They Remade It: The Movie Comparison Podcast

In another episode where Stuart almost wasn't able to obtain a copy of one of the films to be discussed, the duo talk about a couple of films based on the short story and stage play of the same name. If that does ring a bell, how about the classic Germanic tale of Faust. No? Ok, maybe the episode of The Simpson's where Homer goes to hell? Ok, now you get it. Well, two movies with that basic premis...

It's pretty much impossible to escape Disney's pull, as the company not only has acquired plenty of franchises to remake, reboot, and sequelize, but they've done it with their own content plenty over the past fifty years. So, Stuart and Jacob take a look at Tron and it's sequel that no one had really been expecting, Tron: Legacy. Both of these films are fairly infamous when you consider the money...

This time around Stuart and Jacob are tackling a suggested episode. At least for the concept, they ended up picking the two versions of the film to watch. There are a lot of adaptations of the original Brewster's Millions source material, including a film older than the 1945 one being discussed today (although unfortunately that is considered to be lost). What isn't lost however is the willingness...

Did you know that Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds is a remake? Well, technically it isn't and is more so just a borrowed title, but both films have Nazis and that sure is something. Is there any possible way that the 1978 film with the original correctly spelled title of Inglorious Bastards can live up to something created by a director both Stuart and Jacob admire? We'll have to see what exactly...

It's official, the lockdown has driven both Stuart and Jacob so mad that, even with all their perceived downtime, they barely watched anything between this and the last episode. Its okay though, as they both have been dying to talk about these two movies from a franchise whose games they are only familiar with in the loosest sense of the words. How do they compare to one another and does the origi...

At Stuart's request, the duo return to another series of heist films nearly two years after their original look at the Ocean's Eleven films. And what a return to this form, as one film has the presence of Sir Michael Caine and the other has a variety of name actors in its own right. Tons of stunt driving and gold pilfering abound in this episode. This episode contains talks on a series all about D...

To compensate for the headache that was editing Hellboy (thank Jacob and his hellish audio), this podcast comes a bit sooner than usual. After this its back to the routine schedule! Jacob is always looking for an excuse to talk about Japanese animated films, but the remakes are much scarcer under that criteria. Boy did he stumble across the motherload today, as the duo talk about a German piece th...

Firstly, let it be known that this one was delayed so that Jacob could fix his audio to the best of his ability as his microphone broke down on him (and in the middle of a quarantine, no less). There is an echo as well later on in the episode but it fades after some time, apologies for the inconvenience. All that aside, the boys are tackling a more recent movie, one that came out just last year in...

The boys are tackling two films with all-star casts this time around (debatable in regards to the latter), and Stuart and Jacob need to decide whether that means a film is inherently good or not. Chances are, that answer will be no. Also be known that in this episode we have the longest Full Circle to date, so be prepared for that! This episode contains Sonic talk, discussion on the disappearance...

In what is officially the fourth Disney Animated Masterpiece being covered on this very podcast, Stuart and Jacob look at 1991 Best Picture nominee Beauty and the Beast and its 2017 remake of the same name. Does the reputation of the terrible live-action remake ring true with one of Disney's most beloved classics? The boys are gonna find out! This episode contains a brief discussion on the Oscars...

It's season 3, and it's starting off right with laughs and japes as the duo discuss the first Muppet film and compare it to the franchise's big comeback in 2011. And with the episode comes the perfect test case, as Stuart has little to no prior knowledge of the history of the characters before this. Well, besides Muppet Christmas Carol, and really who doesn't love that film? This episode has discu...

Another year comes to a close, and the duo are attempting to look back fondly on this previous decade. Well, not necessarily in the episode as that is primarily focused on 2019, but they are being positive. And why wouldn't they? 2019 marked new jobs for the both of them and a big move for Stuart! Throughout the course of this longer than average episode, Stuart and Jacob discuss varying aspects o...

Due to a rendering issue that pushed the release of this episode back two days, this episode is releasing a little late. But better late than never as some schmuck once said. Neither Stuart nor Jacob had seen any of the Godfather movies in full up to this point, and they decided to rectify that! This, of course, is to varying results. What can be said about these films that hasn't already been sai...

