Which Murderer?

In Which Murderer’s Episode 48 Season 5 the girls cover Social Media Influencer Murders. Mel starts us off with the subject of a recent Netflix documentary, Caleb McGillvary before Holly recounts the story of an incel named Brandon Andrew Clark. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Also Sarah from Alaska for her lovely message to us on Instagram. In this episode Mel pulls herself together to del...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 47 Season 5 the girls cover Secret Society Murders. Holly starts us off with the history of the The Molly Maguires before Mel covers the recent scandal surrounding NXIVM. Shoutout to Carrie for the suggestion! Or Natalie. It was a rough night. In this episode buckle up for poor overworked Mel’s brain, some pretty great TV recommendations, a podcast recommendations and y...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 46 Season 5 the girls cover the challenging topic Florist Murders. Mel starts us off cheeky with the case of Norman Flowers (see what she did there) before Holly covers the unsolved case of Jacob Bornkamp. Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion! If you have any information regarding the Jacob Bornkamp case please contact Crime Stoppers immediately. In this episode Mel is...

WARNING! THIS EPISODE CONTAINS DETAILS OF CRIMES THAT ARE GRAPHIC AND EXTREMELY DISTURBING. LISTEN WITH CAUTION. In Which Murderer’s Episode 45 Season 5 the girls cover Bodies in Concrete. Holly starts us off with a very recent case in Scotland involving Andrew Innes before Mel retells the tale of poor Junko Furata. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! In this episode the girls come to you from...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 43 Season 5 the girls cover heartbreaking cases of people Murdered in Care. Holly starts us off with wee Marcus Fiesel before Mel goes into the story of Leiland James Corkhill. Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion! In this episode you will hear about old news updates that are now also probably old news, Mel learns that there is fruit that doesn’t come out of tins, a s...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 42 Season 5 the girls cover super awful cases of people Murdered by Gas. Mel starts us off with war criminal Joseph Mengele before Holly goes into the real time case of Genivaldo de Jesus Santo. Shoutout to Ricky who probably doesn’t listen to the podcast, for the suggestion. In this episode you will witness a very rare professional start, Holly has some door dramas the...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger. In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) an...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 40 Season 5 the girls cover Murders Solved with DNA. Mel starts us off with the very sad case of Anna Palmer before Holly goes into the murder by Terrence Miller. Shoutout to Michelle for the suggestion! In this episode there are more challenges to recording such as Mels face and Holly’s knees, you will hear all about Holly’s adorable new animals, TV Recommendations are...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 39 Season 5 the girls cover Grifter Murders. What is a Grifter Murder you ask? You’ll have to listen. Holly starts us off with the retelling of the case of Sante Kimes before Mel goes into the murder by Christian Gerhartsteiter. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! In this episode Mel has to be physically removed from her phone, Holly is murdered by a chair which res...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 38 Season 5 the girls cover Nurses Who Murder. Mel starts us off with the incredibly tragic case of Beverly Allitt before Holly goes into the horrible murders by Niels Högel. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! In this episode Mel is eating candy as per usual, Holly reveals her false teeth plan, you’ll learn more about how Holly’s body defies life and Mel brings out...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 37 Season 5 the girls cover Musical Murders. Holly starts us off with the surprising story of Marvin Gaye Jr. before Mel goes into the famous death of Beatle John Lennon. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! In this episode Holly makes third party baby demands, the podcast gets some lovely feedback from a victim’s daughter, Mel has on purpose chosen a case with a lot...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 36 Season 5 the girls cover Cooking Murders. Mel starts us off with the unbelievably horrific and sad case of Lamora Williams before Holly goes into the tragic death of Elivelton Dias. Shoutout to Saraid for the really interesting suggestion! And also to Natalie for more excellent memes. You are experiencing the 4th recording in a row this episode so buckle up, there ar...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 35 Season 5 the girls cover people who were Murdered on a Plane. Holly starts us off with the grand-daddy of plane murderers Earnest P. Pletch before Mel goes into the Canadian murderer Albert Guay . Shoutout to Cheryl for the great suggestion! Who knew we could be even more afraid of air travel. Mel starts off with some unexpected professionalism followed by a current...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 34 Season 5 the girls cover the important topic of Prejudice Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragic and historically important story of Emmett Till before Holly goes into the ongoing case of the Tree of Life Synagogue shooting. Shoutout to NEW MUMMY Caitlin for the great suggestion! And congrats on your beautiful baby boy. Also shoutouts to Mark and Emma Jo - thanks...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 33 Season 5 the girls cover Grannies Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the story of Tamara Samsonova before Mel goes into the case of Nannie Doss. Shoutout to Cheryl for the great suggestion! In the first recording session of 2023 the girls give you a Christmas recap which largely focuses on sickness - Merry Flu from Holly, Mel passes along some wisdom from her own G...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 32 Season 5 the girls cover Murderers with Weird Names. Mel starts us off with the story of Vaughn Greenwood before Holly goes into the case of Joseph Douglas Ball. Shoutout to Carrie for the great suggestion! This episode Holly makes it clear we are NOT the football podcast, Mel is holding onto a killer map until her dying breath, Holly conducts a stupid-pigeon rescue,...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 31 Season 5 the girls cover Noisy Neighbour Murders. Holly starts us off with the story of Barry Williams before Mel goes into the case of Jamie Crosbie. Shoutout to Kirsty for the great suggestion! The girls gift you with a Mrs. Doubtfire greeting before quickly going into the tales of Holly’s Halloween recap which involved terrible neighbours, time travel once again t...

