Tyler Esselman and Michael Osinski
This One Goes to 11
Are you searching for some amazing music, but you can't bear to sift through all those elitist-sounding music reviews out there? Join theatre artists and music enthusiasts Michael and Tyler on their quest to find the perfect album. Each week they invite a guest (or two) to share stories about the music that made them who they are AND to suggest what THEY believe is the perfect album. An album so brilliant that "10 out of 10" just doesn't do it justice.
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.thisonegoesto11podcast.com
Author
Tyler Esselman and Michael Osinski
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Nov 17, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Introducing The Colton Collection 18.11.2025 5:25
Tyler here. Catching our breath before our Season 9 finale! I'm checking in this week and introducing you to a new ongoing project I'm undertaking - The Colton Collection. My sister Lauren (our guest in Ep 106) and her husband Casey recently welcomed their first child into the world and, let me tell ya, this kid's simply the best. Our family is having a ball loving on young Colton and...
Ep 110: Jamar Gilbert Nominates “Lupe Fiasco’s The Cool” 11.11.2025 56:08
We’ve got school spirit, yes we do, we’ve got spirit, and so does Jamar Gilbert! That’s right, another old school chum joins us this week on the pod and we couldn’t be happier about it. Jamar is an artist of the highest order, a truly gifted actor, and a simply lovely human being in general. I hope each and every one of you gets the pleasure of getting to know this guy at a party some day. He’s th...
Ep 109: Josh Tyson Nominates Neutral Milk Hotel's "In The Aeroplane Over the Sea" 04.11.2025 58:01
What a beautiful face we have found in this place - it's Josh Tyson's face, specifically! Josh is an actor and sometime musician based in NYC and he has joined us in all his effervescent glory this week to make his case for one of the ultimate nerdy white guy albums: Neutral Milk Hotel's In The Aeroplane Over the Sea. In The Aeroplane... , with its jangling guitar, warbling vocals from...
Ep 108: Michael Osinski Nominates Zero 7's "Simple Things" (with guest host Matt Risby) 28.10.2025 1:02:12
It’s Scorpio season, and all Michael wanted for his birthday this year was the chance to nominate another album to join the pantheon. Well who are we to deny people their wishes? Especially in this economy. So this week Michael is nominating a downtempo classic from the early aughts - “Simple Things” by Zero 7 - and we’ve enlisted former guest and TTRPG enthusiast, The Bad Spot's own Matt Risb...
Ep 107: Rich Hammond Nominates Elbow's "Asleep in the Back" 21.10.2025 59:37
Don’t tell our moms, but we’ve got another stranger on the pod. (And a foreigner no less.) This week we’re talking to Rich Hammond - musician, mental health advocate, and author of the blog Record Reconstructor - about a shoegazey little gem from the early aughts: “Asleep in the Back” by the UK band Elbow. So it was really just an excuse for us to talk about ALL the amazing music coming out of the...
Ep 106: Lauren Robinson Nominates Noah Kahan's "Stick Season (Forever)" 14.10.2025 1:01:20
The leaves are fallin', the pumpkins are spicin', and we can't think of a better way to celebrate autumn than to finally welcome the one and only Lauren Robinson onto the pod! That's right, Tyler's one and only sister has brought us a little taste of the Northeast with Noah Kahan's megahit album "Stick Season (Forever)". We dive into Lauren's emo roots, her de...
Ep 105: Paul Oakley Stovall Nominates Sade's "Promise" 07.10.2025 59:32
You might say this week’s guest is one smooth operator. We’re talking to the ridiculously talented actor and playwright Paul Oakley Stovall. He’s taking us all the way back to the early days of VH1 with the second album from Sade, Promise . And before you start relegating this music to the aisles of CVS or to those late-night smooth jazz radio stations, you better listen to what Paul has to say. H...
