Addison Ledbetter, Jasmine Waples

What Was That??

True Crime EN ↓ 83 episodes

What was that?? A bump in the night? A stranger lurking in the dark? Discover hair-raising stories that make you question everything from your sanity to your safety. Join Jazzy and Addi every week as they explore the most disturbing reddit stories and dive into those macabre subjects you all want to know.

Author

Addison Ledbetter, Jasmine Waples

Episodes

Ep 83: P-E-to the-T-T-Y 24.06.2026 31:49

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are getting petty. Was OP actually totally justified? Or is it something FAR more sinister going on?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like to share y...

Ep 82: Dark Romance ft. Joe Arden 10.06.2026 1:22:45

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi welcome a very special guest, Joe Arden. They’ll dig into the dark side of Dark Romance and figure out, is it just a madly in love man? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouT...

Ep 81: Trust Issues 03.06.2026 53:58

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are diving in to trust issues. Is it really just a misunderstood husband? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like...

Ep 80: The Mortuary Assitants 27.05.2026 41:51

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are taking a look at the career path of Morticians. Is it really just the gasses escaping? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail....

Ep 79: Well...That Was Weird 20.05.2026 42:42

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are getting weird. Is it just a woman who lost her shoes? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com TRIGGER WARNING: Talk of drug...

Ep 78: FONMO (Fear of NOT missing out) 13.05.2026 51:58

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are putting the fear in the fear of missing out. Is it just a misguided booktok man? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If...

Ep 77: Coworker Woes 29.04.2026 49:07

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are putting in overtime with these crazy coworker stories. Is it just an unusually passionate coworker ? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat...

Ep 76: Is this Delusional?? 22.04.2026 52:24

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are asking the hard questions. Is it someone being insanely delusional? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like t...

Ep 75: You Win Sum(mon), You Lose Sum(mon) 15.04.2026 42:11

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are summoning the great beyond. Is it just grandma’s ghost? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like to share your...

Ep 74: Mother in Claws 08.04.2026 1:10:47

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi explore the family dynamics with Mother in Laws. Is it just a concerned mom looking out for her son? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.the...

EP 73: On the Road Again 25.03.2026 45:34

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi prepare for an upcoming road trip with some terrifying travel tales. Is it just branch scraping against the car? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at Wha...

Ep 72: Missed Call 18.03.2026 55:17

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi put the ear against the receiver for some haunted voicemails. Is it just a silly prank? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com...

Ep 71: A Wee Ole Ghost Story 11.03.2026 36:12

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi celebrate Addi’s Irish heritage with a wee ole ghost story? Is it just a gust of wind? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com...

Ep 70: Horrifying Hospitals 04.03.2026 30:33

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are going to the hospital! Is it just a sleep deprived coincidence? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like to sh...

Ep 69: Valentine's Day 11.02.2026 53:49

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are feeling the love this Valentine’s Day, but these Redditors are not so lucky. Is it just a clueless gym bro who had a little too much creatine? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find...

Ep 68: Kids say the Darndest things 04.02.2026 48:34

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi take a moment to check in on the youths. Is it just a kid with a wild imagination? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If y...

Ep 67: Why you so obsessed with me?? 28.01.2026 43:35

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi try to figure out what causes obsessions. Is it just your mom bringing your a nice meal? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.co...

Ep 66: What is Wrong With You?? 21.01.2026 54:44

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi ask hard hitting questions, like "WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU??". Is it just your roommate waking you up from a nap? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email...

Ep 65: Home Alone 14.01.2026 43:30

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi keep each other company so, unlike our redditors, neither of them is home alone. Is it just the breeze on a dark Appalachian night? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube,...

Ep 64: What NOT to do 07.01.2026 49:44

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi ring in the new year by giving listeners a list of what NOT to do. Is it just a bad person? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail...

Ep 63: Slumber Party ft. Katie 17.12.2025 51:35

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi have a sleep over with their lovely guest Katie. Is it just a case of hypnogogia? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.comIf you...

Ep 62: In the Flesh ft. Sarah 10.12.2025 55:56

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are joined by special guest host, Sarah! Sarah has chosen to take a closer look at things that appear in the flesh. Is it just a small bald man? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find u...

Ep 61: Shop Till You Drop 03.12.2025 51:50

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi hit the mall for some holiday shopping. Is it just a faulty alarm? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.comIf you’d like to shar...

Ep 60: Give Thanks 26.11.2025 39:34

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi celebrate Thanksgiving. Is it just a thankful ghost? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at WhatWasThat.thepod@gmail.com If you’d like to share your own st...

Ep 59: Fowl Incidents 19.11.2025 45:08

What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi dive into a series of Fowl Incidents. Is it simply for the birds? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! TRIGGER WARNING: Story three mentions the death of a child Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or ema...