WARNING - EXPLICIT DESCRIPTIONS OF SEXUAL ASSAULT ARE CONTAINED IN THIS WEEKS EPSIDE. In Which Murderer’s Episode 30 Season 5 the girls cover Beach Murders. Mel starts us off with the Koh Tao Murders before Holly goes into the case of a hero named Khuram Shaikh. Shoutout to OG Listener Jade for the great theme suggestion! Holly kicks you off with some animal stories about possibly killing donkeys...

Happy New Year - and oddly Happy Halloween? In Which Murderer’s Episode 29 Season 5 the girls cover Murderers Who Were Presumed Innocent. Holly starts us off with an incredibly sad and tragic story involving Susan Smith before Mel goes into the case of Carlos de Luna. Shoutout to Cheryl for the great theme suggestion and a fabulous review by Stephanie! The girls compare Trick or Treating methods a...

Merry Christmas to our lovely listeners! We wish you all a very happy holiday season and a joyous new year. In Which Murderer’s Episode 28 Season 5 the girls cover River Murders. Mel starts us off with horrors of the Green River Killer before Holly goes into the monster named Joel David Rifkin. Shoutout to Kristy for the great theme suggestion! Mel begins with being unprepared and slowly sinking i...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 27 Season 5 the girls cover Mistaken Identity Murders. Holly starts us off with the tragic story involving Chad Gordon before Mel goes into the injustice of the conviction of Joyce Ann Brown. Shoutout to Natalie for another great suggestion! Also we require more memes. The new Which Murderer fractions podcast covers off some early Christmas prep, the advice regarding Lo...

In Which Murderer’s Episode 26 Season 5 the girls cover Murdered in Prison. Mel starts us off with the murder story involving Edwin Kaprat before Holly goes into the murder of the Black Movement hero Bantu Stephen Biko. Shoutout to Cheryl for another great suggestion! It’s the halfway episode! The girls have managed to make it halfway through Season 5 and are already planning the Season 6 schedule...

We can't believe we live in Scotland and have yet to cover the Loch Ness Monster, so here it is! This one is actually covered by Marti who was recently up at Loch Ness and inspired to do this ep. We would love to hear your thoughts on our ep and whether you believe in the monster of the deep! Again huge thanks to Erin our amazing podcast editor and a shout out to the Haunted or Hoax podcast featur...

BONUS EPISODE CRIME DRIVERS POD Lee Harvey was murdered in a road rage incident, his fiancee Tracie Andrews claimed they were attacked by two men but the evidence said different. Our contact details are: Instagram & Twitter - crime_divers_pod Email - crime_divers_pod@outlook.com YouTube - CrimeDivers Podcast TikTok - crimediverspodcast If you would like to financially support the show: https://www...