Ep 104: Marcy Barbeau Nominates J Balvin's "Vibras" 30.09.2025 59:19
This week's episode is alllllll vibes, baby! Like, it actually is all about "Vibras" by J Balvin. So it is LITERALLY all vibes. I'm not kidding. We welcome Tyler's dear friend Marcy Barbeau onto the pod this week to tell us exactly how and when to implement "Vibras", because she's an expert. Marcy and Tyler got their starts in the theatre together in high school...
Ep 103: Kerstin Vaughn Nominates Hozier's "Hozier" 23.09.2025 55:43
Brush up your Irish brogues, y'all. This week Kerstin Vaughn is taking us to church as she makes a case for the 2014 eponymous debut album from Hozier. It's an album that may have caused her to wrestle with her Christian upbringing, and to that we say, "Welcome to group!" She talks about her family's eclectic listening habits, her transition from band geek to theatre geek, an...
Ep 102: Aaron Aptaker Nominates Ben Folds Five's "Ben Folds Five" 16.09.2025 1:00:09
Go ahead, you can laugh all you want. We were never cool in school, but we sure as hell hope you remember us. We are back, booked, blessed, and in the same room together for our first episode of season 9! And we're talking with OUR favorite piano man - Aaron Aptaker - about HIS favorite piano man and the eponymous debut album from Ben Folds Five. (Which might not really be an eponymous album,...
THIS ONE GOES TO 11 Season 9 Trailer 09.09.2025 0:39
Get your earholes AND your eyeballs ready! We're doing video all season long. Starting September 16th. Theme music composed by Damien Figueras . Got a question, comment, or suggestion? E-mail us at thisonegoesto11podcast@gmail.com . Follow us on Face...
Tyler Looks Back on 100 Episodes 13.05.2025 32:55
One more look back (but certainly not in anger) before we officially break for the summer! This week, Tyler shares a bit of what he loved most about the first 100 episodes, presents some curated back catalog clips, and calls out the albums he thinks you need to listen to right now. Cheers to y'all once again, thanks so much for listening. Onward and upward, I say. You can also find this episod...
Michael Looks Back on 100 Episodes 29.04.2025 33:27
Before we go on hiatus for the summer, we're each looking back on the first 100 episodes. This week it's Michael's turn, and he's taking you on a walking tour of Canton, New York, as he remembers some of his favorite moments on the podcast. Also, and this is totally unrelated, did you know he likes Pearl Jam? You can also find this episode on our YouTube channel...
Ep 101: Michael & Tyler Nominate Queens of the Stone Age's "Songs for the Deaf" (with Ashlyn Lozano) 15.04.2025 50:15
In Part 2 of the celebration of our 100th episode, we get up to more hijinks with our buddy Ashlyn Lozano! We look to the future and discuss our vision of where we’d like to go next with the pod. There might also be some mention of a few of our dream guests?? And we officially, jointly nominate Queens of the Stone Age’s “Songs for the Deaf” for inclusion in the pantheon. Ash is a loyal listener an...
Ep 100: Part 1 of Our 100th Episode Extravaganza with Ashlyn Lozano 08.04.2025 1:14:36
Man, it’s a milestone day! 100 freaking episodes. Time really has flown since we started chatting music with y’all. We’ve loved every minute so far. As such, we are marking the occasion with our very first VIDEO EPISODE. Your boys are catching up with the times. I’m no Thelma Schoonmaker so goodness knows the video editing will be a little rough around the edges. But fear not, I intend to sharpen...
Ep 99: DJ Jeff Tammy Nominates “Buzz Ballads Vol. 1” 01.04.2025 39:04
On this week’s very special episode of This One Goes to 11, Michael and Tyler welcome DJ Jeff Tammy into the virtual living room. You do not want to miss this one. This episode also comes as a playlist on our YouTube channel . Theme music composed by Damien Figueras...
