loved by the girls!) and Natalie for epic memeing. This episode brings you more pathetic maths, Holly explains the perils of...