Closing out the month of October, or perhaps the beginning of November, is another horror/thriller film that had Stuart and Jacob pleasantly surprised. Whereas last year they only got to do one "Halloween movie", this time around they get to tackle a second. And of course it had to be on a film that has both Atticus Finch himself AND the irreplaceable David Warner. Though, both boys agree that may...

The boys get back to another horror film, harking back to last year's Halloween horror fest. We'll bet Jacob is beyond pleased. Frankenstein and Young Frankenstein were both classics and pioneers in their own right, just for different genres. And this time around, Stuart and Jacob compare these two cinematic staples to the best of their abilities. Which, to be fair, doesn't say a whole lot. This e...

Not since The Little Shop of Horrors episode have we had a full musical to talk about. Let alone two of them! Not many remember (or know for that matter) about the Disney helmed 2003 remake of The Music Man, let alone that Matthew Broderick was in the starring role. However, Jacob and Stuart do! Somehow. This episode also has (surprise!) more musical talk, another actor related to The Andy Griffit...

The duo gets back to science fiction as they talk about both of these moral-laden pictures. Will the original's ironically more down-to-earth themes overshadow its successor? Or will Keanu Reeves steal the show in what is arguably a more thrilling adaptation? As always, only one real way to find out! This episode also contains talk on both of the Netflix Nickelodeon specials, discussion on delight...

After years of talking about Jerry Lewis off the air, Stuart and Jacob finally sit down and get the chance to discuss one film he was in, and the same film produced by him and starring Eddie Murphy. Which film do they find funnier, or do they even find either funny at all? Only one way to find out! This episode also contains discussion on the new Lion King remake, insult comics, gross-out humor in...

Many have been talking about why it is that Spider-Man has received so many remakes in the past two decades, but is this really the question that should be being asked? Stuart and Jacob are going to attempt to find out! Even if it means coming up with some less-than-popular opinions along the way. This episode also contains talks on Toy Story 4, Willem Dafoe's scenery chewing, some thoughts from t...

Well, they've finally done it. It seems that Stuart and Jacob are finally looking at a film that could very well be objectively poorly made. Of course, when compared to a film with such esteem as The Secret of NIMH, its a wonder that a sequel so long after the fact was even attempted in the first place. Regardless, find out their qualms with not just the sequel, but also the original feature! This...

Something a little different this time around as Stuart and Jacob ask each other some questions in order to properly display their thought process and beliefs regarding movies, actors/actresses, and viewing habits. Normal episodes will still be coming out at the regular rate, this is just a little in between that was done. Enjoy! ---------- Socials ---------- @ItRemade on Twitter @theyremadeit on...

Fall down the rabbit hole into Wonderland (or Underland) as Stuart and Jacob take a look at the two Disney adaptations of the timeless classic, Alice in Wonderland. Does the animated version hold up at all in this day and age? Does the Tim Burton adaptation deserve the flack it's been getting in recent years? These two certainly don't have the answers, but they'll stumble their way through it anyw...

Taking on a German film with the impeccable Peter Lorre is one thing, but what about comparing it to a remake that seemingly no one knows or cares about? Now that would be something, and this week that is exactly what is covered in both versions of M. How does America handle taking on Fritz Lang's magnum opus (his words)? Press play and find out! This episode also contains discussion on Endgame an...

Back to anime! Well, on one account. The other film being discussed is a raucous family comedy from the 90's starring John Goodman (and no, it isn't "Mouse Hunt". John Goodman isn't in "Mouse Hunt"). We couldn't have two films more opposite this time around, with one being low and meditative and the other screaming in your face every 5 minutes. This episode also contains the discussion of the new...

For the first time in the short history of the show, one of the films Stuart and Jacob are talking about is a silent picture! Is it effective in it's storytelling? Or is it beaten out by it's much more talkative remake from 16 years after the fact. Tune in to find out! This episode also contains the discussion on the benefits of silent cinema, flat-earth culture, blue-screening vs green-screening,...