Ep 98: Madelaine Strickland Nominates "Lempicka (Original Broadway Cast Recording)" 25.03.2025 54:11
We just couldn't make it to episode 100 without covering one more musical. We're theatre boys, after all. So we invited Mike's dear college friend Madelaine Strickland to make a case for the soundtrack to a very contemporary musical - Lempicka by Carson Kreitzer and Matt Gould. Never heard of it? Not surprised. It didn't last 2 months on Broadway. But Madelaine thinks it deserved b...
Ep 97: Tim Fawkes Nominates Sarah McLachlan's "Fumbling Towards Ecstasy" 18.03.2025 58:59
We've been covering quite a few female artists this season, but finally, at long last, we have arrived at the Queen of Lilith Fair herself - Sarah McLachlan - and her early 90s masterpiece "Fumbling Towards Ecstasy." (Which is NOT the one with the song that plays in all those commercials with the neglected puppies.) Our guest? Arguably better than ice cream. It's Chicago-based mu...
1 That Got Away: Tame Impala's "The Slow Rush" (with Mars Wolfe) 14.03.2025 17:42
We're back with some bonus content. This time we're talking with Mars Wolfe about the album that kicked off the pandemic for so many music enthusiasts out there - "The Slow Rush" by Tame Impala. Theme music composed by Damien Figueras . Got a question, comment, or suggestion? E-mail us at thisonegoesto11podcast@gmail.com...
Ep 96: Mars Wolfe Nominates Solange’s “A Seat at the Table” 11.03.2025 51:59
Well hello there, ya made it back for another edition of This One Goes to 11, did ya? We’re darn glad ya did. We quite enjoy making this piece of podcasting for you. It’s a good thing in my life. This is Tyler, btw! Michael and I split up editing duties and I edited Mars’s episode. (Michael’s better at editing than I am, for surrrre. I’m not mad about it! He's a wizard.) But I digress. MARS WO...
Ep 95: Julianne Lang Nominates The Chicks' "Wide Open Spaces" 04.03.2025 59:19
It took us 95 episodes, but at long last, we're tackling a country album. Or are we? Who cares, y'all? Because we've got the Spotify-proclaimed dancing queen herself - the hilarious Julianne Lang - and she's here to talk about The Chicks' "Wide Open Spaces." She's also here to deliver a stirring rendition of the bridge of her standout track, to tell you the correc...
1 That Got Away: Chappell Roan's "The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess" (with Krissy Vanderwarker) 28.02.2025 16:11
Our newest segment is back! This week Krissy Vanderwarker has a thing or two to say about the deliciously queer cotton candy of Chappell Roan's "The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess." Theme music composed by Damien Figueras . Got a question, comment, or suggestion? E-mail us at thisonegoesto11podcast@gmail.com...
Ep 94: Krissy Vanderwarker Nominates Fiona Apple’s “Tidal” 25.02.2025 51:17
When I tell people about this podcast, there are some names that just keep coming up when people say “Oh cool, has anyone talked about XYZ??” And the artist we’re talking about this week is one of our MOST requested. Yep, that’s right we’re finally talking about the one and only Fiona Apple and her stunning debut album “Tidal”! And who, you might ask, is taking up the task of arguing this album’s...
Ep 93: Tim Giles Nominates Haim's "Days Are Gone" 18.02.2025 1:00:21
It felt right to bring another member of the Cherubs family onto the pod this season, so we invited multi-hyphenate theatre artist Tim Giles to make a case for Haim's debut album - Days Are Gone - to join the pantheon. He talks about meeting this album around the same time he met his wife, blaring this album through car speakers in the summer, and embracing this album's 80s pop sound. He a...
1 That Got Away: LCD Soundsystem's "Sound of Silver" (with Nate Simpson) 14.02.2025 17:45
SURPRISE! We've got something new for you. It's our newest special segment - 1 That Got Away - where we give one of our guests the chance to make a case for one of the other albums on their list. This week our buddy Nate Simpson sleazes things up with LCD Soundsystem's "Sound of Silver" - an album so good that it closed out his wedding. Theme music composed by ...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.