Dawn Lawson Pruszkowski

Unexpected Love Stories | Real Romance & Relationships You Never Saw Coming

Society EN ↓ 36 episodes

Would you buy a wedding dress before a proposal? Have you ever met someone who just knew? Love is unpredictable—it finds us in ways we never expect. On Unexpected Love Stories, real people share how they met, fell in love, and built meaningful relationships. From finding love after loss, to reconnecting decades later, to stories that feel written before they happen—these real love stories will surprise you. Subscribe and discover romance, relationships, and the love stories you never saw coming.

Author

Dawn Lawson Pruszkowski

Category

Society

Podcast website

unexpectedlovestories.com

Latest episode

May 27, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

35 | She Changed. He Got Angry. Their Marriage Nearly Didn’t Survive. | Pasqual & Norma Urrabazo 27.05.2026

He was spiraling deeper into addiction. She had just found faith and her life was beginning to change. Most people would have thought their marriage wouldn’t survive. In this deeply honest episode, Pasqual and Norma Urrabazo share how a relationship that began with love, chaos, and brokenness was transformed through forgiveness, surrender, and the healing power of God. After meeting at a video ren...

34 | He Was Ready to Move Forward. She Wasn’t. | A Second Chance Love Story | Laurel & Ed Nicholson 13.05.2026

Laurel was a single mom who never expected a client seeking help for his aging mother to become the man who would slowly change her heart. Ed, a Grammy-recognized musician, never imagined that the woman offering wisdom, comfort, and guidance would become the person he couldn’t stop thinking about. But with her guarded heart, family concerns, and complicated timing standing between them, their stor...

33 | They Worked Together But Never Met—Until a Missed Hello Almost Cost Them Everything | A Second Chance Love Story of Faith, Healing… and a Star Wars Proposal | John & Rebekah Schafer 29.04.2026

They worked in the same building. Went to the same church. Even connected on Facebook… But one small moment almost ended everything—before it ever began. John was rebuilding his life and faith after a difficult season, while Rebekah was pouring herself into ministry—neither of them looking for love. When John greeted her at work and thought she ignored him, he quietly assumed rejection. And instea...

32 | Do Opposites Really Attract… or Almost Miss Each Other Entirely? From Strong First Impressions to an Unexpected Love Story of Growth, Grace, and a Lasting Marriage That Changed Everything 15.04.2026

At first glance, they didn’t seem like a match at all. She was polished, graceful, and carried herself with quiet confidence. He was straightforward, unfiltered, and completely unapologetic. In this episode of Unexpected Love Stories, Jeff and Kathy Oakes share how two people with completely different personalities—and strong opinions about each other—somehow ended up falling in love. It didn’t st...

31 | He Saw Her Across the Room… But Was About to Go on a Date with Her Best Friend | Faith, Cancer & a Romantic Love Story 01.04.2026

This is a romantic love story about two people whose paths crossed in the most unexpected way. What began as a simple meeting turned into a powerful journey of love, relationships , and faith through life’s hardest moments. Vanessa never expected Las Vegas to become home, and Evan never expected that one glance across a room would change everything. Their story is one of real love stories , unexpe...

30 | A Single Mom Fell at Church-The ER Doctor Who Helped Her Changed Her Life | Dr. Marla Woodmansee’s Love Story 18.03.2026

She fell walking into church… and almost never went back. Marla was a single mom of two, new in town and simply looking for a church to call home. What she didn’t expect was that one painful stumble in the church courtyard would leave her injured… and introduce her to an ER doctor who stepped in to help. And in that moment—an unexpected spark occurred. In fact, it startled her enough that she deci...

29 | Engaged in 1 Month, Married Fast—Then Drifted Quietly: How Josh & Shelly of God’s Goodness Podcast Faced Red Flags, a Misdiagnosis, and Found Healing Through Faith 04.03.2026

They met on Yahoo Personals in 2009. One month later, they were engaged—but fast love doesn’t guarantee deep connection. Josh was serving in the Army Reserves, recovering from the collapse of his second marriage and convinced his “picker” was broken. Shelly saw his profile and paid to upgrade her account just to keep the conversation going. When they finally met, Josh couldn’t shake the feeling th...

28 | They Had a Crush on Each Other for 3 Years, But No One Said a Word. The Mr. Darcy Slow-Burn Love Story of Andrew & Lara Pilcher Began with One Brave Sentence 18.02.2026

They had a crush on each other for three years, but no one said a word. Working side by side in theatre and ministry in Perth, Australia, Andrew and Lara Pilcher quietly admired each other — building productions, sharing faith, and guarding their hearts. Lara’s feelings grew bolder. Andrew’s remained hidden behind steady friendship and restraint. When Lara finally chose courage and told him how sh...

27 | Cheryl McKay Price Wrote the Love Story Before She Met Him… Then It Came True — How the Award-Winning Writer of Never the Bride and Finally the Bride Waited Decades for Real Love 04.02.2026

What happens when the story you wrote about love starts unfolding in real life? Cheryl McKay Price is an award-winning writer and screenwriter, known for Finally the Bride and Never the Bride . For years, she wrote honestly about waiting, surrender, and trusting God with a love story she could not control. What she didn’t expect was how closely her real life would one day mirror what she had writt...

26 | Alexia was intentionally single, waiting for God to reveal her husband, while God kept highlighting Troy—the friend beside her who already saw her as his ideal woman 21.01.2026

Troy and Alexia met in 2020 during the pandemic through country line dancing. For nearly three years, they danced side by side several days a week, building a deep friendship before romance began. Once Troy shared his interest in October 2022, everything moved quickly—courting by November, engaged in December, and married at the courthouse in February 2023. Their marriage began with both joy and c...

25 | He’s from Sweden. She’s from Washington. What Began as Friendship in London Became a Cross-Continental Love Story They Never Saw Coming 07.01.2026

Sam and Sharnessa’s love story begins thousands of miles apart—Sam in Sweden, shaped by military service and a call to ministry, and Sharnessa in Washington State, following a creative path that carried her from New York City to London. In 1998, their worlds collided at the International Bible Institute of London , where friendship slowly deepened into a calling neither could ignore. After graduat...

24 | Christmas Eve Miracles: 4 True Love Stories- a Midnight Call, a Snowy Proposal, a Second Chance for a Widow & a Christmas Eve Wedding That Surprised Everyone 24.12.2025

Grab a cup of hot chocolate, settle into a cozy spot, and join us for a heart-warming Christmas edition of Unexpected Love Stories. This special holiday episode celebrates true-life romances that unfolded at Christmas: stories of love that began on Christmas Eve, surprise engagements under twinkling lights, and even a Christmas Eve wedding that feels straight out of a Hallmark movie. Host Dawn Pru...

23 | They shared a hospital nursery as babies, met again as teens & one night Julie prayed she would marry Brian. A year later, they had their 1st date. A divine love story decades in the making. 10.12.2025

Julie and Brian’s story began long before either of them could imagine it—side-by-side as newborns in the same hospital nursery. Their lives brushed past each other again at sixteen, and once more at twenty for a single unforgettable evening. That night, God woke Julie at 2:30 a.m. with a clear prompting to pray that she would one day marry Brian. A year later, Brian re-entered her life… and this...

22 | She was a single mom of faith; he was a Hollywood actor searching for purpose. When Cameron Arnett called BJ after years apart, God began their love story 26.11.2025

BJ hadn’t found lasting love, but the two men she admired most—her grandfather Clay and her kind-hearted friend Cameron Arnett—showed her her worth and helped lead her to Jesus. Life separated them for years, and when BJ faced an unexpected pregnancy, she chose faith over fear and trusted God completely. She named her son after the two men who had shown her true character and later asked Cameron,...

21 | Disney animator Tom Bancroft helped make The Lion King but proposing to Jen was chaos. High school sweethearts, long-distance love & a bachelor party prank that stopped a plane—this story is wild 12.11.2025

Tom and Jennifer first met their senior year—he and his twin brother ran the high school art club, she was on the drill team. One walk to class turned into every walk to class, and a sweet high school romance began. Jen ended the relationship before heading to college, but shortly after she left, she realized how much she missed Tom. Daily phone calls turned into long-distance dating until she mov...

20 | They were just friends for years—until one snowboarding trip, one movie night, and one unexpected text changed everything 29.10.2025

Josh and Ashley were casual friends for about two and a half years, often hanging out in the same circle but never seeing each other as more than that. One winter, Ashley posted on social media that she wanted to go snowboarding. Josh already had plans to go the next day and invited her to join. On the three-hour drive to the mountains, conversation flowed easily. They discovered how much they had...

19 | She’s from Texas, he’s from the Netherlands—two dreams, one destiny, a love story they never expected. She went abroad to teach dance, but discovered that God was also writing her own love story 15.10.2025

Bethany Sleebos wasn’t looking for love—she was following her lifelong calling to share God’s heart through dance. Born and raised in College Station, Texas, she began dancing at five and went on to teach and perform around the world, using movement as a language of love and hope. In 2007, her journey led her to the Netherlands to serve with Kings Kids, a ministry that equips young people to share...

18 | She whispered, “I just met the man I’m going to marry”, an undeniable connection, a desert deployment in the UAE, a Las Vegas elopement, & a princess wedding, Tucker & Jess’ story is unexpected 01.10.2025

Tucker, raised in Yakima, Washington and now serving as a U.S. Air Force officer, and Jessica, adopted from Russia and raised in Cleveland, Ohio, met during their deployment in the United Arab Emirates. When Jessica saw Tucker without his usual mustache, she suddenly felt nervous butterflies and commented to her friend that she had just met the man she was going to marry. Their connection was inst...

17 | She chased parties and had beauty that turned heads He was only a friend yet prayed for her in secret When she found faith, love surprised them both the most powerful way 17.09.2025

They first met as teenagers working a summer job at Weyerhaeuser. Kim grew up in Longview, Washington, a small town known for its logging and paper mills. The middle of three sisters, she was known for her beauty. She even modeled for local stores and hair stylists. Kim lived the life of a party girl  and, to her, Jeff was just a friendly acquaintance. Jeff felt differently, and he quickly fell in...

16 | After losing her husband of 40 years, Martha found love again. An inspiring story of healing, second chances, love after loss, and new beginnings 20.08.2025

After 40 years of marriage, Martha found herself alone when her beloved husband Bill passed away in March 2020. A pharmacist who had dedicated her career to helping others, Martha’s life had always been filled with purpose and service. Bill, a teacher, coach, and fitness trainer, was her partner in both life and faith. Their home was full of laughter and activity, especially through Bill’s work wi...

15 | She wasn’t looking for love. He couldn’t get her name right. Jon and Emily’s rom-com love story includes a Lifehouse song, a snow scene, and a wedding just hours after graduation. 06.08.2025

Jon first noticed Emily at a college registration table—but struck out when she wouldn’t give him her name. Strike two came months later when he confidently called her “Amanda” during spring break. But everything changed one night on the beach when Jon pulled out his guitar and sang “You and Me” by Lifehouse—Emily’s favorite band. Their eyes met, and something sparked. Back on campus, they fell in...

14 | Deb didn’t want to date Greg. Then they both had the same dream on the same night. 3 months later they were engaged. 3 months after that, married and off across the world 23.07.2025

Debby wasn’t looking for love. She was a high school senior about to turn 18, and dating was the last thing on her mind, especially not with a guy in his early 20s. But on Debby’s birthday, a well-meaning friend had 23-year old Greg take her and Debby to a concert. Her friend thought Greg and Debby made a great match, Debby just wanted to hide. Things got interesting fast. Shortly after their awkw...

13 | Award-winning romance novelist Diane Merrill Wigginton went to one singles dance and met her husband while he was wingmanning for another guy. What unfolded could’ve been one of her own novels. 09.07.2025

After a decade of healing from a painful divorce, award-winning romance novelist, Diane Merrill Wigginton, felt a strong nudge to attend a New Year’s Eve singles dance… the first and only one she’d ever go to. She didn’t know why, but she went. That night, David showed up, not to find love, but as a wingman for his friend, who had hoped to meet Diane. But when David saw her, something shifted. He...

12 | They fell in love at first grocery cart. From long-distance calls to fireworks & magic tricks—Dusty & Rae’s unexpected love story proves God writes the best plot twists. 25.06.2025

Rae was 31, single, and settled in Iowa. As a functional nutritional therapy practitioner, she had finally gotten crystal clear on the kind of man she hoped to marry: someone with unwavering character, a solid Christian faith, a shared passion for healthy living, and—just as essential—a deep appreciation for good coffee. Dusty, on the other hand, was living in sunny Southern California. A chiropra...

11 | Aury face-planted on stage. Tymme had to meet her. These pro dancers, who worked with huge stars like Madonna & Will Smith, became best friends and never expected they would have a love story 11.06.2025

Tymme, a rising star in the hip hop dance world, had just finished his performance at a choreographer’s showcase and took a seat in the audience. As a tribal funk dance piece unfolded, one of the dancers tripped—face first—right on stage. But instead of retreating in embarrassment, she sprang up, unleashed a wild tribal yell, and danced with even more fire than before. Tymme was captivated. “I’ve...

Listen to the Unexpected Love Stories | Real Romance & Relationships You Never Saw Coming podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.